If you spent any time watching ABC’s Once Upon a Time during its seven-season run, you know that props weren't just background noise. They were the plot. But nothing—not even the poisoned apples or the glass slippers—carried the heavy, dark weight of the Dark One's dagger. It’s the show's most iconic relic. It is also the most dangerous.
Power. Control. Damnation.
The dagger Once Upon a Time introduced in the very first season wasn't just a weapon. It was a leash. If you hold the dagger, you own the Dark One. If you kill the Dark One with it, you become the Dark One. It’s a vicious, cyclical curse that defined Rumplestiltskin’s entire existence. Honestly, it’s kind of a metaphor for addiction, isn’t it? The more you try to control the power, the more the power ends up controlling you.
✨ Don't miss: Why Uncle Grandpa Still Feels Like a Fever Dream Worth Having
Where the Dagger Actually Came From
For years, fans just assumed the dagger was some ancient, evil thing that popped out of the ground. But the show eventually peeled back the layers. We found out it wasn't just a random blade. It was actually the broken tip of the Holy Grail.
Think about that for a second.
The Grail represents pure light and immortality. Merlin and his apprentice used it for good. But when it was forged into the sword Excalibur and subsequently broken, that jagged piece became the vessel for all the darkness in the world. It’s a classic Once twist: the darkest object in the universe started as the holiest. It’s poetic. It’s also incredibly messy for the characters involved.
In the episode "Nimue," we see the origin. Merlin’s greatest love, Nimue, drinks from the Grail, kills her enemy, and her heart turns dark. She breaks Excalibur, and that broken shard is forged into the dagger. This is why the two pieces—the sword and the dagger—want to be reunited. They are two halves of a whole.
The Name on the Blade
The most distinctive feature of the dagger is the name etched into the metal. It’s not a static engraving. It changes.
When a new Dark One takes over, the old name disappears and the new name manifests. It’s a magical "property of" tag. Throughout the series, we saw several names on that blade:
- Zoso (the one Rumple killed to get his powers)
- Rumplestiltskin (the longest-reigning holder)
- Emma Swan (the "Dark Swan" arc)
- Killian Jones (Hook)
Watching the name change was always a "holy crap" moment for the audience. It signaled a shift in the show’s power dynamics. Usually, it meant someone was about to lose their free will. Because let’s be real—having your name on that dagger is a death sentence for your agency. Anyone who picks up the knife can force you to do whatever they want. They can make you kill. They can make you bark like a dog. They can make you give up the person you love most.
📖 Related: Why Scarlett Johansson’s Kaa in The Jungle Book 2016 Changed Everything
Why Rumple Was Obsessed With It
Rumplestiltskin spent centuries trying to keep the dagger hidden. He buried it in the woods. He hid it in his shop. He even used magic to make it look like a common kitchen knife.
Why? Because Rumple is a coward.
He admitted it himself. He was terrified of being weak. The dagger gave him the power to protect himself and his son, Baelfire, but it also made him a slave. He wanted the power without the tether. This tension is what made Robert Carlyle’s performance so captivating. You could see him literally vibrating with the need to possess the knife while simultaneously loathing what it represented.
There was that one specific plot point where Belle (the "Beauty" to his "Beast") actually gets her hands on the real dagger. She uses it to banish him from Storybrooke. It was a heartbreaking moment because it proved that even love couldn't override the magical contract of the blade. If you have the knife, you have the person. Period.
The Rules are Sorta Complicated
The show played fast and loose with a lot of its logic, but the dagger rules stayed mostly consistent.
First, you can’t kill yourself with it to end the curse. It doesn't work that way. If a Dark One tries to end their own life with the blade, they just... don't. The darkness protects itself.
Second, the person holding the dagger has total command, but the Dark One can be "tricky." They can interpret commands literally or find loopholes. It’s a genie-in-a-bottle situation. If you aren't specific with your wording, the Dark One will find a way to make you regret opening your mouth.
Third, the dagger is the only thing that can truly end a Dark One. In the series finale, we saw the ultimate resolution of this. Rumple finally chooses love over power. He gives his heart to save Wish-Hook, and in doing so, the dagger and the darkness are finally extinguished. It took seven seasons and a lot of teleporting green smoke, but the cycle finally broke.
Why the Prop Still Matters to Fans
Even though the show ended years ago, the dagger remains a hot item in the cosplay and collector world. People buy high-end replicas of the dagger Once Upon a Time used because it’s so visually striking. The wavy blade (based on a Kris dagger) and the ornate hilt are unmistakable.
But it’s more than just a cool prop. It represents the show’s central theme: the struggle between our worst impulses and our desire to be "good." We all have a "dagger" in our lives—something we think we need to feel powerful or safe, but that actually keeps us trapped in old patterns.
How to Spot a High-Quality Replica
If you're looking to add this piece to your collection, don't just grab the first one you see on a cheap auction site. The real deal has specific details.
- The Blade Shape: It should have that distinct "flame-blade" or Kris style. It’s not straight.
- The Engraving: The name "Rumplestiltskin" should be in a specific, slightly messy script, as if it were carved by magic, not a laser.
- The Material: Cheap plastic looks like... well, cheap plastic. If you want something that looks like the show, look for zinc alloy or stainless steel versions. They have the weight that makes you feel like you're actually holding someone's soul in your hand.
Moving Forward With Your Collection
If you are a die-hard fan or a collector, understanding the lore of the dagger is just the first step. To truly appreciate the craftsmanship of the show, you should look into the work of the original prop masters who designed the series' weapons.
💡 You might also like: Why Cop Out Movie Actors and That Infamous Set Meltdown Still Matter
- Research the "Kris" dagger history: This real-world weapon style from Southeast Asia heavily influenced the Dark One's blade.
- Track the "Dark Swan" variants: During Season 5, the dagger's appearance changed slightly when Emma held it. These versions are much rarer.
- Study the "Excalibur" connection: Understanding how the dagger fits into the hilt of the sword provides a much deeper appreciation for the Season 5 storyline.
The story of the dagger is the story of Once Upon a Time itself. It’s dark, it’s magical, and it’s a little bit tragic. But mostly, it’s a reminder that true power doesn't come from a piece of enchanted metal—it comes from having the courage to let it go.
Don’t just watch the show; look at the objects. They tell the stories the characters are too afraid to say out loud. Focus on the details of the hilt and the tarnishing of the metal in the later seasons. It reflects Rumple's own decay. That's where the real storytelling lives.
Check out the original concept art from the ABC archives if you can find it. It shows just how many iterations they went through before landing on the wavy blade we know today. Most early designs were much more traditional, but they lacked the "sinister" energy the show needed. The final product is a masterpiece of fantasy design.