You've probably heard the phrase whispered in Italian bistros or seen it trending on weird corners of Catholic Twitter. Fat pope skinny pope. It sounds like a nursery rhyme or some bizarre fashion critique from the Vatican sidelines. It isn't.
Actually, it's one of the most enduring "unwritten rules" of the Papacy. The idea is simple: the Church, in its infinite, slow-moving wisdom, tends to swing like a pendulum. After a "fat" pope—meaning one who is expansive, jovial, and perhaps a bit loose with the rules—the College of Cardinals almost instinctively reaches for a "skinny" pope. This isn't just about the scale in the Apostolic Palace. It's about temperament, theology, and how the Church breathes.
Where did this fat pope skinny pope thing even come from?
It’s often attributed to the Roman people, who have a notoriously sharp tongue when it comes to the Bishop of Rome. The Romans have seen them all. They’ve seen the saints, the sinners, and the ones who just wanted to renovate their villas. The saying “Sotto un papa grasso, un papa magro” basically translates to: "After a fat pope, a skinny one."
But don't take it too literally.
While someone like Pope John XXIII was physically "fat" and brought a massive, "fat" change to the Church through Vatican II, his successor, Paul VI, was a wiry, intellectual, "skinny" strategist. It's a rhythm. The Church gets overwhelmed by a big personality and then retreats into the safety of a cerebral administrator. Then, getting bored or stifled by the red tape, the Cardinals look for a "fat" heart again.
History bears this out more often than you'd think.
The 20th Century Pendulum
Let’s look at the actual history because that’s where things get interesting. Take the transition from Pius XII to John XXIII. Pius XII was the definition of "skinny." He was ascetic, tall, thin, and deeply formal. He ate alone. He was a diplomat to his core. When he passed away in 1958, the Church felt... tight.
Enter Angelo Roncalli, John XXIII. He was literally a "fat pope." He was gregarious. He cracked jokes. He visited prisoners and children. He opened the windows of the Church with Vatican II. He was the "Fat Pope" in every sense—physical presence and expansive spirit.
📖 Related: Hairstyles for women over 50 with round faces: What your stylist isn't telling you
But what happened next?
After John XXIII died, the Cardinals didn't look for another jolly grandfather. They went back to the "skinny" model with Paul VI. Giovanni Battista Montini was brilliant, but he was anguished, thin, and cautious. He had to manage the "fat" mess—or "fat" harvest, depending on who you ask—that the previous administration left behind.
It's a cycle of expansion and contraction.
Why the Cardinals do it (even if they won't admit it)
Cardinals are humans. They get exhausted.
Imagine working for a boss who is a visionary. They change everything. They are loud, they are loved, and they leave a mountain of paperwork. By the time that boss retires, you don't want another visionary. You want a guy who knows where the files are. You want a "skinny" pope who focuses on the internal mechanics.
Then, twenty years later, the Church feels like a dusty museum. The bureaucracy is stifling. The pews are emptying. Suddenly, the "skinny" administrator feels too small for the moment. The cry goes up for a "fat" pope—someone with a big personality who can talk to the world again.
Is Pope Francis "Fat" or "Skinny"?
This is where the theory gets spicy.
👉 See also: How to Sign Someone Up for Scientology: What Actually Happens and What You Need to Know
Pope Francis is a fascinating case. Physically? He’s a sturdy man, but in the context of this prophecy, he’s a "Fat Pope." His papacy has been about the "peripheries." It’s been about big gestures, sweeping encyclicals like Laudato si’, and a general "make a mess" (his words) attitude. He broke the "skinny" mold of Benedict XVI.
Benedict was the ultimate "Skinny Pope." He was a world-class academic. He was quiet. He loved his books and his piano. He was a man of the internal life of the Church. When he stepped down, the swing toward Francis—a man who carries his own luggage and calls up random people on the phone—was the "fat" pendulum swinging back with a vengeance.
Honest truth? Many Vatican watchers are already looking at the next conclave through this lens.
If the fat pope skinny pope rule holds, the next guy won't be another Francis. He won't be a charismatic Latin American populist. He’ll likely be a "skinny" European or Asian intellectual who wants to codify the chaos. Someone who wants to button the shirt back up.
The nuance most people miss
It’s easy to dismiss this as superstition. Some people do. Skeptics say it’s just a pattern we impose on random history because humans love a good narrative. Maybe.
But look at the data of the last 200 years.
- Pius IX (Fat): Longest reigning, very present, big personality.
- Leo XIII (Skinny): Intellectual, wrote the first great social encyclical, very thin.
- Pius X (Fat): A populist, "the peasant pope," warm.
- Benedict XV (Skinny): A diplomat, frail, focused on WWI peace.
The pattern is weirdly consistent. It’s almost a psychological necessity for the institution. You can’t have high energy forever; you need a rest period. You can’t have a rest period forever; the institution will die.
✨ Don't miss: Wire brush for cleaning: What most people get wrong about choosing the right bristles
What this means for the future of the Church
We are currently in a "Fat" cycle. Francis has expanded the conversation to include climate change, migration, and radical mercy. He has upset the traditionalists and energized the reformers. He is "big."
When the bells eventually toll for the next conclave, the "fat pope skinny pope" theory suggests a retreat.
We might see a candidate who is:
- Focused on Canon Law.
- Less interested in press conferences on airplanes.
- Physically or temperamentally more "ascetic."
There is a real risk here, though. In a world that moves as fast as 2026, can the Church afford a "skinny" cycle? Some say the Church needs a permanent "fat" personality to stay relevant in the digital age. Others argue that without a "skinny" corrector, the Church will lose its theological identity in the pursuit of being liked.
Actionable insights for the curious observer
If you’re watching the Vatican, don’t just look at the headlines. Look at the "waistline" of the policy.
- Track the "Smallness": Watch for names in the College of Cardinals who are known for being quiet administrators. Men like Cardinal Pietro Parolin often fit the "Skinny Pope" archetype—highly competent, diplomatically focused, and unlikely to start a revolution.
- Observe the Contrast: Whenever a pope dies or retires, list the three things people complained about most. The next pope will almost certainly be the opposite of those three things. That is the "skinny/fat" mechanic in action.
- Read the Room: The "fat" pope cycle usually ends when the Church feels it has become too political or too worldly. The "skinny" cycle ends when the Church feels it has become too insular or boring.
Final thoughts on the cycle
It’s not a divine law. It’s not in the Bible. It’s just how humans manage power. We get tired of one flavor and reach for its opposite. Whether the next Pope is literally thin or just metaphorically "skinny," the pendulum will eventually swing.
The Vatican is a place of centuries, not seasons. This cycle is just its way of breathing in and out.
Next Steps for You:
To truly understand how this might play out next, start following the "Papabile" (pope-able) lists from independent Vaticanistas rather than mainstream news. Focus specifically on the contrast between current frontrunners and the leadership style of Pope Francis. If the "skinny" candidates are gaining traction in backroom discussions, the prophecy is likely preparing for its next turn. Pay close attention to the upcoming consistories where new Cardinals are named; this is where the "weight" of the next conclave is determined.