The search is on. If you walk past MetLife Stadium right now, you can almost feel the nervous energy radiating from the executive offices. It’s January 2026, and the hunt for the next head coach of the New York Giants has officially reached a fever pitch.
This isn't just another coaching search. Honestly, it feels like a turning point for a franchise that has been stuck in a revolving door of "next big things" that never actually became big. After Brian Daboll was relieved of his duties on November 10, 2025, following a crushing loss to the Chicago Bears that left the team at a miserable 2-8, the Giants are once again at a crossroads.
Why the Brian Daboll Era Collapsed
It’s wild to think that just a few years ago, Daboll was the toast of the town. He was the 2022 NFL Coach of the Year. He took a roster that looked like a rebuilding project and squeezed a playoff win out of it.
But football is a "what have you done for me lately" business.
Daboll finished his tenure with a record of 20-40-1. That is the fifth-worst winning percentage in the history of the Giants. Think about that for a second. This is an organization that has been around since 1925. To be in the bottom five is a tough pill to swallow.
The wheels really started coming off in 2024 when Malik Nabers, the bright spot of the offense, went down with a season-ending knee injury. By the time 2025 rolled around, the Giants were starting rookie Jaxson Dart at quarterback. While Dart showed flashes of being "the guy"—throwing for over 2,200 yards and rushing for nearly 500—the team just couldn't close out games. They were blowing late leads like it was their job.
John Mara and Steve Tisch decided they had seen enough. They kept General Manager Joe Schoen, which was a move that surprised a lot of people, but they cut ties with Daboll.
The State of the Head Coach of the New York Giants Search
Right now, Mike Kafka is the name on the door, at least in an interim capacity. Kafka stepped in after Daboll’s firing and went 2-5 down the stretch. He's actually interviewed for the permanent role, but the Giants are casting a wide net.
💡 You might also like: NFL Pick 'em Predictions: Why You're Probably Overthinking the Divisional Round
They aren't just looking for a coach; they're looking for a savior.
Joe Schoen is leading the search, and he's been busy. The list of people who have sat down in those fancy leather chairs in East Rutherford is long. We’re talking about a mix of seasoned veterans and rising stars.
The Big Names on the Radar
- Kevin Stefanski: The former Browns coach is perhaps the most intriguing name. He’s already completed an in-person interview. He’s got the experience, and he knows how to handle a high-pressure environment.
- Mike McCarthy: Fresh off his stint with the Cowboys, McCarthy is a proven winner who sat out the 2025 season. He’s got a Super Bowl ring. In New York, that carries a lot of weight.
- John Harbaugh: This is the one that has fans buzzing. The former Ravens coach is expected to meet with the team this week. If the Giants could land a guy like Harbaugh, it would instantly change the culture of the locker room.
- The Wildcards: You’ve got guys like Raheem Morris, Antonio Pierce (who Giants fans remember fondly from his playing days), and Klint Kubiak. Even Jesse Minter, the Chargers' defensive coordinator, is being discussed because of the way he turned that defense into a brick wall.
What Most People Get Wrong About This Job
There’s a common misconception that the Giants' head coaching job is a poisoned chalice. People look at the last decade and see failure after failure—Ben McAdoo, Pat Shurmur, Joe Judge, Brian Daboll.
But here’s the reality: the roster isn't as bad as the record suggests.
Jaxson Dart is a legitimate talent. Abdul Carter, the rookie defender they picked up in 2025, looked like a monster toward the end of the year. If Malik Nabers comes back healthy, you suddenly have an offense that can actually move the chains.
The next head coach of the New York Giants isn't inheriting a "tear it down to the studs" project. They’re inheriting a team that needs a leader who can actually finish a game in the fourth quarter.
The Giants Strategy for 2026
Schoen has been very clear about what he's looking for. He wants leadership, football acumen, and someone who can develop players.
📖 Related: Why the Marlins Won World Series Titles Twice and Then Disappeared
Basically, he wants a grown-up in the room.
The Giants have the No. 5 pick in the 2026 NFL Draft. That is a massive asset. Whether the new coach wants to bolster the offensive line or add another weapon for Dart, they have the capital to do it.
The interesting part of all this is the "Daboll factor." Despite being fired, Daboll has reportedly been a class act. He’s even put in a good word for the organization to some of the candidates. He clearly believes in Jaxson Dart, even if he didn't get the chance to see the kid through to his second season.
What Really Happened Behind the Scenes?
If you talk to people close to the building, the issue wasn't just the losses. It was the "vibes."
The Giants used to be the gold standard for stability. Under Tom Coughlin, you knew what you were getting every day. Lately, it’s felt chaotic. The whole "staged suit and empty briefcase" entrance Daboll had when he first arrived? It was funny at the time. A few years later, it felt like a metaphor for a tenure that had a lot of style but lacked the substance to sustain a winning culture in the toughest media market in the world.
Why the Next Hire Still Matters (A Lot)
The NFC East is a brutal division. You’ve got the Eagles and the Cowboys constantly reloading. If the Giants don't get this hire right, they risk becoming the "old New York Jets"—a team that is perpetually "three years away" from being relevant.
Ownership knows this. John Mara and Steve Tisch said as much in their joint statement when they let Daboll go. They apologized to the fans. They admitted the results haven't lived up to the standard of the organization.
👉 See also: Why Funny Fantasy Football Names Actually Win Leagues
The search for the next head coach of the New York Giants is more than just a hiring process. It's an attempt to reclaim the identity of one of the NFL's flagship franchises.
Actionable Insights for the Future
If you're a Giants fan or just a student of the game, here is what you need to watch for in the coming weeks:
- The Harbaugh Watch: If John Harbaugh leaves the interview without a deal, it might mean he’s looking elsewhere, or the Giants are leaning toward a younger candidate like Klint Kubiak.
- The Defensive Shift: Watch if the Giants hire a defensive-minded coach like Jesse Minter. This would signal a major shift in philosophy after years of trying to fix the offense first.
- The Staff Retention: See if the new coach keeps any of the current staff. Mike Kafka is interviewing for offensive coordinator jobs elsewhere (like with the Bucs and Lions), so a total housecleaning is likely.
- The Draft Focus: The No. 5 pick will tell you everything you need to know about the new coach's priorities. Do they go with a tackle to protect Dart, or a defensive end to pair with Abdul Carter?
The next few weeks will define the next decade for Big Blue. The search for the head coach of the New York Giants is the only thing that matters in the Meadowlands right now.
Keep an eye on the official team trackers and local beat writers. The announcement usually comes fast once they find their guy. And whoever it is, they better be ready for the brightest lights in the league.
Next Steps for the Giants Front Office:
- Finalize the Shortlist: Complete the second round of in-person interviews with McCarthy, Harbaugh, and Stefanski by January 20th.
- Contract Negotiations: Ensure the new hire has full control over their coordinator selections to avoid the "forced marriage" coaching staffs that have plagued the team in the past.
- Draft Alignment: Hold immediate meetings between the new head coach and Joe Schoen to align on the evaluation of the No. 5 overall pick.
The Giants are at a fork in the road. One path leads back to the playoffs; the other leads to more years of "what if." The decision on the next head coach of the New York Giants will determine which one they take.