When you think about the first NFL black coach, your mind might jump to the 1980s. Maybe you're thinking of Art Shell. Honestly, that’s a fair mistake. Most history books and TV broadcasts spent decades glossing over the league’s early years like they didn't happen. But the truth is, the barrier wasn't first broken in the modern era of neon lights and turf. It was broken in 1921, back when players wore leather helmets without facemasks and the league was still finding its feet.
His name was Frederick Douglass "Fritz" Pollard.
Basically, Pollard wasn't just a coach; he was a walking, breathing defiance of everything the era told him he couldn't be. Standing at just 5'9", they called him the "human torpedo." He was the first Black player to play in the Rose Bowl, the first Black quarterback in the NFL, and yes, the first NFL black coach.
The Akron Pros and the 1921 Breakthrough
Pollard didn't just walk into a head coaching job. In 1920, he was already the star running back for the Akron Pros. He led them to the very first NFL (then called the APFA) championship. He was the biggest gate attraction in the league alongside Jim Thorpe. You’ve gotta realize how wild that is—a Black man was the face of the league in 1920.
In 1921, the Pros decided to make him a player-coach. It wasn't a formal "head coach" title in the way we think of Andy Reid or Bill Belichick today—he was technically a co-head coach with Elgie Tobin—but Pollard was the one calling the shots on the field. He was managing white players in an era where, in many parts of the country, a Black man could be lynched for just looking at a white person the wrong way.
He didn't have a whistle and a clipboard on the sidelines. He was in the dirt.
Pollard's coaching style was born out of necessity. Since he was a quarterback and a coach, he had to be smarter than everyone else. He used a "crossover" step to dodge tacklers that basically revolutionized how running backs played. But the coaching? That was about survival. He had to earn the respect of teammates who initially wouldn't even speak to him.
📖 Related: Matthew Berry Positional Rankings: Why They Still Run the Fantasy Industry
What Most People Get Wrong About the Timeline
There is a massive gap in NFL history that confuses fans. If Pollard coached in 1921, why do people always talk about Art Shell in 1989?
It’s because of the "gentleman’s agreement."
By 1933, the NFL basically scrubbed Black players and coaches from the league. It was an unwritten rule. A ban. For over a decade, the league was entirely white. When the reintegration finally happened in 1946, the coaching ranks stayed closed. For sixty-eight years, there wasn't another Black head coach.
That’s why Art Shell is often called the "modern" first.
- Fritz Pollard (1921): The actual first. Coached the Akron Pros and later the Hammond Pros.
- The Dark Ages (1933-1946): No Black players allowed.
- The Coaching Vacuum (1925-1989): A nearly 70-year stretch where Black men were barred from leadership.
- Art Shell (1989): The first of the modern era with the Los Angeles Raiders.
It’s kinda heartbreaking when you think about it. Pollard didn't just open a door; he blew it off the hinges, only for the league to brick up the entrance for the next two generations.
Facing the "Crowd Hollering"
Pollard’s stories about coaching are legendary, but also pretty grim. He used to tell reporters that he had to dress in a cigar store across the street from the stadium because the locker rooms weren't safe or open to him.
👉 See also: What Time Did the Cubs Game End Today? The Truth About the Off-Season
When his team played on the road, fans would scream racial slurs the entire game. Pollard’s response? He’d just play better. He told his teammates that if they didn't like what he had to say, they could take it up with the owner—who knew Pollard was the only reason people were buying tickets.
He even had a specific way of falling. To avoid getting "piled on" by racist opponents trying to break his ribs or fingers after the whistle, Pollard would roll into a ball and kick his legs out like a cat. It was a defense mechanism turned into a playing style.
The Art Shell Era and the Modern Pivot
Fast forward to 1989. Al Davis, the maverick owner of the Raiders, decided he’d seen enough. He promoted Art Shell, a Hall of Fame tackle, to head coach.
This was a massive deal. Shell wasn't just a "placeholder." He went 54-38 in his first stint. He proved that the "leadership" excuses owners had used for decades were total nonsense. Shell’s success paved the way for the "Rooney Rule" in 2003, which required teams to interview minority candidates for head coaching jobs.
Honestly, the league still struggles with this. Even with the rule, the number of Black head coaches fluctuates wildly. We’ve seen guys like Tony Dungy and Mike Tomlin win Super Bowls, proving the talent is there, yet the hiring cycles often feel like they're stuck in a loop.
Why You Should Care About the Brown Bombers
After the NFL pushed him out, Pollard didn't just quit. He founded the Brown Bombers, an all-Black professional team. They played against white NFL stars in exhibition matches and absolutely crushed them.
✨ Don't miss: Jake Ehlinger Sign: The Real Story Behind the College GameDay Controversy
He was an entrepreneur, too. He started a talent agency, a tax consulting firm, and even a newspaper. He was a "renaissance man" before the term was trendy. He was trying to build a world where Black athletes didn't have to wait for a "gentleman's agreement" to end.
Actionable Insights: Learning from the Pioneers
If you're a student of the game or just someone who likes history, here is how you can actually honor this legacy:
- Look past the "Modern Era" stats. When you're looking at NFL records, remember that "all-time" usually starts in 1966 (the Super Bowl era). Real history goes back to 1920.
- Support the Fritz Pollard Alliance. This is a real organization that works with the NFL to promote diversity in hiring. They keep the pressure on so the "Dark Ages" never happen again.
- Read "Fritz Pollard: Pioneer of Pro Football" by John M. Carroll. It’s the definitive source. If you want the raw, unpolished truth about what those early dirt-field games were like, this is it.
- Watch old film (what's left of it). You can find snippets of the 1920s Pros on YouTube. It looks like a different sport, but the athleticism Pollard shows is undeniable.
Pollard was finally inducted into the Pro Football Hall of Fame in 2005. It took way too long—nearly 20 years after he passed away—but he's there now. He isn't just a footnote. He’s the foundation.
Next time someone mentions the first NFL black coach, make sure they know the name Fritz Pollard. He did it first, he did it under the hardest conditions imaginable, and he did it with a "human torpedo" style that the league had never seen before.
Explore the History Further
To get a better sense of the challenges these pioneers faced, you should look into the history of the "Gentleman's Agreement" of 1933. It provides the necessary context for why the progress made by Pollard was so tragically stalled for over half a century. Understanding that era is the only way to truly appreciate the resilience of the men who eventually reclaimed those roles in the 1980s and 90s.