January 4, 1999. It was a Monday. If you were a wrestling fan back then, you probably remember exactly where you were when Kevin Nash fell down like he’d been hit by a sniper. But he wasn't hit by a bullet. He was poked in the chest by Hulk Hogan's index finger.
That single moment, now infamously known as the finger poke of doom, didn't just ruin a main event. It effectively signaled the beginning of the end for World Championship Wrestling (WCW). People argue about this all the time. Was it the ego? Was it the booking? Honestly, it was a bit of everything, but the finger poke of doom became the visual shorthand for a company that had finally started smelling its own fumes.
The Night the World Changed (and Fans Tuned Out)
To understand why the finger poke of doom was such a disaster, you have to remember the context of the Monday Night Wars. WCW had been beating WWE (then WWF) for 84 consecutive weeks. They were the kings. But by early 1999, the momentum was shifting. Tony Schiavone, the voice of WCW, famously spoiled the results of the taped WWF show airing at the same time, telling fans that Mick Foley—playing Mankind—was going to win their world title. "That'll put some butts in the seats," he sneered.
Bad move.
Over 600,000 households immediately switched channels to watch Foley win. And what did they miss on WCW? They missed Kevin Nash, the giant who had just ended Goldberg’s legendary 173-0 winning streak, lying down for Hulk Hogan.
The crowd in the Georgia Dome went from electric to confused, and then to outright livid. You can see it in the footage. People weren't "booed" into a frenzy like good heels; they were just done. It felt like a middle finger to everyone who had invested months of their lives into the storyline of the New World Order (nWo) splitting apart. Instead of a war between the nWo Wolfpac and the nWo Hollywood, we got a hug.
💡 You might also like: Why Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy Actors Still Define the Modern Spy Thriller
Why Kevin Nash and Hulk Hogan Thought It Would Work
Kevin Nash has defended the move in interviews for years. His logic? He wanted to reunite the nWo because the "split" was diluted. He thought the heat from the betrayal would propel them through the rest of the year.
Hulk Hogan, ever the politician, was happy to be back on top. But the execution was lazy. If Hogan had cheated—maybe a low blow or a brass knuckles shot—the fans might have stayed. But the finger poke of doom made the title look like a toy. It made Nash look like a coward. Most importantly, it made Goldberg look like a chump because the man who beat him just gave the belt away for a joke.
The Goldberg Problem
WCW’s biggest asset was Bill Goldberg. He was their home-grown answer to Stone Cold Steve Austin. By having Nash beat Goldberg at Starrcade 1998 (via a cattle prod, no less) and then having Nash lose to Hogan via a finger tap just eight days later, WCW destroyed Goldberg’s aura.
The plan was supposed to be a long-term chase where Goldberg hunted the reformed nWo to get his title back. But Goldberg got injured, the booking got messy, and the fans simply stopped caring. You can't ask an audience to stay excited when you show them that the results don't matter.
The Long-Term Fallout of the Finger Poke of Doom
Business didn't die overnight. That's a common misconception. WCW actually still pulled decent ratings for a while after the finger poke of doom. But the "buy rate" for Pay-Per-Views started a slow, agonizing slide.
📖 Related: The Entire History of You: What Most People Get Wrong About the Grain
Trust was gone.
When you look at the numbers, 1999 was the year WCW lost roughly $15 million. By 2000, that loss ballooned to over $60 million. The finger poke of doom was the moment the casual viewer realized that WCW was a show written by the people starring in it, for the benefit of the people starring in it. It was "creative control" run amok.
The Creative Control Nightmare
Hulk Hogan had a contract that gave him "suggested creative control." In reality, that meant he could nix any finish he didn't like. Kevin Nash was the head booker at the time. When the stars are the ones deciding who wins and loses, you get the finger poke of doom.
- Self-Indulgence: The nWo members were having fun in the ring, laughing at their own jokes.
- The Mid-Card ceiling: Guys like Chris Jericho, Eddie Guerrero, and Rey Mysterio saw the glass ceiling and started looking for the exit.
- Narrative Dead Ends: The reunion of the nWo (Elite) didn't lead to any new stars being made; it just kept the same guys in the spotlight.
What Most People Get Wrong About That Night
Some historians argue that the "Butts in the seats" comment by Schiavone was actually more damaging than the poke itself. It's a "chicken or the egg" scenario. But the reality is that the two events happened simultaneously. It was a perfect storm of arrogance.
WCW thought they were untouchable. They thought they could mock the competition and treat their own title like a prop on the same night. They forgot that wrestling is built on the "suspension of disbelief." The moment Hogan poked Nash, that suspension didn't just crack—it shattered.
👉 See also: Shamea Morton and the Real Housewives of Atlanta: What Really Happened to Her Peach
Lessons for Modern Storytelling
If you’re a creator, a marketer, or even a business leader, the finger poke of doom is a masterclass in how to alienate your core audience. It teaches us three specific things about brand loyalty:
- Don't Cheat Your Customers: If you promise a "Mega-Match," deliver a match. Don't deliver a skit.
- Internal Politics Ruin External Products: When the "talent" (or employees) prioritize their own status over the quality of the output, the customer notices immediately.
- The "Shock Factor" Has Diminishing Returns: Being unpredictable is good. Being nonsensical is fatal.
If you want to dive deeper into this era, I highly recommend reading Death of WCW by Bryan Alvarez and R.D. Reynolds. It breaks down the financial documents and the backstage chaos in a way that makes the finger poke look even crazier than it did on TV. You can also watch the full episode of Nitro on the WWE Network (or Peacock) to see the crowd reaction for yourself. It’s a chilling reminder of how quickly an empire can fall.
The next time you see a brand or a show make a decision that seems to completely ignore what the fans want, just remember Kevin Nash falling over. It wasn't just a poke. It was a self-inflicted wound that never stopped bleeding.
To truly understand the impact, look at the ratings graphs from 1999. Notice the steep decline in the 18-34 male demographic right after January. Those fans didn't just stop watching WCW; many of them stopped watching wrestling entirely or moved over to the WWF "Attitude Era" and never looked back. The lesson is simple: respect the audience's time, or they will find someone else who does.
Check the archives of the Wrestling Observer Newsletter from that week. Dave Meltzer’s reporting at the time was scathing, noting that the company had "essentially turned their world title into a joke." He wasn't wrong.
If you're looking to apply this knowledge, start by auditing your own projects for "finger poke" moments—places where you're prioritizing your own ease or ego over the actual value you're providing to the people who support you. Avoid the shortcut. Finish the match. Keep the trust.