Long before he was Christian Grey or the charming "Pa" in Belfast, Jamie Dornan was a monster. Not a literal one, though. He played Paul Spector in the BBC’s gritty, rain-soaked thriller The Fall. Honestly, if you haven’t seen it, you’re missing out on one of the most unsettling performances in modern TV history.
It’s been over a decade since the show first aired in 2013, yet people are still obsessed. Why? Because Dornan did something most actors can’t. He made a serial killer feel like your neighbor. That’s the scary part.
The Fall with Jamie Dornan: A Masterclass in Creepy
Most crime shows are "whodunnits." You spend forty minutes guessing who the guy in the hoodie is. The Fall threw that out the window immediately. We knew it was Paul. We saw him tucking his kids into bed, and then we saw him breaking into houses to pose bodies.
Dornan was a former underwear model when he got the role. People expected him to just be "the hot guy." Instead, he gave us a man who was cold, methodical, and strangely relatable in his domestic life. He’s a bereavement counselor by day. Think about the irony there. He helps people process death while spending his nights causing it.
Why Spector Was Different
Dornan has mentioned in interviews that playing Spector actually "scarred" him. You can see why. He had to inhabit a headspace of pure, calculated misogyny. Unlike the "slasher" villains of the 80s, Spector didn't jump out of bushes with a chainsaw. He was a "family man." He had a wife, Sally Ann, and two kids who genuinely loved him.
👉 See also: City Heat: What Really Happened With the Only Burt Reynolds Clint Eastwood Movie
The show’s creator, Allan Cubitt, didn't want a caricature. He wanted a mirror. He wanted to show that the most dangerous men aren't always hiding in the shadows; sometimes they’re sitting right across from you at the dinner table.
The Stella Gibson Factor
You can't talk about Jamie Dornan in The Fall without talking about Gillian Anderson. Her character, Stella Gibson, is the ice to his fire. Or maybe she's the ice to his ice.
Their dynamic is basically a high-stakes chess match played across the streets of Belfast. They didn’t even share a scene together for the first two seasons. Not one. They communicated through phone calls and the traces they left behind. When they finally sat in that interrogation room in Season 3? Pure electricity.
- The Power Shift: Stella is a feminist icon. She doesn't apologize for her sexuality or her ambition.
- The Mirroring: The show subtly suggests they are two sides of the same coin—both obsessive, both lonely, both hunters.
- The Language: Stella refuses to call him a "monster." To her, he’s just a man who made choices. That’s way more terrifying.
A Career-Defining Shift
Before this show, Jamie Dornan was struggling to be taken seriously. After it? He was a superstar. But it came at a cost. He’s admitted he found himself carrying Spector’s "anger and hatred" home with him after long days on set.
The filming locations in Belfast added to the gloom. The city itself feels like a character. It's grey, wet, and heavy with history. Using real spots like the Botanic Gardens or the Merchant Hotel made the horror feel grounded. It wasn't "Hollywood" scary. It was "this could happen on my street" scary.
The Controversy of the Ending
Season 3 is... divisive. Some fans hated the "amnesia" plotline. After being shot at the end of Season 2, Spector wakes up claiming he doesn't remember the last six years. Is he faking? Is he actually a victim of his own brain?
The finale is brutal. There's no big courtroom victory. Instead, it’s a messy, violent conclusion that leaves everyone—including the audience—feeling a bit sick. Spector takes his own life in a psychiatric facility, robbing Stella (and the victims' families) of true justice. It’s an ending that refuses to give you closure.
What Most People Get Wrong
A lot of people think The Fall is just another "dead girl" show. It's not. It’s actually a pretty intense critique of how society views violence against women.
Stella Gibson spends half her time fighting the killer and the other half fighting her own sexist colleagues. The show highlights how the police—and the media—often blame the victims for "risky behavior." Stella shuts that down every single time. It's probably the most feminist serial killer show ever made, which sounds like a contradiction, but it works.
Real Insights for Fans:
If you’re planning a rewatch or checking it out for the first time, keep an eye on the journals. Both Stella and Paul keep them. His are filled with disturbing fantasies; hers are filled with dreams. It’s a tiny detail that shows how much they are "hunting" their own psyches.
👉 See also: Thor End of Days: Why This Grim Future for the God of Thunder Still Haunts Marvel Fans
Also, look at the colors. Stella is almost always in silk blouses—creams, blues, whites. She is light in a world that Spector is trying to turn black.
Moving Forward
If you finished The Fall and need more Dornan but don't want to be depressed, go watch The Tourist. It’s got that same mystery vibe but with a lot more dark humor and Australian sun. Or watch Belfast to see him play a genuinely good man in the same city where he once played a killer.
The best way to appreciate what Dornan did is to watch his transition from the silent, predatory Spector to the vulnerable characters he plays now. It shows the range of a guy who was once just "the model."
To dive deeper into the psychology of the show, watch the 2014 IFTA awards footage where Dornan discusses the "scarring" nature of the role. It provides a lot of context for why his performance felt so raw and uncomfortable. Alternatively, look up the filming map of Belfast and see how close the "fictional" crimes were to everyday landmarks. It changes how you see the city.