Stories are weirdly obsessed with three-way dynamics. Honestly, we’ve spent centuries trying to figure out why a single protagonist and a single antagonist just don't feel like enough sometimes. You've seen it everywhere. The "hero the demon and the villain" structure is basically the DNA of high-stakes drama, but people get the roles confused all the time.
It’s not just a triangle. It’s a messy, volatile chemical reaction.
Think about it. The hero is the one we’re supposed to root for, the "good" guy. Then you have the villain—the person with a plan, the one driving the plot forward through sheer force of will or malice. But the demon? That’s the wild card. The demon is the internal or external force of pure destruction that doesn't care about "plans" or "morals." When you put the hero the demon and the villain in the same room, things get complicated fast.
The Difference Between a Villain and a Demon
Most people think a villain and a demon are the same thing. They aren't. Not even close.
A villain is a person. They have a mortgage, or a grudge, or a twisted vision for how the world should look. Think of someone like Magneto from X-Men. He’s the villain, sure, but he has a point. He has a philosophy. You can argue with a villain. You can even, occasionally, win them over to your side because they operate on some level of human logic.
The demon is different. In the context of storytelling, the "demon" is often a representation of primal chaos. It might be a literal monster, like the Xenomorph in Alien, or it might be a metaphorical one, like Joker in The Dark Knight—someone who just wants to see the world burn.
Demons don't want power. They want erasure.
When a story uses the hero the demon and the villain together, the villain often finds themselves in a terrifying position: they realize they've unleashed something they can't control. It’s the classic Frankenstein mistake. The villain builds the demon, thinking it will help them defeat the hero, only to realize the demon doesn't take orders.
✨ Don't miss: Why La Mera Mera Radio is Actually Dominating Local Airwaves Right Now
Why the Hero Always Ends Up Caught in the Middle
Being the hero in this scenario sucks.
You aren't just fighting "evil." You're fighting two different types of it. The hero usually starts by trying to stop the villain's grand plan. But then the demon enters the fray, and suddenly, the hero has to decide if they should team up with their worst enemy to stop a literal apocalypse.
It’s a trope because it works. It forces the hero to compromise their morals.
Look at Berserk by Kentaro Miura. You have Guts (the hero/anti-hero), Griffith (the villain), and the literal demons of the God Hand. The interplay between Guts's human rage and Griffith's cold, calculated ambition creates a friction that has kept readers hooked for decades. The "demon" element there—the Eclipse—is what shifts the story from a standard medieval war drama into a cosmic horror nightmare.
The Psychological Pull of the Trio
Why do we keep coming back to this?
Maybe because it mirrors our own brains. Psychologically, you could map this onto the Freudian id, ego, and superego if you really wanted to get academic about it.
- The Hero (Ego): Trying to navigate reality and do the "right" thing.
- The Villain (Superego - Distorted): The rigid, often cold logic of "how things should be."
- The Demon (Id): Raw, unfiltered desire and destruction.
When these three forces clash, it feels "right" to us because it's how we feel inside when we're making a hard decision. We have the part of us that wants to follow the rules, the part that wants to win at any cost, and the part that just wants to break everything and scream.
🔗 Read more: Why Love Island Season 7 Episode 23 Still Feels Like a Fever Dream
Real-World Examples of the Hero the Demon and the Villain
If you look at the 1995 film Heat, you can see a grounded version of this. Neil McCauley (De Niro) is the professional "villain"—he’s a criminal, but he has a code. Vincent Hanna (Pacino) is the hero trying to stop him. But Waingro? Waingro is the demon. He’s the chaotic, murderous element that ruins McCauley’s clean heist and forces the hero and villain into a final, fatal collision.
Without the demon, the hero and the villain might have just played a high-stakes game of cat and mouse forever. The demon is the catalyst. It’s the thing that makes the situation "unsustainable."
In gaming, the Doom franchise handles this with a sledgehammer. The Doom Slayer is the hero (mostly), the UAC corporate leaders are the villains trying to "harness" hell for profit, and the demons are... well, they’re demons. The corporate villain thinks they can control the demon for the "greater good" (or just money), and the hero has to clean up the mess when that hubris inevitably fails.
Misconceptions About the "Demon" Role
One big mistake writers make is making the demon too human.
The moment the demon starts giving long speeches about their childhood trauma, they stop being a demon and start being a second villain. That’s fine for some stories, but it loses that specific "hero the demon and the villain" tension. To keep the dynamic alive, the demon has to remain somewhat unknowable. They represent the "other."
If the hero and villain represent different ways to live, the demon represents death.
How to Spot This Pattern in Modern Media
You’ll start seeing this everywhere once you look for it.
💡 You might also like: When Was Kai Cenat Born? What You Didn't Know About His Early Life
- The Inciting Incident: Usually, the villain does something "smart" that accidentally invites the demon in.
- The Uneasy Truce: The hero and villain have a "the enemy of my enemy" moment.
- The Sacrifice: Someone—usually the villain or a secondary hero—has to be consumed by the demon to stop it.
It’s a cycle.
In Stranger Things, you have the kids (heroes), the government scientists (villains), and the Upside Down/Demogorgon (demon). The scientists think they can study the portal. They think they can weaponize it. They are wrong. They are always wrong.
Actionable Insights for Storytellers and Fans
If you're writing a story or just trying to analyze one, pay attention to the "Agency" of each character.
- The Villain has Agency and a Goal. They want to change the world.
- The Hero has Agency and a Responsibility. They want to protect the world.
- The Demon has Agency but no "Human" Goal. They want to consume the world.
To make this work in your own analysis or writing, ensure the demon is a threat to the villain as much as the hero. If the villain is perfectly safe from the demon, the stakes aren't high enough. The villain's fear of the demon they created or summoned is what gives the story its weight.
Next time you’re watching a movie or playing a game, ask yourself: who’s the person with the plan, and who’s the monster that’s going to eat that plan?
How to leverage this dynamic:
- Identify the "Demon" in your favorite series. Is it a person, a force of nature, or an internal struggle?
- Watch for the "Villain's Regret." This is the specific moment the villain realizes the demon is worse than the hero.
- Note the hero's breaking point. When does the hero realize they can't stay "pure" while fighting a demon?
The best stories don't just give us a guy in a white hat and a guy in a black hat. They give us a guy in a white hat, a guy in a black hat, and a storm that doesn't care about hats at all.