You’re standing in the backyard, staring at a pile of grey ash while your guests hover around the patio table with empty plates. The charcoal isn't ready. It’s been forty minutes. You realize, too late, that you should’ve just used gas, but you wanted that smoky flavor. This is exactly why the combination propane charcoal grill exists. It’s a peace treaty between two warring factions of the BBQ world.
Honestly, it’s a weird machine. You’ve got a massive steel box taking up half your deck, split right down the middle like a culinary Jekyll and Hyde. One side offers the instant gratification of propane—click, whoosh, heat. The other side demands the slow, meditative ritual of lump charcoal or briquettes. Most people buy these because they’re indecisive. They want the Monday night convenience of a quick grilled chicken breast and the Saturday afternoon glory of a slow-seared ribeye.
But here’s the thing: most of these "dual-fuel" beasts are built like tin cans. If you buy a cheap one at a big-box store, you'll likely see it rusting out in three seasons because the manufacturer spent the budget on features rather than steel quality.
The Dual-Fuel Reality Check
Let’s talk about the physics of it. A combination propane charcoal grill has to manage two completely different types of heat. Gas is consistent and directional. Charcoal is radiant, chaotic, and incredibly hot. When you cram both into one chassis, you often end up with "jack of all trades, master of none" syndrome.
Take the Oklahoma Joe’s Longhorn Combo, for example. It’s a heavy-duty beast. It’s got a massive footprint. But if you aren’t careful with the seals, the smoke from the charcoal side can leak into the gas side, which sounds cool until you realize you're just getting soot on your "clean" gas burners. People love the idea of "everything in one place," but they forget that these units are heavy. Like, "don't try to move this on grass" heavy.
You’ve gotta think about the airflow. In a dedicated charcoal kettle, like a Weber, the bowl shape is designed specifically to circulate air. In a combo unit, you’re usually dealing with square or rectangular fireboxes. This changes how the coal burns. It’s not necessarily worse, but it’s different. You have to learn the hotspots all over again.
Why the Propane Side is Your Best Friend (and Worst Enemy)
The gas side of a combination propane charcoal grill is usually pretty standard. You get three burners, maybe a side sear station if you’re fancy. It’s perfect for hot dogs, corn on the cob, or a quick salmon fillet.
But here is a secret: the gas side often serves as the "starter" for the charcoal side. Expert grillers—the ones who don't want to mess with lighter fluid—will sometimes use a propane torch or even the side burner to get a charcoal chimney started. It’s efficient. However, the downside is the maintenance. You now have gas lines, valves, and igniters sitting right next to a high-heat charcoal firebox. Heat degrades components. If the insulation between the two chambers isn't top-tier, the intense heat from a charcoal sear can actually wear down the seals on your gas valves over time.
Meathead Goldwyn, the guy behind AmazingRibs.com and a certified legend in the pitmaster world, often points out that temperature control is the soul of great BBQ. On the gas side, you have knobs. On the charcoal side, you have dampers. Managing both simultaneously during a big party is a workout. It’s not "set it and forget it."
The Durability Gap
- Materials matter: Look for porcelain-coated cast iron grates. They hold heat on the gas side and withstand the abuse of charcoal.
- Gauge of steel: If the lid feels light, walk away. Thin steel loses heat, meaning you’ll burn through propane and charcoal twice as fast.
- The "Third Side": Many combos, like the Char-Griller Duo, offer an optional side firebox. Now you’ve turned a dual-fuel grill into a triple-threat smoker. But beware: more surface area means more places for rust to hide.
What Most People Get Wrong About Flavor
There’s a common myth that you can "taste the gas." You can’t. Science says so. If your gas-grilled food tastes "off," your burners are dirty or your grease tray is full of old gunk. The real difference is the sear.
🔗 Read more: IHOP Kansas City KS Legends: Why This 24/7 Spot Still Rules Village West
A combination propane charcoal grill allows you to do something called "reverse searing" perfectly. You start a thick steak on the gas side at a very low temperature (around 225°F) until the internal temp hits about 115°F. Then, you move it over to the screaming-hot charcoal side for sixty seconds to get that Maillard reaction—that crusty, salty, delicious exterior. You can’t do that easily on a single-fuel grill without a lot of waiting around for temps to change.
