It is a bit of a tragedy, honestly. Every year, thousands of high school students and casual readers pick up The Great Gatsby book and walk away thinking they’ve just read a tragic romance about a guy who worked hard to win back the girl of his dreams. They see the glitter. They see the yellow Rolls-Royce. They see the champagne towers and think, "Man, Gatsby was a romantic hero."
He wasn't. F. Scott Fitzgerald didn't write a love story. He wrote a ghost story about a man haunting his own life.
If you actually sit down with the text—I mean really look at the prose Fitzgerald labored over in 1924 while living on the French Riviera—it’s a much darker, grittier critique of the American dream than the Baz Luhrmann movies ever let on. It’s about the rot underneath the gold paint.
The Great Gatsby Book and the Myth of the Self-Made Man
Jay Gatsby is a lie. That’s the whole point. We meet him through Nick Carraway, a narrator who admits he’s trying to be "unprejudiced" while simultaneously judging every single person he meets. Nick tells us Gatsby "represented everything for which I have an unaffected scorn," yet he’s obsessed with him.
Why? Because Gatsby did the one thing Americans are obsessed with: he invented himself.
James Gatz from North Dakota didn't just change his name; he tried to kill his past. But Fitzgerald is cynical here. He’s telling us that in the 1920s—and let’s be real, probably today too—you can’t actually buy your way into the "old money" upper class. Tom Buchanan smells the "new money" on Gatsby like a bloodhound. It isn't just about the bank account. It’s the way Gatsby talks. It’s the "Old Sport" catchphrase that he uses like a shield. It’s the pink suit.
What People Miss About the "Green Light"
Everyone talks about the green light at the end of Daisy’s dock. It’s the most famous symbol in American literature. But people usually frame it as a symbol of hope.
"Gatsby believed in the green light, the orgastic future that year by year recedes before us."
Read that again. Recedes. It’s moving away. The light isn't a destination; it's a mirage. By the time Gatsby actually reunites with Daisy in Chapter 5, the light loses its power. Nick observes that the "colossal significance" of that light had vanished forever. The moment Gatsby touched the dream, the dream started to die. Reality can’t compete with the version of Daisy he built in his head over five years of staring across the bay.
The Brutal Reality of the 1920s Setting
Fitzgerald wasn't just guessing about this world. He was living it. He and Zelda were the "It Couple" of the Jazz Age, but they were also broke, alcoholic, and miserable half the time. The Great Gatsby book captures that specific 1925 atmosphere—the post-war hangover.
📖 Related: Why Grand Funk’s Bad Time is Secretly the Best Pop Song of the 1970s
The Great War changed everything.
These characters are traumatized. Gatsby and Nick were both in the 3rd Division during the war. They’ve seen slaughter. That’s why the parties feel so desperate. It’s not just "partying"; it’s a frantic attempt to forget the trenches. When you look at the Valley of Ashes—that gray wasteland between West Egg and New York—you’re looking at the literal trash heap of capitalism. It’s where Myrtle Wilson lives, and it’s where the dreams of the poor go to be crushed by the speeding cars of the rich.
The Women of West Egg
Daisy Buchanan gets a bad rap. People call her a villain. They call her shallow.
But look at her first lines. She hopes her daughter will be a "beautiful little fool." That’s not a shallow comment; it’s a devastatingly pragmatic one. In Daisy’s world, being smart just means you realize how trapped you are. She’s a "golden girl," but gold is a heavy metal. She’s encased in it. Tom is a brute—a literal white supremacist who quotes books like The Rise of the Colored Empires (a thin veil for the real-life The Rising Tide of Color by Lothrop Stoddard). Daisy stays with him not because she loves him, but because Tom is "real" in a way Gatsby’s stage-managed life isn't. Tom has a history. Gatsby just has a library of books he hasn't even read.
Why the Prose Actually Matters
You can't talk about this book without talking about the sentences. Fitzgerald was a perfectionist. He rewrote the ending dozens of times.
The rhythm of the final page is practically hypnotic.
"And as I sat there brooding on the old, unknown world, I thought of Gatsby’s wonder when he first picked out the green light at the end of Daisy’s dock."
It’s iambic. It’s poetic. It’s designed to make you feel the tug of the tide. The book is short—barely 50,000 words. You can read it in an afternoon, but you’ll think about the "boats against the current" line for the rest of your life. It’s a trick of the light. The book feels big because the themes are massive: time, memory, and the impossibility of repeating the past.
"Can’t repeat the past?" Gatsby cried incredulously. "Why of course you can!"
