The movie was terrifying. Most people remember the silver screen version of the haunting of Connecticut true story—the scene with the eyelids, the toes, the heavy sense of dread permeating a picturesque New England home. But Hollywood has a habit of dressing up the truth in expensive CGI.
The real events that took place at 208 Meriden Avenue in Southington, Connecticut, during the late 1980s are actually much stranger than the film. And honestly? They’re a bit more controversial too.
If you’re looking for a simple ghost story, this isn't it. This is a messy, complicated saga involving a desperate family, a house with a dark history, and the most famous paranormal investigators in American history: Ed and Lorraine Warren.
The Snedeker Family’s Nightmare Begins
In 1986, Allen and Carmen Snedeker were just trying to survive. Their eldest son, Philip, was battling Hodgkin’s lymphoma. The commute to UConn Health Center in Farmington was draining their resources and their energy. They needed to be closer to the hospital.
They found a spacious, surprisingly affordable rental in Southington. It seemed like a godsend.
It wasn't.
They moved in and quickly realized why the rent was so low. While exploring the basement, they discovered a graveyard of sorts. Not a literal cemetery in the backyard, but the tools of the trade. Embalming tables. Toe tags. Sinks with blood drains.
The house had been the Hallahan Funeral Home.
"The landlord never told us," Carmen later told reporters. They were stuck. With a sick son and no money to move again, the Snedekers tried to make it work. They didn't have much of a choice, really.
Life Inside a Former Mortuary
Imagine sleeping in a room where bodies were once prepared for burial. That was the reality for the Snedeker boys, who took the basement as their bedroom.
Almost immediately, the atmosphere shifted.
📖 Related: Alfonso Cuarón: Why the Harry Potter 3 Director Changed the Wizarding World Forever
Philip started changing. It wasn't just the chemotherapy. He became moody, aggressive, and claimed to see a thin man with long black hair. The family reported strange smells—the scent of rotting meat or overwhelming floral perfume that would vanish as quickly as it appeared.
Water in the mop bucket would turn red. Dishes would rattle.
One of the most chilling claims involved a physical assault. Carmen alleged she was being slapped and pinched by invisible hands while she went about her daily chores. The family's accounts weren't just about "bumps in the night." They described a systematic breakdown of their sanity.
Enter the Warrens and the Demonology Angle
When the Snedekers couldn't take it anymore, they reached out to the Catholic Church, but eventually, the case landed on the desk of Ed and Lorraine Warren.
The Warrens were already celebrities in the paranormal world by the mid-80s. They had "handled" the Amityville Horror. They had the Annabelle doll in their museum. When they arrived at the Southington house, they didn't just see ghosts.
They saw demons.
Ed Warren famously stated that the house was infested by "powerful" entities. According to the Warrens' narrative, the former morticians who worked in the house had engaged in necrophilia and other dark acts, which supposedly "invited" demonic presences into the home.
This is where the haunting of Connecticut true story gets murky.
Critics and researchers, like the investigator Joe Nickell, have pointed out that there is zero evidence the Hallahan family ever did anything untoward. They were respected members of the community. But for the "demonology" narrative to work, there had to be a "doorway" opened by human evil.
The Warrens brought in a crew of researchers, including Ray Garton, a professional horror novelist, to document the events for a book.
👉 See also: Why the Cast of Hold Your Breath 2024 Makes This Dust Bowl Horror Actually Work
The Ray Garton Revelation
If you want to understand the skepticism surrounding the case, you have to look at Ray Garton’s experience. Garton was hired by the Warrens to write In a Dark Place: The Story of a True Haunting.
He expected to interview the family and find a consistent story. Instead, he found chaos.
Garton has gone on record several times stating that the family members’ stories didn't align. When he went to Ed Warren with these inconsistencies, Ed reportedly told him, "They're crazy. All the people who come to us are crazy. Just use what you can and make up the rest."
Garton did the job, but he later distanced himself from the book, calling it a work of fiction based on a very thin foundation of fact.
Medical Science vs. The Supernatural
There is a very human element to the haunting of Connecticut true story that often gets ignored in favor of ghost stories: Philip’s health.
The young man was undergoing intense treatment for cancer. Some of the medications used at the time, combined with the extreme stress of his illness, are known to cause hallucinations and personality changes.
In fact, after Philip was removed from the house and placed in a psychiatric facility for a period, his "visions" stopped.
Believers argue that he was simply away from the source of the haunting. Skeptics argue that he was finally receiving the mental health support and medication adjustments he needed.
Interestingly, once Philip’s cancer went into remission and the family eventually moved out, the "haunting" seemingly vanished. Subsequent owners of the house on Meriden Avenue have reported absolutely zero paranormal activity. No ghosts. No blood drains. No thin men with long hair.
The Cultural Legacy of Southington
The 2009 film The Haunting in Connecticut took the Snedeker story and ran with it. It added the "Aickman" family name and the plot point about the son having visions of the dead to find bodies hidden in the walls.
✨ Don't miss: Is Steven Weber Leaving Chicago Med? What Really Happened With Dean Archer
None of that happened.
There were no bodies in the walls. The real story is much more psychological. It’s a story about a family under immense pressure who found themselves living in a place with a creepy history, which likely acted as a catalyst for their fears.
Whether you believe in demons or just the power of the human mind to create monsters during times of trauma, the Southington case remains a cornerstone of American folklore. It bridges the gap between the "Satanic Panic" of the 80s and modern paranormal investigation.
Separating Fact from Hollywood Fiction
If you're trying to piece together the truth, keep these specific details in mind:
- The Funeral Home was real. It was the Hallahan Funeral Home, and it operated legally and respectfully for years before the Snedekers moved in.
- The physical evidence was non-existent. Despite claims of blood and moving furniture, no photographic or video evidence was ever produced, despite the Warrens spending weeks in the home with equipment.
- The "Necrophilia" claims are unsubstantiated. These were likely added to the narrative to provide a "reason" for a demonic presence, a common trope in Warren-led investigations.
- The house still stands. You can drive by it today. It looks like a normal, somewhat grand New England home. It is a private residence, so don't go knocking on the door expecting a tour of the basement.
Moving Forward with the Truth
When researching the haunting of Connecticut true story, the best approach is to look at the primary sources—the original news clippings from the Record-Journal and the interviews with Ray Garton.
Avoid taking the 2009 movie or even the Discovery Channel's A Haunting episode as gospel. Those are dramatizations.
If you're interested in the paranormal, the lesson here isn't necessarily that ghosts are real, but that the story of ghosts is incredibly powerful. It can provide a family with a framework to understand their suffering, even if that framework is terrifying.
For those visiting Southington, appreciate the history of the town. It’s more than just a "haunted" location; it’s a community that, for better or worse, became the backdrop for one of the most debated supernatural cases in history.
Actionable Insights for Paranormal Enthusiasts:
- Research the Chain of Title: If you think a house is haunted, check the local library for the history of the property. Often, "dark histories" are local legends that grow over time.
- Consider Environmental Factors: Before jumping to demons, check for high EMF (electromagnetic fields) or carbon monoxide leaks, both of which are documented to cause feelings of being watched or hallucinations.
- Read the Skeptics: To get a full picture of any "famous" haunting, read the reports from the Committee for Skeptical Inquiry (CSI). They often provide the "boring" but factual explanations that investigators like the Warrens leave out.