Billy Sianis just wanted to watch a game. It was 1945. Game 4 of the World Series. He had two tickets—one for himself and one for Murphy, his pet goat. But the usher at Wrigley Field wasn't having it. The goat smelled. People complained. Philip K. Wrigley, the team owner, allegedly said the goat wasn't allowed because, well, "the goat stinks."
Sianis was livid. He supposedly threw up his hands and declared that the Cubs would never win again. For 71 years, they didn't.
That’s the basic version of the curse of the Chicago Cubs, but honestly, it’s only the tip of the iceberg. To understand why this specific superstition gripped an entire city—and most of the baseball-watching world—for seven decades, you have to look at the bizarre series of "near misses" and psychological scarring that turned a simple bar owner's grudge into a national phenomenon. It wasn't just about a goat. It was about a collective belief that the universe had a personal vendetta against the North Side of Chicago.
The Day the Goat Became a Ghost
Most people think the curse started and ended with Murphy the goat. It’s a clean story. But the reality is that the 1945 World Series was just the beginning of a spiral. The Cubs lost that series to the Detroit Tigers, and then they stayed away from the Fall Classic for a lifetime.
Was there a real hex? Probably not. But try telling that to the fans who watched a black cat crawl behind Ron Santo in the on-deck circle at Shea Stadium in 1969. The Cubs were leading the division by a mile. Then, the "Miracle Mets" happened. The Cubs collapsed. The cat was just a stray, but in the context of the curse of the Chicago Cubs, it became a demonic omen.
Successive generations of fans grew up waiting for the other shoe to drop. It became a self-fulfilling prophecy. When you expect disaster, you stop playing loose. You play tight. You make errors. You let a foul ball change the course of history because you’re already half-convinced you’re supposed to lose.
1984 and the Leon Durham Error
By the 1980s, the goat story was legendary. The 1984 NLCS against the San Diego Padres felt like the moment the spell would finally break. The Cubs were up two games to none. They only needed one more win to reach the World Series.
They lost the next two.
In the deciding Game 5, first baseman Leon Durham let a routine ground ball skip right through his legs. It was a nightmare. People pointed out that earlier in the game, some Gatorade had spilled on Durham's glove, making it slick. Others? They pointed at the goat. It didn't matter if it was physics or spirits; the result was the same. The Cubs stayed home.
🔗 Read more: Lawrence County High School Football: Why Friday Nights in Louisa Still Hit Different
The Night the World Collapsed: Steve Bartman
If you want to talk about the curse of the Chicago Cubs without mentioning 2003, you’re missing the most painful chapter. This wasn't just a sports highlight; it was a public tragedy for a man who did absolutely nothing wrong.
October 14, 2003. Wrigley Field. Game 6 of the NLCS. The Cubs are five outs away from the World Series. Mark Prior is dealing. Then, Luis Castillo hits a fly ball toward the left-field stands. Moises Alou reaches for it.
So does Steve Bartman.
Bartman, a die-hard fan in a turtleneck and headphones, deflected the ball. Alou went ballistic. The Cubs unraveled instantly. Alex Gonzalez, a sure-handed shortstop, botched a double-play ball that would have ended the inning. The Florida Marlins poured it on, scoring eight runs.
The city turned on Bartman. He needed a police escort to leave the stadium. It was the darkest moment of the "curse" because it showed how superstition can turn a community toxic. We blamed a guy in seat 113, row 4, aisle 4 for a professional shortstop’s error and a pitcher’s meltdown. That’s what the curse did to people's heads. It made the irrational feel perfectly logical.
The Science of "Cursed" Thinking
Psychologists often look at the curse of the Chicago Cubs as a massive study in confirmation bias. When the Cubs won, it was an outlier. When they lost in spectacular, heartbreaking fashion, it was "the curse."
Neuroscience tells us that our brains are wired to find patterns even where they don't exist. It’s called apophenia. We connect the goat in '45 to the cat in '69 to the ball through the legs in '84. We ignore the years of bad management, poor scouting, and the fact that the Tribune Company (the longtime owners) sometimes treated the team more like a real estate asset than a competitive franchise.
