You know the feeling. The Paladin has a look of pure dread, the Rogue is grinning like a maniac, and the DM is sweating through their shirt while holding a single card. That’s the classic Deck of Many Things experience. But then Wizards of the Coast went and dropped the Deck of Many More Things, and honestly, the game changed. It isn't just a bigger deck. It’s a total rewrite of how we handle high-stakes gambling in Dungeons & Dragons.
Chaos is a tool. Most people think this deck is just a "campaign-ender" button, but if you actually look at the 66 new cards added to the original 22, there’s a lot more nuance than just "you die" or "you get a castle."
What’s Actually Inside the Deck of Many More Things?
Let’s get the math out of the way first. The original set had 22 cards. The Book of Many Things expansion—which is where the Deck of Many More Things lives—cranked that up to 88 total cards. That is a massive jump. You aren't just pulling the Flames or the Void anymore. Now you’ve got things like the Bridge, the Statue, and the Tree.
Some players get weird about the size. They think a bigger deck dilutes the "iconic" cards. Maybe. But in practice, it just means the DM has more ways to mess with the narrative without accidentally teleporting the party's Soul to a different plane of existence in the first session.
The art is also wild. Each card has this distinct, cosmic-tarot vibe. It feels heavy in your hand, or at least it does if you bought the physical boxed set. If you're playing on a VTT like Roll20 or D&D Beyond, the digital implementation is smooth, though you lose that tactile "oh no" moment of flipping a physical card.
The New Mechanics of Chaos
It isn't just about drawing cards. The Book of Many Things introduced a whole bunch of lore regarding the deck’s origin. We’re talking about Asteria, a character who is basically the "First Rogue" or at least a powerful seeker who has a deep connection to these cards. Her story adds a layer of "why does this exist?" that was missing for decades.
One of the coolest additions is the idea of using the deck for more than just gambling. The book suggests using the cards for cartomancy. Basically, you can use the deck to build a dungeon or generate an NPC's personality.
- Take the Donjon card. Instead of trapping a player, maybe it represents a literal prison the party has to break into.
- Use the Gem card to determine the hoard at the end.
- Let the Euryale card define the curse on the main villain.
Why the "Campaign Killer" Reputation is Kinda Wrong
Everyone has a story about a deck. "Oh, my Level 5 Fighter pulled the Moon and got three wishes and now the campaign is over." Yeah, that happens. But the Deck of Many More Things spreads out the power curve. By adding 66 cards that are often more "utility" or "narrative" focused, the statistical likelihood of pulling a "Game Over" card on turn one drops significantly.
✨ Don't miss: All Might Crystals Echoes of Wisdom: Why This Quest Item Is Driving Zelda Fans Wild
It makes the deck a viable long-term tool rather than a one-off joke.
Think about the Key card. Getting a rare magic weapon is cool, but it doesn't break the game the way the Fates might. The new cards follow this logic. They provide hooks. They give the DM something to work with. Honestly, if your campaign "dies" because of a card pull, it's usually because the DM didn't know how to pivot. The Deck of Many More Things provides the pivot points.
Breaking Down the Cards That Actually Matter
I won't list all 88—that’s what the manual is for—but a few of these new entries are genuinely brilliant from a design perspective.
The Sage: This card is a godsend. You draw it, and you get to ask a question and receive a truthful answer. It sounds simple. It is simple. But in a mystery-heavy campaign, this is a scalpel. It forces the DM to give up the goods, but it doesn't give the player "infinite power."
The Maze: This is a classic "save or suck" but with a twist. You’re vanished into a literal labyrinth. It creates an immediate mini-quest. The party has to find you, or you have to find your way out. It’s active. Compare that to the Donjon, where you just... disappear. Active play is always better than sitting at the table waiting for the session to end.
The Well: This is the gambler's dream. You learn three spells, but you also get a "fateful" downside. It’s that "power at a cost" trope that D&D does so well when it isn't being too stingy.
Implementation Strategies for DMs
If you’re a DM, don't just hand this over in a shop. That’s boring. You've gotta make them earn it.
🔗 Read more: The Combat Hatchet Helldivers 2 Dilemma: Is It Actually Better Than the G-50?
Maybe the deck is being used by a high-stakes gambling ring in the City of Brass. Or perhaps it’s scattered. This is my favorite way to use the Deck of Many More Things. Don't give them the whole deck. Give them five cards. They find more cards as they level up. It turns the deck into a collectible quest item.
- Level 3: They find the Star and the Jester.
- Level 7: They loot the Void from a Lich’s study.
- Level 12: They finally complete the 88-card set.
By the time they have the whole thing, they're high enough level to handle the consequences of a bad pull.
The Physical vs. Digital Debate
The physical Deck of Many Things set that came with the book had some production issues early on. If you remember the 2023 delay, that was a whole thing. Wizards actually pushed the release back because the card quality wasn't up to snuff. They fixed it, mostly. The current version you find on shelves is much sturdier.
Digital is "safer" because you can’t lose a card under the couch, but there is zero substitute for the tension of a player physically reaching for a face-down card on the table. If you can afford the physical box, get it. The guidebook alone is worth it for the inspiration tables.
Common Misconceptions About the New Set
People think the Deck of Many More Things is just "more of the same." It isn't. The original 22 cards were very binary—mostly "Very Good" or "Very Bad." The 66 new cards introduce "Very Weird."
There are cards that change your appearance. Cards that give you a weird spectral companion. Cards that change the weather for a month. It’s more about flavor and consequence than just reward and punishment.
Also, you don't have to use all 88. That’s a huge misconception. The book explicitly says you can curate the deck. If you're running a gritty survival horror game, take out the Castle and the Gem. Keep the Skull and the Talons. You are the architect of the chaos.
💡 You might also like: What Can You Get From Fishing Minecraft: Why It Is More Than Just Cod
Actionable Tips for Your Next Session
If you're going to introduce the Deck of Many More Things this weekend, do these three things to make sure it doesn't blow up in your face.
First, set the stakes before the draw. Make sure the player knows that once they declare a number of cards, they are locked in. No take-backs. The magic of the deck is the permanence.
Second, read the Book of Many Things lore chapters. Don't just skip to the card descriptions. The stuff about the Solar and the rogue Asteria gives you a reason for the deck to be in your world. Maybe the party is being hunted by someone who wants to "reclaim" the cards to stabilize reality.
Lastly, don't be afraid to let it get weird. If a player pulls a card that grants them a keep, don't just hand them a map. Make them deal with the fact that the keep is currently inhabited by a tribe of confused orcs who think the player is their new god.
The Deck of Many More Things is a storytelling engine. Use it to start stories, not to end them. If you treat it like a random loot table, you're missing the point. Treat it like a deck of destiny, and your players will talk about that session for the next five years.
Start by picking out 10 cards that fit your current story arc. Slip one into the pocket of a defeated rival. See what happens when the Rogue realizes what they've found. That’s where the real game begins.
---