Honestly, if you haven’t stood under that massive white-columned portico on Commercial Street while a drag queen in seven-inch heels regales the sidewalk crowd, have you even been to Provincetown? Probably not. The Crown and Anchor hotel Provincetown isn’t just a place to sleep. It’s basically the town’s living room, its theater, and its most resilient survivor all rolled into one salt-sprayed complex.
But there is a lot of noise right now about what’s actually happening behind those famous doors.
In late 2025, the news hit that the Crown was being sold again. This time to Tristan Schukraft’s Tryst Hospitality. If you follow queer travel, you’ve heard the name. He’s the guy buying up iconic spots from Fire Island to Puerto Vallarta. People are worried. They’re asking if the "local" is being sucked out of P-town.
The Identity Crisis That Isn’t
Most people think the Crown and Anchor is just a hotel. It’s not. It’s an entertainment machine that happens to have seventeen rooms attached to it. For years, Jonathan Hawkins and Paolo Martini ran the show, focusing heavily on elevating queer arts. They didn’t just book acts; they curated a vibe. Now, as the property transitions to become The Tryst Provincetown in 2026, the community is watching the paint dry—literally.
The hotel is currently tucked away for a massive renovation. We’re talking updated bathrooms, better beds, and a lobby that doesn’t just feel like a pass-through to the bar.
✨ Don't miss: What Time in South Korea: Why the Peninsula Stays Nine Hours Ahead
The "Crown" name isn't disappearing from the building's soul, but the lodging side is getting a serious facelift. It needed it. Let’s be real: for a long time, you stayed at the Crown for the proximity to the party, not necessarily for the thread count. That's changing. The goal now is to marry that gritty, legendary nightlife with a luxury experience that doesn't feel like an afterthought.
Why the Crown and Anchor Hotel Provincetown Still Matters
You can’t talk about this place without talking about the fire. February 1998. It was one of the worst disasters in the town's history. The Whaler’s Wharf next door went up, and the Crown went with it. It was a skeleton.
But they rebuilt it in 1999, keeping that 19th-century "Central House" silhouette. That’s why the architecture feels weirdly historic and relatively modern at the same time. It’s a replica of a ghost.
The Six Bar Ecosystem
Most hotels have a lobby bar. The Crown has an ecosystem. You've got:
🔗 Read more: Where to Stay in Seoul: What Most People Get Wrong
- The Paramount: The big dog. It’s a high-energy nightclub where Jennifer Holliday or Billy Porter might be belting on stage one night, and a sweaty circuit party is happening the next.
- The Vault: Provincetown’s premier leather and levi bar. It’s dark, it’s cruisy, and it’s unapologetic.
- Wave Video Bar: Where you go to watch music videos and actually be able to hear your friends talk (mostly).
- The Cabaret: This is the heartbeat of the building. It’s intimate. It’s where you see the legends like Varla Jean Merman or Dina Martina.
If you’re staying in the hotel rooms during peak season, you have to know what you’re signing up for. It’s loud. It’s vibrant. If you want a silent retreat to read Tolstoy, go to the East End. You come here to be in the thick of it.
The Food Shuffle
There’s been some musical chairs with the dining situation lately. The Provincetown Brewing Co. moved into the restaurant space (historically called Central House) recently. It brought a more casual, "public house" feel to the front of the building. People used to go there for formal-ish seafood; now they’re going for smash burgers and local drafts.
Under the new 2026 Tryst management, everyone is wondering if the brewery stays or if a new concept moves in. Schukraft has hinted at keeping the local flair but adding the "Tryst" polish. Basically, expect the menu to get a bit more "Instagram-ready" by the time the 17 rooms reopen for the summer season.
What Most People Get Wrong About Booking
Here is the insider truth: booking a room at the Crown and Anchor hotel Provincetown is a strategic move, not just a transaction.
💡 You might also like: Red Bank Battlefield Park: Why This Small Jersey Bluff Actually Changed the Revolution
- The Balcony Hack: If you can snag a room with a balcony facing Commercial Street, you have the best seat in the house for Carnival or just the general 11:00 PM madness. It’s better than any TV show.
- The "Quiet" Side: There isn't really one, but the rooms facing the back toward the water are slightly more insulated from the street barkers. You get the harbor breeze instead of the drag queen's microphone feedback.
- The Pool Advantage: The pool at the Crown is legendary. It’s one of the few places in town where the "see and be seen" vibe is dialed up to eleven. Hotel guests get access, which is a golden ticket during Bear Week or July 4th when the deck is packed.
The 2026 Timeline
The property is closed from January through April 2026. If you’re trying to visit for a quiet spring weekend, you’re out of luck this year. They are gutting the rooms to rebrand as The Tryst. When it reopens in May, expect the prices to jump. This is no longer the "budget" option for people who just want to be near the clubs; it’s positioning itself as a boutique destination.
How to Actually Do the Crown and Anchor Right
If you're planning a trip, don't just show up and hope for the best. P-town is small, and the Crown is the sun that everything else orbits around.
- Buy show tickets early. Like, months early. If Dina Martina is performing, those seats vanish before you’ve even packed your swimsuit.
- Check the theme weeks. If you accidentally book during "Mates Leather Weekend" and you’re just a family of four looking for a beach holiday, you’re going to have some... interesting conversations with the kids.
- Use the Concierge. Because the owners are so plugged into the local scene, the staff at the Crown usually know which private house parties are happening or which "secret" beach spot isn't covered in seaweed that day.
Actionable Insights for Your Visit
To make the most of your stay or visit to the complex, keep these specific steps in mind:
- Monitor the 2026 Reopening: Follow their social media for the exact "soft opening" dates in May. These initial dates often have slightly lower rates before the summer madness kicks in.
- Prioritize The Cabaret: Even if you aren't staying at the hotel, book at least one show at the Crown Cabaret. It is the quintessential Provincetown experience.
- Plan Around Theme Weeks: Check the Provincetown Business Guild calendar. The vibe of the Crown shifts dramatically between Women's Week (October) and Bear Week (July). Match your energy to the week.
- Request Room 4 or 5: Traditionally, these have offered some of the better views of the harbor, though with the 2026 renovation, the room numbering and layout may see slight adjustments. Always ask for "waterfront view" when booking.
The Crown and Anchor is entering its "Tryst" era, but the DNA of the place—the salt air, the late-night bass thumping through the floorboards, and the absolute freedom to be whoever you want—isn't going anywhere. It's just getting better linens.