Basically, the "curse" was a convenient narrative that masked decades of organizational mediocrity. It’s much easier to blame a goat than to admit your front office is failing to adapt to modern sabermetrics.
💡 You might also like: LA Rams Home Game Schedule: What Most People Get Wrong
Theo Epstein and the Death of Superstition
When Theo Epstein arrived in Chicago in 2011, he didn't care about goats. He had already broken the "Curse of the Bambino" in Boston. He brought a cold, calculated, data-driven approach to a franchise that had been running on vibes and heartbreak.
He rebuilt the farm system. He drafted Kris Bryant. He traded for Anthony Rizzo. He hired Joe Maddon, a manager who brought "Try Not to Suck" T-shirts and petting zoos to spring training to lighten the mood.
The 2016 season was the final boss. The Cubs won 103 games. They breezed through the early rounds. But then, in the World Series against Cleveland, they fell behind 3-1. The old panic started to set in. You could feel it in the city. "Here we go again," people whispered in the bars on Clark Street.
Game 7: The Rain Delay that Changed Everything
November 2, 2016. The most stressed-out night in the history of Illinois.
The Cubs had a lead. They blew it. Rajai Davis hit a home run off Aroldis Chapman that seemed to solidify the curse of the Chicago Cubs forever. It was the Bartman game all over again, but worse, because it was Game 7.
Then it rained.
A brief, 17-minute rain delay forced the players into the weight room. Jason Heyward gave a speech. He told the team they were the best in the league and to forget the last nine innings. They came back out, scored two runs in the 10th, and Mike Montgomery induced a ground ball to third base.
Kris Bryant slipped. He actually slipped as he fielded the ball, but he was smiling. He threw to Rizzo. Out.
📖 Related: Kurt Warner Height: What Most People Get Wrong About the QB Legend
The curse wasn't just broken; it was obliterated.
Why the Curse Still Matters Today
Even though the Cubs won in 2016, the "curse" remains a vital piece of sports history. It represents the romantic, miserable, and ultimately rewarding nature of being a fan. If they had won every ten years, 2016 wouldn't have felt like a religious experience.
It also serves as a warning about sports culture. The treatment of Steve Bartman remains a stain on the fanbase. It took years for the organization to officially make amends, eventually gifting him a 2016 championship ring in a private ceremony. It was a quiet admission that the "curse" was never his fault.
Realistically, the curse of the Chicago Cubs was a mix of bad luck, bad management, and the incredible power of a shared story. We need these stories. They make the eventual victory taste better.
What We Can Learn From the Long Wait
If you’re a fan of a struggling team, or just someone interested in the psychology of sports, there are actual takeaways from the Cubs' century of losing.
- Logic over Legend: Success came only when the team stopped leaning into the "lovable losers" identity and started focusing on elite player development and data.
- Narrative Control: The curse ended when the players in the clubhouse stopped believing in it. Joe Maddon’s biggest contribution wasn't his lineups; it was his refusal to let the past haunt the present.
- The Danger of Scapegoating: The Bartman incident is a permanent lesson in how quickly "fun" superstitions can turn into genuine harassment.
- Patience and Process: Winning a championship after 108 years requires a total teardown. The Cubs got worse on purpose from 2012 to 2014 to get the draft picks they needed. Short-term pain is often the only path to long-term relief.
The goat is dead. The curse is gone. But the 108-year wait defined the identity of one of the most iconic franchises in sports. It proved that in baseball, as in life, the baggage you carry only weighs as much as you allow it to.
To dig deeper into the actual mechanics of how the Cubs rebuilt their roster to beat the odds, you should look into the "Epstein Model" of scouting. It shifted the focus from raw talent to "character and makeup," specifically looking for players who could handle the high-pressure environment of a "cursed" city. Understanding the transition from the "Curse" era to the "Data" era is the real key to seeing how modern sports dynasties are actually built. Focus on the 2012-2015 draft cycles to see where the real magic happened—on paper, long before it happened on the field.