Elizabeth Gilbert has always been the patron saint of the "big pivot." You know the story—the unhappy marriage, the Italian pasta, the Balinese healer, and the multi-million-dollar book empire that followed. But lately, the conversation around her has shifted from sun-drenched self-discovery to something much darker, more jagged, and frankly, a lot harder to stomach. If you’ve been scrolling through The Cut Elizabeth Gilbert archives recently, you’ve probably noticed the tone has changed from "How I Get It Done" morning routines to raw, uncomfortable excavations of addiction and moral collapse.
It turns out the "Eat Pray Love" lady has a shadow side. A big one.
The Memoir That Changed Everything
For years, fans followed Gilbert’s relationship with her best friend turned partner, Rayya Elias. When Gilbert announced in 2016 that she was leaving her husband (the guy from the end of her famous memoir) because she realized she was in love with a dying Rayya, the internet collectively swooned. It felt like the ultimate romantic truth. But Gilbert’s 2025 memoir, All the Way to the River, alongside her high-profile interviews with The Cut, paints a picture that isn't exactly a Hallmark movie.
Honestly, it’s a horror story.
Gilbert admits that after Rayya’s terminal diagnosis, the two spiraled into a "level-five hurricane" of codependency. We aren't just talking about holding hands in hospital rooms. We’re talking about Gilbert—the woman who told us to find our "word" in Rome—buying thousands of dollars of cocaine for her dying partner. She describes tying off Rayya’s limbs and holding flashlights so the needles could find a vein.
"I'm Not a Good Person"
In a 2025 conversation with Emily Gould for The Cut, Gilbert didn't hold back. She dismantled her own "nice lady" image with surgical precision. She spoke about the exhaustion of caretaking and the terrifying moment she actually planned to murder Rayya.
Yeah. You read that right.
Gilbert admits she collected fentanyl patches and medication, plotting to end the "nightmare" because she was tired and Rayya had become abusive in her addiction. She told The Cut that if she’d written the book right after Rayya died in 2018, it would have been about what a "nice person" she was. Instead, she waited seven years to tell a story about being a "vampire" who tried to drain all the love out of a dying woman.
The Backlash and the "Financial Sobriety"
The reaction hasn't been all "love and light." Rayya’s own sister has publicly criticized the memoir, calling it exploitative and accusing Gilbert of monetizing a tragedy she helped fuel.
Then there’s the "financial sobriety."
📖 Related: Kris Kross Chris Kelly: What Really Happened to the Mac Daddy
Gilbert, who is worth upwards of $20 million, has recently shared that her "recovery" involves refusing to give financial support to struggling family or friends. She calls it a boundary; critics call it the ultimate act of a wealthy woman who has lost the plot. It’s a far cry from the woman who once seemed to advocate for radical, open-hearted generosity.
Why The Cut Profile Matters Now
What makes the coverage of The Cut Elizabeth Gilbert so compelling—and controversial—is the way it challenges our obsession with the "perfect" healing arc. We want our gurus to stay enlightened. We want the "Pray" part of the book to be the final word.
But Gilbert is leaning into the mess.
- She admits to being a "sex and love addict."
- She acknowledges her role as a high-functioning enabler.
- She claims she got "permission" to write the book from Rayya’s spirit during a telepathic visitation.
That last part? That's where she loses a lot of people. It’s one thing to be honest about drug use; it’s another to say a dead person told you to "go full punk rock" and reveal their most humiliating moments to the world.
The Snow Forest Side-Step
We also can't forget the other big controversy that led up to this: the 2023 shelving of her novel The Snow Forest. After Ukrainian readers expressed pain over a book set in Russia—even though it was 1930s Siberia and had nothing to do with modern politics—Gilbert pulled the book entirely.
🔗 Read more: Why the Side Boob Celeb Trend Still Dominates the Red Carpet
People were livid.
Free speech advocates called it "literary suicide." They argued she was setting a dangerous precedent by letting a Goodreads "review bomb" dictate what history we’re allowed to write about. It showed a woman who was perhaps too tuned into the "outpouring of sorrow" from her audience, or perhaps just a woman who knew exactly how to manage her brand in a crisis.
What This Means for You
So, what do we actually do with this information? If you grew up on Gilbert’s brand of "Magic," seeing her admit to planning a murder and enabling a relapse feels like a betrayal. But there’s a weirdly practical lesson here about the limits of "self-help" culture.
- Kill the Guru: Stop expecting public figures to be your moral compass. Gilbert is proving she’s just as fractured as anyone else, maybe more so.
- Watch the "Nice" Trap: Gilbert’s admission that she used "niceness" to manipulate people into loving her is a massive red flag we can all learn from.
- The Cost of Honesty: Determine for yourself where "radical honesty" ends and "exploitation" begins. Just because someone says it’s their "truth" doesn't mean it isn't causing harm to the people left behind.
If you're looking for the next chapter of the Elizabeth Gilbert saga, keep an eye on her 12-step journey and her life in the converted New Jersey church she calls home. She isn't looking for your approval anymore; she's looking for "ego collapse at depth." Whether you find that inspiring or deeply disturbing is entirely up to you.
To see the full evolution of this story, you can browse the chronological archives of The Cut Elizabeth Gilbert coverage, which tracks her transition from 2016's "Love Ceremony" to the "forensic account" of her life today.