You’ve heard the noise. Every time the Dallas Cowboys drop a game or a pass sails three inches too high, the same chant starts in the nosebleeds: "Bring in the new guy." But honestly, looking at the Dallas Cowboys new QB landscape heading into 2026, the "new guy" looks remarkably like the old guy.
Dak Prescott just finished his 10th season. Ten years. In NFL terms, that’s an eternity, yet here we are, staring down a 2026 campaign where he remains the undisputed focal point of the franchise. Even after a hamstring injury sidelined him in 2024, Prescott bounced back in 2025 with stats that would make most coordinators drool: 4,552 yards and 30 touchdowns.
But stats don't buy patience in North Texas.
The Joe Milton Factor and the Myth of the Successor
The real intrigue for people hunting for a Dallas Cowboys new QB actually centers on a name many casual fans might have missed during the 2025 shuffle: Joe Milton III.
Dallas traded with the New England Patriots to bring Milton in as the primary backup. He’s basically the human equivalent of a rocket launcher. We’re talking about a guy who can flick his wrist and send a football 70 yards downfield without breaking a sweat. If you’re looking for the "new" element in the room, it’s Milton. He’s the developmental project that Jerry Jones is currently enamored with, especially now that the Trey Lance experiment has officially ended.
Trey Lance is gone. He signed with the Chargers back in April 2025 after never really finding his footing in Frisco. That leaves Milton as the guy standing behind Dak.
📖 Related: Why the March Madness 2022 Bracket Still Haunts Your Sports Betting Group Chat
Is he the future? Maybe. Is he the starter in 2026? Barring a catastrophic injury to Prescott, absolutely not. Jerry Jones recently doubled down, saying he’s "very pleased" with Dak going forward. When Jerry says he’s pleased, he usually means he’s not ready to pay the massive cap hit that comes with cutting a franchise icon.
Why Everyone Is Obsessed With the 2026 Draft
The Cowboys are sitting in a weird spot. They have the 12th overall pick in the 2026 NFL Draft. They also have the 20th pick, thanks to the trade that sent Micah Parsons to Green Bay before the 2025 season.
Two first-round picks.
This is where the Dallas Cowboys new QB rumors actually get some legs. When a team has two picks in the top 20, they have the ammunition to move up. If a blue-chip signal-caller is sitting there at No. 3 or No. 4, does Dallas pull the trigger?
Historically, the Cowboys don't draft quarterbacks in the first round. They haven't done it since Troy Aikman in 1989. They prefer the "Dak model"—finding a guy in the middle rounds and letting him cook. But the 2025 season was a reality check. The defense allowed over 30 points per game, and the team finished 7-9-1.
👉 See also: Mizzou 2024 Football Schedule: What Most People Get Wrong
You can’t keep wasting Pro Bowl seasons from your quarterback because your defense can’t stop a nosebleed.
The Breakdown of the Current Room
- Dak Prescott: The incumbent. He’ll be 33 this summer. He’s healthy, he’s coming off a 4,500-yard season, and his command of the line of scrimmage is basically at an elite level.
- Joe Milton III: The high-upside backup. He’s the guy fans will clamor for the second Dak throws an interception.
- The Unknown: Dallas still needs a third body for camp. They’ve looked at UFL standouts like Jordan Ta’amu and even gave Donovan Smith a tryout, but that’s just depth.
What Most People Get Wrong About the QB Window
There’s this idea that because Dak is hitting his mid-30s, the "Dallas Cowboys new QB" needs to be drafted tomorrow. But look around the league. Look at Stafford. Look at Rodgers.
The window for a modern NFL quarterback has shifted. Dak "plays old man football," as some analysts like to put it. He’s not relying on 4.4 speed; he’s relying on reading a disguised Cover 2 shell and checking into a run play that gains six yards. That kind of mental game doesn't age out at 33. It actually gets better.
The real problem isn't the guy taking the snaps. It's the roster construction around him.
The Cowboys are losing George Pickens and Javonte Williams to free agency this March unless they move some money around. They just drafted Tyler Booker at guard to fix the line, but the defense is a total rebuild. If the Cowboys bring in a rookie QB now, they’re just throwing a kid into a burning building.
✨ Don't miss: Current Score of the Steelers Game: Why the 30-6 Texans Blowout Changed Everything
The Actionable Reality for 2026
If you’re waiting for a massive change at the position, you’re probably going to be disappointed this September. The strategy in Dallas is clearly "win now with Dak while grooming Milton."
Here is what to actually watch for in the coming months:
- Restructuring: Watch if the Cowboys move Dak’s money around again. If they extend him further, it’s a sign he’s the guy through 2028.
- The 12th Pick: If Dallas passes on a QB at 12 and 20 in April, the "new QB" conversation is dead until 2027.
- Milton’s Preseason: This is where the hype will live. If Joe Milton lighting up second-stringers in August doesn't start a quarterback controversy in the Dallas media, nothing will.
The Dallas Cowboys new QB isn't a person yet; it's a looming question mark. For now, the jersey still says No. 4, and the owner still says "optimism." Whether that optimism is earned or just Jerry being Jerry is something we'll find out by Week 1.
Keep a close eye on the official 2026 NFL Draft order as it finalizes after the Super Bowl. The Cowboys' decision to either use those two first-round picks on defensive help or trade up for a signal-caller will be the definitive signal of their long-term plan under center.