The Hidden Logistics of Owning a Combo
Where are you going to put it? No, seriously.
These things are wide. A standard 3-burner gas grill is maybe 50 inches wide. A combination propane charcoal grill can easily push 70 inches. If you have a small deck, it’s going to feel like you parked a Vespa in your kitchen.
Then there’s the fuel storage. You need a propane tank (and a backup, because it always runs out at 6:00 PM on a Sunday). You also need bags of charcoal. And a chimney starter. And maybe wood chunks. Your garage is about to get very crowded.
I’ve seen people buy these and then only use the gas side for six months because they’re "too busy" for charcoal. If that’s you, don't buy a combo. You’re paying for a heavy, rusting charcoal chamber you aren't using. Buy a combo only if you actually enjoy the process of fire.
Maintenance is a Double Chore
Cleaning a gas grill is easy: burn off the residue and scrape the grates. Cleaning a charcoal grill is messy: you’ve got ash. Ash is alkaline. When ash gets wet from humidity or a light rain, it turns into a corrosive paste that eats through steel.
In a combination propane charcoal grill, the ash from the right side can blow over (if not sealed well) or the moisture from the gas combustion (water vapor is a byproduct of burning propane) can settle in the charcoal side. You have to be meticulous. You need to vacuum out that ash every single time. Every. Single. Time.
Real-World Recommendations
If you’re looking for the "Goldilocks" of this category, names like Blackstone, Pit Boss, and Camp Chef usually pop up.
- The Heavy Hitter: Oklahoma Joe’s Longhorn. It’s heavy. It’s steel. It’s a workout to assemble. But it holds heat like a vault.
- The Tech-Forward Option: Pit Boss makes some units that incorporate pellet smoking into the mix. This is getting into "franken-grill" territory, but for the gadget-obsessed, it’s a playground.
- The Budget Entry: Char-Griller. They are cheaper. They will rust if you don't season them like a cast-iron skillet. But if you're on a budget and want to try the dual-fuel life, it's a low-risk entry point.
Is it actually worth it?
Kinda. It depends on your personality.
If you are the type of person who loves tinkering with air vents while sipping a beer, but also wants to be able to cook burgers for the kids in 10 minutes on a Tuesday, then yes. It’s the perfect compromise. If you’re a "purist," you’ll hate it because neither side is as good as a dedicated, high-end standalone unit.
Actionable Steps for New Owners
Don't just buy the thing and throw a steak on it.
First, season the whole interior. Treat the charcoal side like a cast-iron pan. Wipe the inside walls with a thin layer of flaxseed or vegetable oil and run a medium-hot fire for an hour. This creates a polymer coating that fights rust.
🔗 Read more: Why E Pellicci in London is Still the Only Place That Matters
Second, get a high-quality cover. This is non-negotiable. Because these grills have so many joints and seams (where the two sides meet), they are prone to water ingress. A $50 cover will save you from buying a new $600 grill in two years.
Third, buy a dual-probe thermometer. Don't trust the thermometers built into the lid. They are notoriously inaccurate—sometimes off by as much as 50 degrees because they measure the air at the top of the dome, not where the meat is sitting.
The combination propane charcoal grill is the ultimate tool for the backyard generalist. It’s big, it’s bold, and it’s a little bit ridiculous. But when you’ve got a rack of ribs smoking on the left and some halloumi grilling on the right, you’ll feel like the king of the neighborhood. Just remember to vacuum the ash. Seriously.
Next Steps for the Aspiring Pitmaster
- Measure your space: Ensure you have at least 2 feet of clearance behind the grill for the lids to open and for heat safety.
- Inventory your fuel: Buy a translucent propane tank or a scale so you never guess your fuel level again.
- Clean the "Vitals": Every 5 cooks, check the gas burner ports for spider webs or clogs, which are common in outdoor storage.
- Master the Zone: Practice "two-zone" cooking on the charcoal side by piling coals to one side, using the other for indirect heat.