Ever get that weird, tingly feeling that a Christmas movie is doing something totally different from the usual "girl-meets-baker" trope? That’s basically the vibe of Dear Secret Santa. Released back in 2013 on Lifetime, it’s one of those holiday flicks that people still hunt for every December. It isn't just a romance; it’s a time-bending mystery with a cast that honestly feels like a family reunion of TV royalty.
If you’ve ever sat on your couch wondering, "Wait, where do I know her from?" while watching Jennifer stress over her dad’s health and those mysterious letters, you aren't alone. The dear secret santa movie cast is a powerhouse of 90s nostalgia and genuine acting chops.
The Leading Lady: Tatyana Ali as Jennifer
Let’s be real. Most of us grew up with Tatyana Ali as Ashley Banks on The Fresh Prince of Bel-Air. Seeing her transition into the "workaholic banker returns home" role in Dear Secret Santa felt very natural.
In the film, she plays Jennifer, a woman who’s a bit too focused on her Los Angeles career until her dad, Ted, takes a nasty fall. Ali brings a grounded, slightly skeptical energy to the role. She’s not just a damsel waiting for a Christmas miracle; she’s a woman dealing with real grief and a very confusing mailbox. Her performance is what keeps the "time-slip" plot from feeling too goofy.
The Mystery Man: Lamorne Morris as Jack
This is probably the biggest surprise for modern viewers. Before he was the chaotic and lovable Winston Bishop on New Girl, Lamorne Morris was Jack.
🔗 Read more: Anjelica Huston in The Addams Family: What You Didn't Know About Morticia
Jack is Jennifer’s childhood best friend and the "one who got away." The catch? He died in a car accident three years before the movie starts. Morris plays Jack in flashbacks and—without spoiling the "how"—through the letters Jennifer receives. It’s a much more grounded and romantic role than the bird-shirt-wearing Winston we know today. His chemistry with Ali is the heartbeat of the whole story. Honestly, seeing him play a straight-up romantic lead makes you realize how much range the guy actually has.
The Heavy Hitters: Supporting Icons
The dear secret santa movie cast didn't stop with the leads. They brought in some serious legends to fill out the town of Berkeley.
- Bill Cobbs as Ted: The late, great Bill Cobbs played Jennifer’s father. He’s the classic "grumpy but loves you" dad. Cobbs was a veteran actor you’ve seen in everything from The Bodyguard to Night at the Museum. He gives the movie its emotional weight.
- Della Reese as Linda: Talk about casting gold. Having the star of Touched by an Angel in a Christmas movie about mysterious messages from the "beyond"? Perfect. She brings that warm, authoritative presence that only Della Reese could.
- Ernie Hudson as Pastor Avery: Yes, Winston Zeddemore from Ghostbusters is the local pastor. He’s the moral compass of the film.
- Jordin Sparks as Abby: The American Idol winner plays Jennifer’s best friend. Sparks doesn't just act here; she adds to the overall "star power" of the film. She’s the one who calls Jennifer home and keeps her sane when the letters start arriving.
Why the Cast Works So Well
It’s rare for a made-for-TV movie to have this many recognizable faces who actually mesh well. Usually, these movies have one "big name" and a bunch of extras. Dear Secret Santa feels different because the ensemble feels like a real community.
The plot involves a lot of "is this magic or am I crazy?" moments. Because actors like Ernie Hudson and Bill Cobbs are so believable, you find yourself going along with the supernatural elements. You want to believe that Jennifer is actually communicating with Jack across time because the people around her are so well-drawn.
💡 You might also like: Isaiah Washington Movies and Shows: Why the Star Still Matters
The Full Cast Breakdown
If you're looking for the specifics, here’s a quick rundown of who’s who:
- Jennifer: Tatyana Ali
- Jack: Lamorne Morris
- Abby: Jordin Sparks
- Ted: Bill Cobbs
- Linda: Della Reese
- Pastor Avery: Ernie Hudson
- Dr. Brad: Jay Ellis (Yep, Insecure fans, that’s him!)
- Gayle: Denise Boutte
- Chris: Elimu Nelson
The Jay Ellis Connection
Wait, did I mention Jay Ellis? Before he was "Lawrence" on Insecure or flying jets in Top Gun: Maverick, he was Dr. Brad in this movie. He plays the ex-boyfriend who cheated on Jennifer years ago. It’s a relatively small role, but it’s fun to see him in his earlier career days, playing the "wrong guy" for the protagonist.
The Legacy of the Film
Even though it’s been well over a decade since it premiered, the movie stays relevant. It’s often compared to The Lake House because of the letter-writing-across-time mechanic. But while The Lake House is a heavy drama, Dear Secret Santa keeps things cozy.
The film deals with a very human question: what would you say to the person you lost if you had one more chance? The dear secret santa movie cast handles that question with more grace than your average holiday fluff. They make the grief feel real, which makes the eventual resolution feel earned.
📖 Related: Temuera Morrison as Boba Fett: Why Fans Are Still Divided Over the Daimyo of Tatooine
Where to Watch and What to Look For
You can usually find this one streaming on Lifetime’s app or through various VOD services during the holidays. When you watch it, keep an eye out for the small details in the background of the Berkeley scenes. The production design does a great job of making the town feel lived-in, not just a set.
If you’re planning a watch party, here’s a tip: pay attention to the dates mentioned in the letters. It’s the key to the whole puzzle. Also, have some tissues ready for the scenes between Tatyana Ali and Bill Cobbs. Their father-daughter dynamic is arguably the most "real" part of the movie.
Next time you're scrolling through a sea of identical-looking Christmas posters, give this one a shot. The cast alone makes it worth the 90 minutes. You get to see a pre-superstar Lamorne Morris, a post-fresh-prince Tatyana Ali, and a group of acting legends who clearly enjoyed working together.
To get the most out of your viewing, try watching it back-to-back with another Tatyana Ali holiday film like Wrapped Up in Christmas to see how her "holiday movie persona" has evolved over the years. It’s a fun way to see a talented actress own a specific genre.