Honestly, if you picture a few hundred Spanish guys in shiny armor just walking into Mexico and taking over an entire empire, you’ve been sold a bit of a myth. History is messier. The Conquest of New Spain wasn't a clean military victory. It was a chaotic, bloody, and surprisingly political collapse of a superpower.
Think about it.
Hernán Cortés landed on the coast of Veracruz in 1519 with roughly 500 men. The Aztec Empire (the Triple Alliance) had a population in the millions and a warrior culture that lived for combat. The math doesn't work. If it were just Spaniards vs. Aztecs, the Spaniards would have been a footnote in a museum in Mexico City.
Instead, the fall of Tenochtitlan changed the entire world. It shifted the global economy toward the Atlantic. It created a new racial and cultural identity. But the way it happened—through a mix of biological warfare they didn't even realize they were carrying and some very shrewd local alliances—is way more interesting than the "great men" theory of history suggests.
The Myth of the "Small Group of Conquerors"
We love the narrative of the underdog. But Cortés wasn't an underdog; he was a catalyst. When we talk about the Conquest of New Spain, we have to talk about the Tlaxcalans.
👉 See also: Short Side Bangs with Short Hair: Why This Low-Maintenance Look Is Actually Hard to Get Right
They hated the Aztecs.
For years, the Triple Alliance had been squeezing surrounding tribes for tribute and sacrificial victims. The Tlaxcalans, the Totonacs, and dozens of other groups were tired of it. When the Spanish showed up, these indigenous groups didn't see "invaders from another world." They saw a tactical opportunity. They saw a new weapon they could point at their old enemies.
By the time the Spanish marched on Tenochtitlan for the final siege in 1521, Cortés had maybe 1,000 Spaniards. But he had tens of thousands of indigenous allies. This was a Mexican civil war as much as it was a Spanish conquest. Ross Hassig, a leading scholar on Mesoamerican warfare, has pointed out repeatedly that without this indigenous support, the Spanish wouldn't have survived the first month. They provided the food. They provided the scouts. They provided the bulk of the front-line infantry.
Steel, Germs, and a Whole Lot of Bad Timing
Steel swords matter. So do crossbows and early firearms like the arquebus. But let’s be real—reloading an arquebus in the humid Mexican heat while a thousand jaguar warriors are charging at you is a nightmare.
The real "superweapon" was invisible.
Smallpox hit Tenochtitlan at the absolute worst moment for the Aztecs. While the Spanish were licking their wounds after being kicked out of the city during the Noche Triste (the "Sad Night"), the virus was doing the work for them. It killed Cuitláhuac, the emperor who succeeded Moctezuma II. He was a brilliant military leader who actually knew how to beat the Spanish. When he died, the Aztecs lost their best chance at a coordinated counter-offensive.
It’s estimated that smallpox killed 40% of the population in the Valley of Mexico in just one year. Imagine your entire government, your generals, and your farmers all dying at once. The Conquest of New Spain was essentially won because the Spanish were accidentally carrying a biological nuke.
Why the "Superiority" Argument is Garbage
Some older textbooks claim the Aztecs thought the Spanish were gods. Specifically, the myth of Quetzalcoatl returning.
Most modern historians, like Matthew Restall in Seven Myths of the Spanish Conquest, argue this was largely a post-conquest invention. It was a way for the Spanish to justify their victory and for the defeated Aztecs to explain why they lost. "We didn't lose because we were outfought; we lost because the gods willed it."
The Aztecs were sophisticated. They knew the Spanish were men. They saw them bleed. They saw them die. They just didn't have an answer for the specific combination of shifting tribal loyalties and a plague that hit right when they needed to be at their strongest.
Malintzin: The Woman Who Actually Built New Spain
You can't understand the Conquest of New Spain without talking about Malintzin, often called La Malinche.
She was an enslaved Nahua woman given to Cortés as a gift. She spoke Mayan and Nahuatl. Later, she learned Spanish. She wasn't just a translator; she was a diplomatic strategist. She could read the room. She knew the political grievances of the local lords and told Cortés exactly what to say to flip them.
👉 See also: Dr Becky Potty Training: What Most People Get Wrong
In Mexico today, her legacy is... complicated. Some see her as the ultimate traitor. Others see her as the mother of the Mestizo people. Regardless of how you feel, she was the one who navigated the linguistic minefield that allowed the Spanish to survive long enough to make alliances. Without her, Cortés is just another guy who got lost in the jungle.
The Siege of Tenochtitlan: A 16th-Century Apocalypse
The end came in August 1521.
Tenochtitlan was a city on a lake. It was beautiful—canals, floating gardens (chinampas), and massive stone temples. To take it, the Spanish had to build brigantines (small ships) and launch them into the lake to cut off the city's food supply.
It was a slow, grinding, horrific siege.
The Aztecs fought for every single house. They stripped the gold off the Spanish horses and threw it in the water. But you can't fight hunger and smallpox forever. When the city finally fell, it wasn't a proud handover of power. It was a ruin. The Spanish literally built Mexico City on top of the rubble of Tenochtitlan, using the same stones from the Great Temple to build their cathedrals.
Beyond the War: The Economic Pivot
Why does this matter in 2026?
Because the Conquest of New Spain wasn't just a local war. It was the birth of the global economy. Before this, Europe was a bit of a backwater compared to China or the Ottoman Empire. After the conquest, the sheer amount of silver coming out of mines like Zacatecas flooded the world.
It paid for the Spanish Empire's wars in Europe. It ended up in China to pay for silk and tea. It fundamentally changed the value of money. We are still living in the world that silver created.
What We Get Wrong About the Aftermath
People assume that once Tenochtitlan fell, the "Conquest" was over.
Nope.
The conquest of the North and the South (the Mayan territories) took decades—centuries in some cases. The Chichimeca War in the north was a brutal guerrilla conflict that the Spanish basically couldn't win with weapons. They eventually had to "buy" peace by providing the tribes with food and supplies, a policy called paz por compra.
The Conquest of New Spain was a series of local negotiations, small-scale wars, and cultural blendings that lasted long after Cortés was dead.
Actionable Insights for History Buffs and Travelers
If you want to actually "see" this history, don't just look at the statues.
- Visit Tlatelolco: Most people go to the Zócalo, but Tlatelolco (the Plaza of the Three Cultures) is where the final surrender happened. There’s a plaque there that says something beautiful: "It was neither a victory nor a defeat. It was the painful birth of the mestizo nation that is Mexico today."
- Read the Indigenous Accounts: Check out The Broken Spears by Miguel León-Portilla. It’s a collection of Nahuatl accounts of the conquest. It’s haunting to read the descriptions of the plague and the confusion from the perspective of the people who actually lived it.
- Trace the Silver: If you’re in Mexico, head to Guanajuato or Taxco. The architecture there exists because of the wealth extracted in the wake of the conquest. It’s stunning, but it’s a physical manifestation of the colonial system.
- Look at the Food: Almost everything we think of as "Mexican food" is a result of this collision. Pork, beef, dairy, and cilantro came from Spain. Chilis, tomatoes, corn, and chocolate were already there. The kitchen was the first place the conquest truly ended and the new culture began.
The Conquest of New Spain wasn't a movie. It wasn't a simple story of "civilization" meeting "savagery." It was a collision of two complex, violent, and deeply religious worlds that produced something entirely new. We’re still trying to figure out how to navigate the fallout of that collision today.