You’ve probably sung them a thousand times. Maybe you’re humming one right now while folding laundry or trying to get a toddler to finally, mercifully, go to sleep. We treat these little jingles like innocent relics of childhood, but honestly, the origins of nursery rhymes are often messy, political, and sometimes straight-up gruesome. They weren't always meant for kids. Most of these verses started as adult folk songs, drinking tunes, or coded satirical barbs aimed at the ruling class when saying the wrong thing could literally get your head chopped off.
History is loud. It’s rarely as "nursery" as the name suggests.
Why the Origins of Nursery Rhymes Are So Weirdly Dark
If you look at the 18th-century collection Mother Goose's Melody, published around 1780 by John Newbery, you start to see the shift from oral folk tradition to printed children’s literature. But before that? It was the Wild West of oral history. People used rhyme because it was sticky. Information lived in the ear, not on the page.
Take "Ring-a-Ring o' Roses." You’ve likely heard the theory that it’s about the Great Plague of London in 1665. The "rosie" is the rash, the "posies" are the herbs carried to ward off the smell of death, and the "falling down" is, well, dying. It’s a compelling story. It feels right. But here’s the thing: most folklorists, including the legendary Iona and Peter Opie who wrote The Oxford Dictionary of Nursery Rhymes, argue this is actually a myth. The rhyme didn't even appear in print until the late 19th century. If it were about the 17th-century plague, why did it take 200 years to show up? It’s more likely just a dancing game that people retrofitted with a spooky backstory because humans love a good urban legend.
The Tax Man and the Wool Trade
"Baa Baa Black Sheep" is a different animal entirely. It’s not just a cute song about farm life. This one likely points to the heavy taxation of the wool trade in medieval England. Specifically, the "Great Custom" wool tax of 1275. Back then, the king took a third, the church took a third, and the farmer was lucky to keep the rest. One for the master, one for the dame, and none for the little boy who lives down the lane? That’s a complaint about poverty and systemic greed, not a bedtime story.
Imagine being a shepherd in the 13th century. You're working in the cold, shearing sheep, and most of your profit is being siphoned off by the crown and the clergy. You can't start a protest—you'd be jailed or worse. So, you sing. You make a little rhyme that mocks the situation. It’s subversive. It’s a survival tactic disguised as a melody.
Religious Conflict and the Terrible Fate of Humpty Dumpty
Most people picture Humpty Dumpty as a giant, clumsy egg. Thank Lewis Carroll for that. In Through the Looking-Glass, Carroll depicted Humpty as an egg, and the image stuck in the global consciousness forever. However, the original rhyme never actually mentions an egg.
There are two major historical theories here. One involves a massive siege engine used during the English Civil War. During the siege of Gloucester in 1643, a heavy piece of ordnance (a "Humpty Dumpty") was supposedly positioned on a church wall. When the wall was blown out, the cannon fell and couldn't be put back together again. The other theory points to King Richard III, the "hunchback" king, who fell at the Battle of Bosworth Field. Whether it’s a cannon or a king, it’s about a catastrophic failure of power.
👉 See also: Thinking of Ankle Tattoo Designs for Ladies? Here is What the Artists Won't Tell You
Then there’s "Goosey Goosey Gander." This one is undeniably grim.
Goosey goosey gander, whither shall I wander?
Upstairs and downstairs and in my lady's chamber.
There I met an old man who wouldn't say his prayers,
So I took him by his left leg and threw him down the stairs.
This isn't just about a grumpy old man. It’s widely believed to reference the religious persecution of Catholic priests in 16th and 17th-century England. "Priest holes" were tiny concealed rooms where Catholic families would hide clergy. If a Protestant search party found a "non-conforming" priest who refused to say the officially mandated prayers, the consequences were violent. Throwing someone down the stairs was often a euphemism for much worse forms of execution.
The Royal Scandals Behind Your Favorite Jingles
The origins of nursery rhymes are frequently tied to the drama of the British monarchy. It was the celebrity gossip of the pre-internet era.
"Sing a Song of Sixpence" sounds like a fever dream. Four and twenty blackbirds baked in a pie? Sounds messy. But look at the characters. King Henry VIII is a common candidate for the "king in his counting house." The blackbirds might represent the various manors or properties associated with the dissolution of the monasteries. Anne Boleyn is often cited as the "maid in the garden" whose nose was "pecked off"—a rather blunt metaphor for her execution.
Mary, Mary, Quite Contrary
Who was Mary?
✨ Don't miss: Gender Neutral Names That Start With D: Why They’re Taking Over the Charts
- Mary, Queen of Scots: A tragic figure whose "pretty maids all in a row" might have been her famous ladies-in-waiting, the "Four Marys."
- Mary I of England (Bloody Mary): A much more sinister interpretation. The "silver bells" and "cockleshells" aren't garden ornaments; they were reportedly instruments of torture used against Protestants. The "garden" was a graveyard.
It’s dark. It’s heavy. And yet, we teach these to toddlers. Why? Because the rhythm works. The brain loves the predictable cadence of a trochaic or dactylic meter. We forget the blood and the taxes because the beat is so catchy.
Why We Should Still Care About the Origins of Nursery Rhymes
Modern kids are growing up with Cocomelon and algorithmic YouTube hits. But the old rhymes persist. They are linguistic fossils. They carry the DNA of English history, shifting from political satire to playground games.
The nursery rhyme "London Bridge is Falling Down" is a perfect example of layers. Some say it's about a Viking attack in 1014. Others point to the "immurement" myth—the horrifying idea that children were buried in the foundations of bridges to keep them from collapsing. While there's no archaeological evidence for child sacrifice in London Bridge's history, the fact that the rhyme exists shows how we process collective fears through song.
We use these rhymes to teach phonics. We use them to develop motor skills (think "The Itsy Bitsy Spider"). But we also use them to connect to a past that was often frightening and unfair. They are a bridge.
How to Explore This Further
Don't just take the "dark origins" at face value. The internet loves a creepy story, and many "origins" you find on TikTok are just made up.
- Verify with the Opies: If you want the real deal, find a copy of The Oxford Dictionary of Nursery Rhymes. It is the gold standard of scholarship in this field.
- Look for the first print date: If a rhyme is supposedly about a 1300s plague but wasn't written down until 1920, be skeptical. Oral tradition is strong, but a 600-year gap is a red flag.
- Compare versions: Rhymes change based on geography. The American "Twinkle Twinkle Little Star" (written by Jane Taylor in 1806 as a poem called "The Star") is fairly consistent, but others have dozens of regional variations.
- Visit the locations: If you're ever in Gloucester, look for the "Humpty Dumpty" plaques. If you're in London, the history of the bridge is more fascinating than any rhyme could suggest.
The origins of nursery rhymes remind us that language is a survivor. These stories were whispered in shadows, shouted in taverns, and eventually sung in nurseries. They are the echoes of people who wanted to be heard when they weren't allowed to speak. Next time you sing "Three Blind Mice," just remember: you're likely singing about three Protestant bishops being burned at the stake by Queen Mary. Sleep tight!