When we talk about school shootings, the mind usually jumps straight to the 1990s. We think of trench coats, suburban high schools, and the 24-hour news cycle. But the reality is much older. History is messy. It’s often darker than the textbooks let on. If you’re looking for the first school shooting ever, you have to go back way before the invention of the AR-15 or even the metallic cartridge. You have to go back to 1764, to a small log cabin in what was then the frontier of Pennsylvania.
It was July 26.
The setting was the Enoch Brown schoolhouse, located near what is now Greencastle. This wasn't a "shooting" in the way we visualize them today—there were no semi-automatic weapons or tactical vests. It was a brutal, intimate, and horrifying encounter during a period of intense colonial conflict known as Pontiac’s War.
Honestly, it’s a miracle we even have the records we do. Most people think of the frontier as this empty expanse, but in the mid-18th century, it was a powder keg. Tensions between British colonists and Native American tribes were at a breaking point. Settlers were pushing west; tribes were fighting to keep their land. Caught in the middle was a schoolmaster named Enoch Brown and a room full of children.
Why the Enoch Brown Massacre is the First School Shooting Ever
Technically, people debate what counts as a "school shooting." If you're looking for a student bringing a gun to school to settle a grievance, that's a different story (and that usually points to the 1800s). But if we are talking about the first time a school was targeted for a mass killing involving firearms, the Enoch Brown massacre is the grim winner.
Three Lenape (Delaware) warriors approached the school that morning. Enoch Brown, the teacher, reportedly pleaded with them to take him and let the children go. He didn't have a weapon. He had a book.
They didn't listen.
The attackers opened fire. They used muskets—primitive, single-shot weapons that took forever to reload. Because of the limitations of the technology at the time, much of the actual killing was done with tomahawks after the initial shots were fired. It was a slaughter. Ten children died. Enoch Brown died. Only one student, a boy named Archie McCullough, managed to crawl away and survive, despite being scalped and left for dead.
Think about that for a second. Archie lived to tell the story of the first school shooting ever.
The Political Chaos of 1764
You can't understand this event without looking at the 1760s. The French and Indian War had just "ended," but peace was a joke. The British had won, but they were broke and arrogant. They stopped the traditional practice of giving "gifts" (essentially rent or tribute) to the Native tribes. This, combined with the constant encroachment of settlers onto protected lands, led to Pontiac's Rebellion.
It was a total war.
On the frontier, there was no police force. No 911. If you lived in a log cabin in Pennsylvania, you were on your own. The Enoch Brown school was just a simple structure, vulnerable and isolated. The attack wasn't a "random act of violence" in the modern psychological sense; it was a calculated strike intended to terrorize the settler population and force them to retreat back east.
Comparing 1764 to Modern Incidents
We tend to look at history through a straw. We see the first school shooting ever as a historical oddity, but the community reaction back then was eerily similar to what we see today. There was immediate outrage. There was a demand for better security (which, in 1764, meant more forts and militias). There was also a massive political fallout.
The Pennsylvania authorities were heavily criticized for failing to protect the frontier. The pacifist Quaker leadership in Philadelphia was increasingly at odds with the "backcountry" Scots-Irish settlers who were actually being killed. This event fueled a cycle of revenge that led to atrocities on both sides, including the infamous Paxton Boys uprising, where settlers murdered peaceful Conestoga Indans in cold blood.
Violence, it seems, always breeds more of itself.
The Weaponry of the Time
Let's talk about the "shooting" part. A Brown Bess musket or a similar flintlock wasn't accurate beyond fifty yards. You had to pour powder down the muzzle, ram a lead ball home, prime the pan, and hope the spark caught.
It wasn't efficient.
In modern shootings, the high body count is often a result of the speed of the weapon. In 1764, the "efficiency" came from the lack of resistance. The school was a soft target. There were no locks on the doors. There was no way to call for help. The terror wasn't in the rate of fire; it was in the absolute isolation of the victims.
Other "Firsts" That Cloud the Record
History is rarely a straight line. Depending on how you define the term, there are other candidates for the first school shooting ever that pop up in different contexts.
- The 1840 University of Virginia Incident: This is often cited as the first time a student shot a teacher. A law professor named John Davis was shot by a student who was wearing a mask and causing a ruckus on campus. Davis tried to unmask him, and the student shot him in the stomach. Davis died three days later. This was more of a "murder on campus" than a mass shooting, but it changed how universities handled discipline forever.
- The 1853 Louisville School Tragedy: A student named Matthew Ward brought a pistol to school and killed the principal, William Butler, because the principal had punished Ward’s brother the day before. This feels more "modern" because it involved a personal vendetta and a concealed handgun.
