You’ve seen the pink boxes. They’re everywhere. You can’t scroll through TikTok or walk through a suburban shopping center without seeing that distinct, minimalist branding. But the Crumbl cookies origin isn’t some boardroom-conceived corporate strategy. It started with two cousins, a bunch of stolen equipment from a family member, and a borderline obsessive quest for a chocolate chip cookie that didn't suck.
Jason McGowan and Sawyer Hemsley didn't have a background in professional baking. That’s the wild part. Jason was a tech guy. Sawyer was still finishing up his degree at Utah State University. In 2017, they decided they wanted to start a business together, and for some reason, they landed on cookies. Maybe it was the nostalgia, or maybe they just saw a massive hole in the late-night snack market in Logan, Utah. Regardless of the "why," the "how" was messy. They spent thousands of dollars on ingredients, baking batch after batch of cookies that were, frankly, mediocre. They were basically conducting a giant, expensive science experiment in a kitchen, A/B testing flour ratios and butter temperatures like they were optimizing a software landing page.
The Quest for the Perfect Chocolate Chip
The Crumbl cookies origin is defined by a single flavor: the Milk Chocolate Chip. Most bakeries use semi-sweet chips because that’s the "standard." Jason and Sawyer went the other way. They wanted something sweeter, richer, and more distinct. To get there, they didn't just ask their grandmas for recipes. They went to the streets.
They would literally stand outside grocery stores or gas stations and ask random strangers to taste-test two different versions of a cookie. "Which one is better? This one or that one?" It was brutal, real-time data collection. They’d take the feedback, go back to the kitchen, tweak the recipe, and do it again. This iterative process is a hallmark of tech startups, but applying it to a physical pastry was what gave them their edge. They eventually landed on the recipe that launched the brand—a thick, soft, milk chocolate chip cookie that stayed warm and felt "homemade" even if it was technically a commercial product.
Eventually, they opened their first storefront in Logan, Utah, in 2017. It was a humble start. They didn't even have a full menu back then. In fact, for a long time, they only served that one single chocolate chip cookie. That was it. No rotating flavors. No chilled sugar cookies. Just one really good, warm cookie available for takeout and delivery.
✨ Don't miss: Funny Team Work Images: Why Your Office Slack Channel Is Obsessed With Them
Scaling the Pink Box Phenomenon
Success happened fast. Like, scary fast. Within a few years, Crumbl went from a single shop in a college town to a nationwide franchise. But how? Most mom-and-pop bakeries stay mom-and-pop bakeries. The Crumbl cookies origin story shifts here from a kitchen experiment to a masterclass in modern business scaling.
They leaned into the "open kitchen" concept. They wanted people to see the eggs being cracked and the dough being balled. It built trust. Then came the branding. The pink box wasn't just a container; it was designed to be "Instagrammable" before that was even a tired cliché. The oblong shape was specifically engineered to fit the cookies perfectly side-by-side, making for a satisfying visual when you flipped the lid.
Then came the "Rotating Menu." This was the genius move. By 2018, they realized that while people loved the chocolate chip, they wanted variety. By introducing four to five new flavors every single week and taking them away the following Monday, they created a permanent state of "Fear Of Missing Out" (FOMO). It turned a simple cookie run into an event. People started filming "Crumbl Reviews" on social media, creating a free marketing machine that most brands would spend millions to replicate.
Why the Tech Background Mattered
Jason McGowan’s experience in the tech industry is the secret sauce behind the Crumbl cookies origin efficiency. While other bakeries were struggling with clunky point-of-sale systems, Crumbl built their own. Their app is one of the highest-rated in the food and drink category. They treated the logistics of delivery and franchise management like a tech stack. This allowed them to maintain quality control across hundreds of locations. If a cookie in Florida doesn't taste exactly like the one in Utah, the data shows it, and they fix it.
🔗 Read more: Mississippi Taxpayer Access Point: How to Use TAP Without the Headache
Common Misconceptions About the Start
Honestly, a lot of people think Crumbl was an overnight success backed by massive venture capital from day one. It wasn't. It was bootstrapped by family. There's also this weird rumor that they use cake mixes. They don't. Everything is made from scratch in the stores.
Another thing people get wrong is the "health" aspect. People love to point out the calorie counts. Let’s be real: no one goes to Crumbl for a salad. The brand has always been transparent about the fact that these are indulgent, oversized treats meant for sharing. The "cutting tool" they sell is a subtle nod to the fact that one cookie is technically four servings. It’s a brilliant bit of self-aware marketing.
The Logan Roots
Logan, Utah, is a specific kind of place. It’s a college town with a high density of families and a culture that values "treats" over bars or nightlife. Starting the Crumbl cookies origin here was strategic, even if it felt accidental at the time. They had a captive audience of students looking for late-night study snacks and families looking for a weekend reward. The community's feedback loop was tight and fast.
What Businesses Can Learn From the Crumbl Model
If you're looking at the Crumbl cookies origin for professional inspiration, there are a few non-obvious takeaways. It isn't just "sell cookies."
💡 You might also like: 60 Pounds to USD: Why the Rate You See Isn't Always the Rate You Get
- Focus on one thing first. They didn't launch with 50 flavors. They launched with one. They perfected the core product before diversifying.
- The packaging is the product. The pink box is arguably as valuable as the cookie recipe itself. It’s the brand’s visual shorthand.
- User-generated content is king. By making the product look good and changing the menu weekly, they gave customers a reason to talk about them every single week.
- Don't fear the pivot. They started with just chocolate chip, but they weren't too proud to change when they saw people wanted variety.
Actionable Steps for Exploring the Brand
If you’re interested in diving deeper into the world of Crumbl beyond just eating the cookies, here is how you can actually engage with the business side or the history:
Research the Franchise Disclosure Document (FDD): If you’re a business nerd, look up Crumbl’s FDD. It’s public record and shows the actual costs and earnings of their locations. It’s a fascinating look at the "pink empire" under the hood.
Track the Flavor Cycle: Use the Crumbl app to look at the "Graveyard." It shows every flavor they’ve ever made. Looking at how their recipes have evolved from simple cookies to complex, topping-heavy desserts tells the story of their brand evolution better than any article could.
Visit the Original Site: If you ever find yourself in Northern Utah, the original Logan location still has a different energy than the polished franchises in LA or NYC. It’s a reminder that every massive global brand started as a "what if" between two people who were willing to fail a lot before they got it right.
Audit Your Own Brand Identity: Look at your own projects. Are you trying to do too much at once? The Crumbl cookies origin teaches us that narrowing your focus to a single, high-quality "Minimum Viable Product" (the milk chocolate chip) is often the fastest way to eventually own the whole market.
The story of Crumbl is ultimately a story of two guys who didn't know the "rules" of the baking industry, so they made up their own. They treated cookies like software, and in doing so, they changed the way we think about the local bakery. It’s not just about the sugar; it’s about the system.