👉 See also: Why La Mera Mera Radio is Actually Dominating Local Airwaves Right Now
That’s the most famous line of dialogue for a reason. It’s the ultimate American delusion. We think if we work hard enough, or get rich enough, or find the right person, we can fix the mistakes of ten years ago. Fitzgerald says no. The current always pushes back.
Common Misconceptions About the Plot
People often forget how the book actually ends. They remember the party, maybe the car crash, but they forget the funeral.
Gatsby’s funeral is the most important part of The Great Gatsby book.
Hundreds of people came to his parties. They drank his illegal bootlegged booze. They ate his food. But when he dies, nobody shows up. Not Daisy. Not the party-goers. Only Nick, Gatsby's father (Henry Gatz), and the "Owl-Eyed" man from the library.
It’s a brutal commentary on "networking" and superficial connections. Gatsby was a means to an end for everyone around him. Even Nick, who claims to be Gatsby’s only friend, spends a lot of the book being fascinated by the spectacle rather than the man.
The Role of Jordan Baker
Jordan is often sidelined in the movies, but she’s the "new woman" of the 1920s. She’s a professional golfer. She’s cynical. She’s a liar.
She represents the shift in gender roles after WWI. Nick is attracted to her because she’s hard and modern, but he eventually dumps her because he realizes she’s just as "careless" as Tom and Daisy. That’s the keyword: careless.
"They were careless people, Tom and Daisy—they smashed up things and creatures and then retreated back into their money or their vast carelessness."
How to Read Gatsby Today
If you’re picking up the book now, don’t look for a hero. There aren't any.
✨ Don't miss: Why Love Island Season 7 Episode 23 Still Feels Like a Fever Dream
Instead, look at the geography. The contrast between East Egg (old money, established, "civilized") and West Egg (new money, flashy, "vulgar") is still the defining divide in global culture. We still have "East Eggs" in the form of zip codes and legacy admissions. We still have "West Eggs" in the form of overnight crypto-millionaires and influencers.
The "Valley of Ashes" is still there too. It’s just in different places now.
The Censorship and Legacy
It’s wild to think that when the book was published in 1925, it was a bit of a flop. It didn't sell well. Critics were lukewarm. It wasn't until World War II, when the Council on Books in Wartime distributed "Armed Services Editions" to soldiers, that it became a classic.
Soldiers sitting in foxholes identified with Gatsby. They identified with the longing for a home and a girl that didn't exist anymore. That’s how the book was saved from obscurity. It’s a testament to the fact that great art sometimes needs a specific historical moment to be understood.
Practical Insights for Your Next Read
If you want to actually "get" the book on your next pass, try these specific focal points.
First, watch the colors. Fitzgerald uses yellow/gold to represent money and white to represent a fake kind of purity (Daisy is always in white). Blue is usually associated with Gatsby’s "gardens" and his dreams—it’s the color of the ethereal and the unreachable.
Second, pay attention to the weather. The hottest day of the year is when the confrontation at the Plaza Hotel happens. It’s not just a coincidence. The tension is literal. When Gatsby and Daisy reunite, it’s pouring rain—representing the awkward, messy reality washing away the "dry" perfection of Gatsby’s plan.
Third, look at the eyes of Doctor T.J. Eckleburg. The giant billboard in the Valley of Ashes. Wilson, the man who eventually kills Gatsby, thinks the eyes are the eyes of God. He says, "God sees everything." But they aren't God. They’re just an advertisement for an optometrist. In Gatsby’s world, commerce has replaced religion.
What to do after finishing the book
- Read the letters. Check out Dear Scott, Dearest Zelda. It gives you the raw, unedited pain that Fitzgerald poured into the characters of Gatsby and Daisy.
- Compare the adaptations. Watch the 1974 version with Robert Redford and then the 2013 version with Leo DiCaprio. Notice how they both fail to capture Nick’s internal judgment, which is the soul of the book.
- Visit the real "West Egg." If you’re ever in New York, head out to Sands Point and Kings Point on Long Island. You can still see the mansions. You can still feel that distance across the water.
- Analyze your own "Green Light." We all have one. The thing we think will finally make us "arrive." The book is a warning: the pursuit of the light is often more meaningful—and more dangerous—than the light itself.
The book isn't a museum piece. It’s a mirror. Gatsby’s tragedy wasn't that he failed to get the girl. It was that he succeeded in becoming someone else, only to find out that the "someone else" didn't have a place to belong. As Nick says, Gatsby "had come a long way to this blue lawn, and his dream must have seemed so close that he could hardly fail to grasp it."
He did fail, though. We all do, eventually. And that’s why the book is still the greatest thing ever written about the American psyche.