You didn't just go to the Frog and Turtle for the food. Honestly, if you were in a rush, you didn't go there at all. It was the kind of place where time sort of slowed down, usually over a "Swamp" cocktail that bubbled with dry ice or a plate of those legendary made-to-order doughnuts. For seventeen years, this gastropub wasn't just a restaurant in Westbrook; it was the town's living room.
Then, March 2, 2025, happened. The doors locked for the last time.
Now, in early 2026, the space at 3 Vallee Square is finally seeing some action again with a new Indian spot called Bombay Bistro moving in. But if you walk past that green exterior, it’s hard not to feel a bit of a sting. Losing the Frog and Turtle Westbrook wasn't just about losing a place to grab brunch. It was the end of an era for Maine’s first true gastropub.
The Real Story Behind the Closure
Most people assume restaurants close because they run out of customers. That wasn't the case here. The Frog and Turtle was busy. Like, "90-minute wait on a Tuesday" busy.
The actual reason? Boring, frustrating logistics.
✨ Don't miss: The Long Haired Russian Cat Explained: Why the Siberian is Basically a Living Legend
Basically, the city of Westbrook required the installation of a massive sprinkler system in the rental space next door for the business to keep using it. For a small business operating on the razor-thin margins of the hospitality world, that six-figure price tag was a death knell. Chef and owner James Tranchemontagne was pretty transparent about it. Without the income from that extra space to offset rising costs, the math just stopped working.
It’s a classic "death by a thousand cuts" scenario. You’ve got labor shortages, food inflation, and then a city mandate drops a heavy brick on the scale. It sucks.
What Made the Frog and Turtle Westbrook Special?
James Tranchemontagne didn't go to culinary school. He learned by doing, working his way through kitchens like Portland’s Back Bay Grill before deciding Westbrook was the place to be. He wanted "high-end food at a price that didn't feel like a car payment."
The name itself was a tribute. "Frog" for his French-Canadian heritage and "Turtle" for his neighbors.
🔗 Read more: Why Every Mom and Daughter Photo You Take Actually Matters
The Menu Staples People Still Talk About
- The Doughnut Bar: These weren't your Dunkin' variety. We're talking the "John Candy" (maple and bacon) or the "Carson" (rocket fuel pastry cream). They were fried when you ordered them. Hot. Messy. Perfect.
- The Memere: A nod to James’ French-Canadian roots. Poached eggs on an English muffin with creton (a spiced pork pâté) and mustard. It was heavy, salty, and exactly what you needed after a long week.
- The Swamp: If you didn't order the green drink that smoked like a mad scientist's experiment, did you even go?
- House-Cured Everything: They did their own butchering. They made their own bacon. In a world of "thaw and serve" pub grub, they were doing the hard work in the back.
A "Vibe" You Can't Just Replicate
Westbrook used to be a mill town that people drove through to get to Portland. The Frog and Turtle changed that. It gave the downtown a pulse. On Friday nights, you’d hear the Tony Boffa Quartet or local blues acts shaking the walls.
It was a "Mug Club" kind of place. You knew the person sitting next to you. Even when the service was slow—and yeah, it was famously slow—people stayed. You stayed for the rooftop deck views of the Presumpscot River waterfalls. You stayed because the staff actually knew your name.
The Controversy Factor
Look, James wasn't everyone’s cup of tea. He was known to be "vocal." There was a semi-famous Reddit thread where a disgruntled customer posted a screenshot of him being, well, pretty blunt about why their service was slow. He didn't suffer fools, and he definitely didn't subscribe to the "customer is always right" mantra if the customer was being a jerk to his staff.
In a world of corporate-sanitized PR, that raw honesty was part of the brand. Love it or hate it, you knew exactly where you stood.
💡 You might also like: Sport watch water resist explained: why 50 meters doesn't mean you can dive
What Happens Now?
By the time you're reading this in 2026, Bombay Bistro is likely serving up traditional Indian dishes with a modern flair in that same spot. It’s great to see the building occupied; a dark storefront in Vallee Square is bad for everyone. They’re aiming to be a community hub too, which is exactly what that corner of Westbrook needs.
But for those of us who remember the smell of frying dough and the sound of live blues on a humid Maine evening, the Frog and Turtle Westbrook remains a high-water mark for what a local neighborhood pub should be.
Moving Forward: How to Support What's Left
If the loss of the Frog and Turtle taught us anything, it’s that your favorite "staple" is more fragile than you think.
- Go to the weird spots: Don't just stick to the Portland waterfront. Places in Westbrook, Gorham, and Biddeford need the foot traffic.
- Be patient: If a place tells you the food is made from scratch, expect it to take a minute. The staff are doing their best.
- Check out the legacy: James and his brother Andre also ran the French Press Eatery nearby. Supporting the people who built the scene is the best way to keep the "old Westbrook" spirit alive.
The era of the "Swamp" drink might be over, but the blueprint they left for a community-focused gastropub isn't going anywhere. Go find the next one before it's gone too.