You’ve probably heard the name "St. Jetersburg." It wasn’t just a clever nickname coined by Tampa locals; it was a legitimate landmark. For over a decade, the massive derek jeter home tampa fl stood as a monument to success, excess, and some of the most famous neighbors in sports history.
But if you drive down to Davis Islands today looking for those iconic green-roofed gables and the massive "Great Wall of Jeter," you’re going to be disappointed. The house is gone.
Honestly, it’s one of the weirdest real estate stories in Florida. A guy builds a 30,000-square-foot custom fortress, rents it to the greatest quarterback of all time, sells it for a record-breaking $22.5 million, and then the new owners just... tear the whole thing down.
Let’s get into what actually happened at 58 Bahama Circle.
The House That Derek Built (and Why It’s Gone)
When Derek Jeter first started piecing together this estate in 2005 and 2006, he didn’t just buy a house. He bought two adjacent lots on the southernmost tip of Davis Islands. He wanted privacy. He wanted space. And he definitely wanted a view of Hillsborough Bay that didn't involve seeing his neighbors' laundry.
Construction wrapped up around 2011. What resulted was an English-manor-style behemoth that clocked in at roughly 30,875 square feet. To put that in perspective, a "regular" big house is maybe 5,000 square feet. This thing was a village.
🔗 Read more: How Tall is Tim Curry? What Fans Often Get Wrong About the Legend's Height
Why did they demolish it?
It sounds crazy to wreck a $22 million mansion, right?
Well, the truth is a bit more practical. The new owners, a trust managed by a local attorney, reportedly found the layout—while impressive—a bit too "commercial" and dark. It was built like a fortress. Jeter had a six-foot privacy wall (the "Great Wall") and a layout that felt more like a luxury hotel than a cozy family home.
Also, there were boring, nerdy construction reasons. Building codes in Tampa changed. If you wanted to do a massive renovation on the existing structure, you'd run into issues with flood elevation requirements. Sometimes it’s just cheaper and easier for billionaires to start over from scratch than to retro-fit a 2011 mansion to 2024/2025 standards.
Life Inside St. Jetersburg
Before the wrecking balls arrived in 2023, the derek jeter home tampa fl was basically the ultimate bachelor-turned-family-man pad. It had seven bedrooms and a staggering 16 bathrooms.
Why 16? Because when you’re Derek Jeter, no guest should ever have to wait.
💡 You might also like: Brandi Love Explained: Why the Businesswoman and Adult Icon Still Matters in 2026
- The Club Room: This was the soul of the house. It had a full bar, billiards table, and enough TVs to rival a Buffalo Wild Wings.
- The 80-Foot Pool: Most people have a "lap pool." Jeter had an 80-foot saltwater masterpiece with a glass railing that looked like it spilled right into the bay.
- The Garage: It was a six-car, climate-controlled setup. Because you can't have your Ferraris getting humid.
- The Privacy: This was the house's biggest selling point. Jeter famously battled with local boards to get that high wall built. He wanted a sanctuary, and for a long time, he had it.
The Tom Brady Era: A Rental for the Ages
The house hit a second peak of fame in 2020. When Tom Brady signed with the Tampa Bay Buccaneers, he needed a place to live. Fast.
He ended up renting the mansion from Jeter. It was the ultimate "game recognizes game" moment. Brady, Gisele Bündchen, and their kids moved in, and suddenly Davis Islands was the center of the sports universe.
But it wasn't all sunshine and Super Bowls. Brady actually complained about the privacy—or lack thereof—during an interview with Howard Stern. He mentioned that even with the walls, people could boat right up to the back of the house.
"I forgot people could drive up to your house," Brady told Stern. "Here they can pull right up to the back of the house."
It turns out even a 30,000-square-foot fortress can’t stop a fan with a Jet Ski and a GoPro.
📖 Related: Melania Trump Wedding Photos: What Most People Get Wrong
What’s There Now?
The site at 58 Bahama Circle is currently undergoing a massive transformation. Ellison Construction was tapped to build the replacement.
We aren't getting another English manor. The plans filed with the city show a more "modern French" design. It’s supposed to be even bigger in some ways—hovering around 30,000 square feet again—but with three distinct wings. One for sleeping, one for entertaining, and one basically dedicated to a gym and an indoor basketball court.
It’s going to be "cozier," according to the developers. Though, how "cozy" you can get with 30,000 square feet is anyone's guess.
What You Can Learn From the Jeter House Saga
If you’re looking into the derek jeter home tampa fl because you’re interested in Davis Islands real estate or just love sports history, there are a few real-world takeaways here.
First, Davis Islands remains the premier spot for privacy in Tampa. If it was good enough for the Captain and the GOAT, it’s the gold standard.
Second, the "buy-to-demolish" trend is real in high-end Florida real estate. Land value on the water is so high that the actual building is often secondary. People are paying for the 345 feet of linear waterfront, not the bricks Jeter picked out in 2008.
Actionable Next Steps:
- Drive by Davis Islands: If you're in Tampa, the area is still worth a drive. You won't see Jeter's house, but you'll see the scale of the new construction.
- Check Local Permits: If you're a real estate nerd, Tampa’s public portal shows the filings for 58 Bahama Circle. It’s a masterclass in how ultra-luxury homes are permitted.
- Explore the Area: Davis Islands isn't just for mansions; the "village" area on East Davis Blvd has some of the best coffee and small-town vibes in the city.
The era of St. Jetersburg is officially over, but the dirt it sat on will probably be the most expensive real estate in Tampa for the next fifty years.