- The 1867 Blandville Shooting: After the Civil War, violence was everywhere. In Kentucky, a student who had been expelled came back and opened fire.
But none of these reach the scale or the pure organized horror of Enoch Brown. The 1764 incident remains the benchmark for a targeted, multi-victim attack on an educational institution.
The Psychological Impact on the Frontier
People in 1764 didn't have therapy. They didn't have grief counselors. When Archie McCullough survived, he became a living ghost. He lived a long life, but reports suggest he was never "right." How could you be?
The community of Greencastle didn't just move on. They built a monument. If you go there today, you can see the "Enoch Brown Park." It’s a quiet, somber place. There's a common grave where the teacher and the ten children are buried together.
It’s strange to think that the first school shooting ever is marked by a peaceful park in the woods.
What Modern Research Says About These Early Cases
Sociologists like Peter Langman, who specializes in the history of school shooters, note that early incidents were almost always external threats (like the 1764 massacre) or specific personal disputes (like the 1853 Louisville case). The "mass shooter" profile we recognize today—the alienated student seeking infamy—didn't really coalesce until the late 20th century.
👉 See also: Kamal Kaur Bhabhi News: The Tragic Reality Behind the Viral Reels
Back then, the school was targeted because it was a symbol of the community's future. To attack a school was to tell the settlers, "You have no future here."
Key Lessons From the Enoch Brown Massacre
We have to stop looking at history as a series of disconnected dates. The Enoch Brown massacre tells us a few things that are still relevant.
First, schools have always been vulnerable. Whether it’s a log cabin or a glass-and-steel "mega-campus," the inherent nature of a school—a place where children gather—makes it a target for those looking to inflict maximum emotional pain on a society.
Second, the "first" of anything usually happens because of a massive shift in the surrounding culture. In 1764, it was the collapse of colonial-tribal relations. In the modern era, researchers point to social isolation and the internet. The "why" changes, but the target stays the same.
Third, recovery is a multi-generational process. The town of Greencastle still remembers 1764. That’s over 260 years of collective memory.
Why Don't We Hear About This More?
Mostly because it doesn't fit the narrative. We like to think of school shootings as a "new" problem that we can solve with a new law or a new piece of technology. Admitting that the first school shooting ever happened before the United States was even a country is uncomfortable. It suggests that this type of violence is deeply baked into the American experience, tied to our history of land conflict and frontier justice.
Also, the 1764 event is often classified as "warfare" rather than "crime." But to the parents of those ten children, that distinction didn't matter. Their kids went to school and didn't come home. That is the universal thread that connects 1764 to every tragedy that has happened since.
💡 You might also like: What Really Happened with the Charlie Kirk Shooter Released Narrative
Fact-Checking the Record
Some sources try to downplay the Enoch Brown event or claim it wasn't a "shooting" because of the use of tomahawks. This is a bit of a semantic dodge. The primary accounts from the time, including those from Archie McCullough and the local settlers who discovered the scene, explicitly mention the discharge of firearms. The use of muskets was the opening salvo.
It’s also important to note that the Lenape leaders themselves were reportedly horrified. When the three warriors returned to their village and showed the scalps of the children, they were reportedly rebuked by their elders. This wasn't "official" tribal policy; it was a rogue act of war by three individuals.
Even in 1764, there were lines that most people agreed shouldn't be crossed.
Actionable Insights and Historical Perspective
If you’re researching the first school shooting ever for a project or just out of a sense of morbid curiosity, don’t stop at the Wikipedia summary. The nuance is in the primary documents.
What you can do next:
- Visit the Site: If you are ever in Pennsylvania, visit the Enoch Brown Park in Antrim Township. Seeing the physical size of the original schoolhouse (marked by stones) puts the tragedy into a perspective that no article can provide. It is incredibly small.
- Read Primary Accounts: Look for the papers of the "Frontier Forts of Pennsylvania." They contain the original reports from the days following the massacre.
- Contextualize the Violence: Don't view 1764 in a vacuum. Compare it to the 1840 UVA shooting or the 1891 St. Mary's Parochial School shooting (where a 70-year-old man fired a shotgun into a playground). You'll start to see that "school shooting" is a broad category that has evolved through three distinct phases: political warfare, personal vendettas, and the modern "active shooter" phenomenon.
Understanding the first school shooting ever isn't just about trivia. It's about realizing that the safety of our schools has been a concern since the very beginning of American history. It’s a long, tragic thread that continues to this day.
By looking at the Enoch Brown massacre, we see the rawest form of this tragedy—one stripped of modern politics and technology, leaving only the basic, devastating reality of a community losing its children.