You've probably seen the show. Rick and Marty Lagina, two brothers from Michigan with deep pockets and even deeper persistence, have spent over a decade tearing up a small island in Nova Scotia. People call it a money pit. They call it a life’s work. But when we talk about the Curse of Oak Island found treasure, we need to be honest about what that actually looks like. It’s not just a chest of gold coins sitting on a pedestal. It’s much more complicated, a bit messier, and honestly, way more interesting than just "pirate booty."
The "Curse" itself says seven must die before the treasure is found. Six have already perished. It’s a grim backdrop for a reality show, but it’s the mystery of the items pulled from the muck that keeps millions of us watching every Tuesday night.
The Lead Cross: A 14th-Century Game Changer
If you’re looking for the single most significant piece of the Curse of Oak Island found treasure, you have to start with the lead cross. Found by Rick Lagina and metal detection expert Gary Drayton at Smith’s Cove, this isn't just some old trinket. This thing is tiny, but its implications are massive.
Initial testing by experts like Dr. Chris Gazzo and later geochemical analysis suggested the lead didn't come from North America. It came from a quarry in Europe—specifically, one that was active during the medieval period. Some researchers point toward the Knights Templar. Why? Because the shape of the cross—a "crux ansata" style—closely mirrors carvings found in the Domme prison in France, where Templars were held in the early 1300s.
It’s a wild thought. You’ve got a piece of lead potentially dating back to the 14th century sitting in a muddy cove in Canada. It suggests that people were visiting this island hundreds of years before Columbus even thought about sailing the ocean blue. That’s not just treasure; that’s rewritten history.
The Gold and the Garnet: Small Finds, Big Hopes
Okay, let’s talk about the actual "bling." Fans often get frustrated because we haven't seen a massive haul of bullion. But there is gold.
👉 See also: Kate Moss Family Guy: What Most People Get Wrong About That Cutaway
Back in Season 5, the team discovered a small, rhodolite garnet brooch. It’s a beautiful, deep red stone set in what appeared to be silver or a low-grade gold alloy. Expert analysis dated it back at least 400 to 500 years. Then there are the gold flakes. In the Garden Shaft and various boreholes in the Money Pit area, the team has consistently found trace amounts of gold and silver in the water and the soil.
Is it a melted-down hoard? Or just environmental runoff from something larger? Honestly, we don't know yet. But you don't find high concentrations of silver and gold in the groundwater of a random North Atlantic island without something being down there.
The Human Element: Bones in the Pit
This is where it gets a little eerie. During the drilling of the "H8" shaft, the team recovered two distinct fragments of human bone at a depth of about 160 feet.
DNA testing was performed at Lakehead University. The results? One fragment belonged to someone of Middle Eastern descent, and the other to someone of European descent. This wasn't a modern burial. The bones were found alongside pottery shards and bits of leather, deep underground in a layer of earth that shouldn't have been disturbed for centuries.
It’s a sobering reminder. Whatever the Curse of Oak Island found treasure turns out to be, people died for it—and not just the six men mentioned in the legend. People were down in those shafts long before the 1795 discovery by Daniel McGinnis.
✨ Don't miss: Blink-182 Mark Hoppus: What Most People Get Wrong About His 2026 Comeback
Why the "Treasure" Might Be Information
We often think of treasure as physical wealth. But for the Laginas, the real treasure has often been the engineering they’ve uncovered.
- The U-Shaped Structure: Found at Smith's Cove, this massive wooden formation was dated to the 1760s.
- The Stone Road: A massive, paved stone path discovered in the swamp that looks remarkably like a Roman road or a heavy-duty wharf system.
- The Pine Tar Kiln: Proof of industrial-scale activity that predates any known settlement on the island.
The island is basically a giant Swiss cheese of tunnels, flood traps, and hidden wharves. The complexity of the stone road in the swamp suggests that whoever was there wasn't just hiding a small chest. They were moving something incredibly heavy. You don't build a paved road through a swamp just to hide a few bags of silver. You do it for something monumental.
What Most People Get Wrong About the Finds
A lot of skeptics say the "treasure" is just trash left behind by colonial farmers. And sure, some of it is. They’ve found plenty of ox shoes and 18th-century buttons. But those things actually matter. They show a level of labor and habitation that contradicts the "empty island" narrative.
The biggest misconception is that the search has been a failure. If you look at the sheer volume of the Curse of Oak Island found treasure—from the 17th-century Spanish "maravedis" coins to the mysterious parchment scraps with the letters "vi" or "wi"—the evidence of a high-stakes operation is overwhelming.
The parchment is particularly interesting. Found deep in the Money Pit, it’s tiny, but it’s made of animal skin (vellum). In the 1400s and 1500s, this was what you used for important documents. Is it a piece of a map? A ledger? A Shakespearean manuscript? The mystery is maddening.
🔗 Read more: Why Grand Funk’s Bad Time is Secretly the Best Pop Song of the 1970s
The Reality of the Search in 2026
Modern technology has changed the game. We're now seeing muon tomography—essentially X-raying the island using cosmic rays—and advanced sonic drilling. These aren't just guys with shovels anymore. They are pinpointing "anomalies" that show high-density objects or large voids at depths that would have been impossible for 18th-century miners to reach without insane engineering.
The core of the mystery remains the "Money Pit." Every time they think they've found it, they hit a flood trap or a collapse. It’s a defensive system that has worked for over 200 years.
How to Follow the Evidence Yourself
If you're fascinated by the hunt and want to dig deeper into the actual science behind the finds, there are a few things you can do to stay informed beyond just watching the show.
- Track the Muon Tomography results: This is the most likely way a "big" find will be confirmed. Keep an eye on reports regarding high-density voids in the Money Pit area.
- Study the Smith’s Cove Geochemical reports: The lead isotopes in the found artifacts are the "smoking gun" for European origins. Look for updates on the specific mines in France or Spain that match the lead cross.
- Visit the Oak Island Interpretive Centre: If you're ever in Nova Scotia, the museum on the island holds many of the actual artifacts, including the coins and tools found by the Restall and Blankenship families decades ago.
- Verify the "13-cent" Theory: Some researchers believe the treasure isn't at the bottom of the pit, but hidden in the various "offsets." Look into the work of Zena Halpern and the controversial Templar maps she provided to the team.
The search for the Curse of Oak Island found treasure isn't over. Whether it’s the Ark of the Covenant, Marie Antoinette’s jewels, or just the world's most elaborate 18th-century naval storehouse, the items recovered so far prove one thing: something happened on that island that shouldn't have been possible. And until the last hole is dug, the mystery stays alive.