Let’s be honest. Most of us spend our entire lives running away from the one thing that is absolutely, 100% guaranteed to happen. We treat death like a surprise party we didn't ask for. But when you pick up The Good Death book by Ann Neumann, that comfortingly vague distance vanishes.
It hits you. Hard.
Neumann didn't just sit in a library and philosophize about mortality for three hundred pages. She got her hands dirty. After her father died, she became a hospice volunteer, sitting at the bedsides of people who were literally hours away from the end. This isn't some "five steps to a happy life" manual. It’s a gritty, deeply researched, and sometimes uncomfortable look at how we die in the modern world—and why we’re doing such a bad job of it.
What the Good Death Book Actually Teaches Us
Most people think a "good death" means slipping away in your sleep at ninety-five. That’s the dream, right? But the reality is way messier. Neumann spends a lot of time deconstructing the "medicalization" of death. We’ve turned a natural biological process into a series of hospital codes and billing cycles.
It’s weird.
We have more technology than ever to keep a heart beating, but does that actually mean a person is "living"? That's the central tension. Neumann looks at the legal battles, like the landmark Terri Schiavo case, which turned a private family tragedy into a national political circus. She isn't just reciting history; she’s showing us how these public battles changed the way doctors treat us today.
Think about the last time you were in an ICU. The beeps. The sterile smell. The fluorescent lights that never seem to turn off. Is that where you want your story to end? Most people say no, yet that’s exactly where the majority of Americans die. The Good Death book challenges the idea that we have to hand over our autonomy to a machine just because the technology exists.
💡 You might also like: Why the Blue Jordan 13 Retro Still Dominates the Streets
The Hospice Reality Check
Hospice is often whispered about like it’s a failure. If you’re in hospice, you’ve "given up."
Neumann flips that.
Through her work as a volunteer, she shows that hospice is actually about reclaiming the time you have left. She describes patients who just want a cigarette, or to see their dog, or to have one last conversation without a tube down their throat. It’s about dignity. But she’s also realistic. She doesn't romanticize it. She talks about the smell, the pain, and the crushing exhaustion of caregivers who are often left to manage the "business of dying" with very little support.
Why We’re All So Bad at This
Honestly, our culture is death-phobic. We use euphemisms like "passed away" or "lost them" because the word "dead" feels too heavy. Neumann argues that this silence is actually dangerous. When we don't talk about death, we don't plan for it. And when we don't plan for it, someone else makes the decisions for us. Usually a doctor who doesn't know our favorite song or what we value most.
The book dives into the "Right to Die" movement. This is where things get controversial. Neumann explores the ethics of physician-assisted dying without taking the easy way out. She looks at the racial and economic disparities too. It’s easy to talk about "choosing" how to die when you have a mountain of resources. It’s a lot harder when you’re struggling to pay for basic palliative care.
She spends time with the prisoners at Graterford, a maximum-security prison. Think about that for a second. Dying in prison is a whole different level of complexity. There’s no family to hold your hand. There’s no "comfort of home." Watching inmates care for their dying peers is one of the most moving—and gut-wrenching—parts of the narrative. It forces you to ask: Does a "good death" belong to everyone, regardless of what they’ve done?
📖 Related: Sleeping With Your Neighbor: Why It Is More Complicated Than You Think
The Role of Religion and Politics
You can’t talk about dying in America without talking about God and the government.
Neumann is sharp here.
She examines how religious institutions have historically controlled the narrative around the end of life. From the Catholic Church’s stance on suffering to the way evangelical politics influenced end-of-life legislation in the early 2000s. It’s a web of conflicting interests. On one hand, you have the "sanctity of life" crowd. On the other, you have those advocating for "death with dignity."
Neumann navigates this minefield by focusing on the individuals caught in the middle. The families who are just trying to do what’s best while being screamed at by protesters or bogged down by red tape. She makes it clear that the "good death" is often sacrificed on the altar of ideology.
What Most People Get Wrong About This Book
People see the title and think it’s going to be depressing. I get it. Who wants to spend their weekend reading about morgues and terminal illness?
But here’s the thing: The Good Death book is actually about life.
👉 See also: At Home French Manicure: Why Yours Looks Cheap and How to Fix It
By looking closely at the end, Neumann highlights what makes life worth living in the first place. It’s about agency. It’s about the relationships we build. It’s about the realization that our time is finite, which is exactly what gives it value. If we lived forever, nothing would matter.
She also debunks the myth that there is a "perfect" way to go. There’s no script. Sometimes it’s peaceful, sometimes it’s loud, and sometimes it’s just plain frustrating. Accepting that messiness is part of the process.
The Economic Burden
We don't talk enough about the money. Neumann does.
She explores the "death industry." From the cost of funerals to the way insurance companies dictate the type of care you receive in your final months. It’s a system designed for profit, not necessarily for peace. She points out how the burden of caregiving almost always falls on women, often forcing them out of the workforce and into poverty. This isn't just a philosophical issue; it’s a systemic one.
How to Actually Prepare (Actionable Insights)
Reading this book should change the way you live today. It shouldn't just be an intellectual exercise. Neumann’s research suggests that the people who have the "best" endings are the ones who were willing to look the monster in the eye long before it arrived.
- Fill out your Advance Directive now. Don't wait for a diagnosis. Do it while you’re healthy and thinking clearly. Name a healthcare proxy—someone who actually knows what you want and has the backbone to fight for it in a hospital setting.
- Have the "Uncomfortable Conversation." Sit down with your parents, your spouse, or your kids. Ask them: "If I couldn't breathe on my own, what would you want me to do?" It feels morbid, but it’s actually a gift to them. You’re taking the guilt of making that choice off their shoulders.
- Define your "Must-Haves." What makes life worth living for you? Is it being able to recognize your family? Is it being free of pain? Is it being at home? Write these down.
- Audit your digital legacy. In the 2020s, our lives are online. Who has your passwords? What happens to your social media? Don't leave your family locked out of your memories because of a two-factor authentication code they can't access.
- Research local hospice options. Not all hospice providers are created equal. Some are non-profits with deep community roots; others are corporate chains focused on the bottom line. Know the difference before you're in a crisis.
- Acknowledge the fear. It’s okay to be scared. Neumann was scared. The doctors she interviewed were scared. Acknowledging the fear takes away its power to paralyze you.
The Good Death book reminds us that while we can't control that we die, we have a lot more say in how we die than we think. But that power only exists if we’re willing to use our voices while we still have them. Death is coming for everyone. The question isn't how to avoid it, but how to meet it with your eyes open and your dignity intact.
The first step is simply refusing to look away. Stop treating the end of life as a failure of medicine and start seeing it as a final, essential chapter of being human. If you can do that, you're already ahead of the curve. It's about taking back the narrative from the machines and the lawyers and putting it back where it belongs: in the hands of the person living the life.