Honestly, whenever the holidays roll around, people get these movies confused. It’s inevitable. You've got The Princess Switch on Netflix with Vanessa Hudgens, but then there’s the actual movie titled The Christmas Switch. They are different. Totally different. If you’re looking for the 2014 film—the one involving a gambling addict and a smooth-talking mall Santa—you’re in the right place. The Christmas Switch cast isn't full of A-list Marvel stars, but it has that specific brand of "TV movie" chemistry that makes the whole body-swap trope actually watchable.
Most people click into these movies for the comfort of the predictable. We know how it ends. We know the grumpy guy becomes nice. But the actors are the ones who have to sell the "soul-swapping" magic without making it look completely ridiculous. In this case, you have Brian Krause and Natasha Henstridge leading the charge.
The Heavy Lifters: Brian Krause and Cooper Koch
Let's talk about Brian Krause. If you grew up in the late 90s or early 2000s, he’s Leo from Charmed. He’s got that "reliable guy" energy. In this movie, he plays Eddie Bennett. Eddie is... well, he’s a bit of a mess. He’s a gambler. He’s looking for a shortcut.
Then there’s the younger version. Well, not exactly a younger version, but the body he inhabits.
The movie uses a classic "Freaky Friday" mechanism. Eddie (Krause) ends up in the body of Sam (played by Cooper Koch). This is where the Christmas Switch cast gets interesting. Cooper Koch has since gone on to do some pretty intense work—most notably in Ryan Murphy’s Monsters: The Lyle and Erik Menendez Story. Seeing him here in a 2014 holiday movie is a trip. He has to play a man who is essentially a middle-aged loser trapped in a young, handsome body. It’s a lot of physical acting.
Natasha Henstridge and the Supporting Players
You can’t talk about this cast without mentioning Natasha Henstridge. She plays Susan Wells. Most people remember her from Species or The Whole Nine Yards. Here, she’s the grounding force. While the guys are swapping souls and dealing with the "magic" of the season, she provides the emotional stakes.
🔗 Read more: Blink-182 Mark Hoppus: What Most People Get Wrong About His 2026 Comeback
The dynamic works because she doesn't play it like a cartoon.
There's also Cedric Smith as Sam. No, not the young Sam, but the "older" Sam—the mall Santa figure who facilitates the whole mess. Cedric Smith has one of those voices you just recognize. He was Professor X in the original X-Men animated series. When he speaks, you listen. He brings a level of gravitas to a movie that could have easily felt like a cheap Hallmark knockoff.
- Brian Krause as Eddie Bennett: The guy who needs to learn a lesson.
- Natasha Henstridge as Susan Wells: The heart of the film.
- Cedric Smith as Old Sam: The magical catalyst.
- Cooper Koch as Young Sam: The vessel for Eddie’s transformation.
Why This Specific Cast Works for the Trope
The body-swap genre is crowded. You've got Big, 17 Again, and a dozen others. Why does the Christmas Switch cast stand out to people who stumble upon it on UpTV or Prime Video?
It’s the sincerity.
Brian Krause plays desperation really well. You actually believe Eddie is at the end of his rope. When the switch happens, the contrast between Krause's weathered look and Koch's youthful energy drives the comedy. But it's not all jokes. The movie tries—and mostly succeeds—at showing the frustration of not being recognized by the people you love.
💡 You might also like: Why Grand Funk’s Bad Time is Secretly the Best Pop Song of the 1970s
Usually, these movies fail because the actors play the "new" personality too big. They do the "Whoa, I have hands!" thing for forty minutes. Here, the transition is faster. It focuses more on the consequences of Eddie's past mistakes.
The Legacy of the 2014 Version vs. The Netflix Giant
We have to address the elephant in the room. If you search for "Christmas Switch," Google is probably going to scream The Princess Switch at you.
Vanessa Hudgens didn't invent the holiday swap.
The 2014 The Christmas Switch is a humbler production. It was directed by Paul Lynch. It doesn't have the European castle budget or the triple-role gimmick. It’s a story about a guy who realizes that being young again doesn't matter if you’re still the same selfish person inside.
The Christmas Switch cast had to do more with less. They didn't have flashy costumes or pop-star marketing. They had a mall set and a script about redemption.
📖 Related: Why La Mera Mera Radio is Actually Dominating Local Airwaves Right Now
Does the Cast Hold Up Today?
Looking back at this movie over a decade later, it’s a time capsule. It was filmed in Canada (like almost every holiday movie ever). You can see the roots of Cooper Koch’s career before he became a household name in prestige TV.
It’s also a reminder that Brian Krause is a very capable lead. He’s spent a lot of his career in B-movies and TV guest spots, but he has a screen presence that feels very "everyman." He’s relatable.
If you're watching this for the first time, don't expect Succession levels of acting. Expect a cozy, slightly cheesy, but ultimately well-acted story about second chances. The chemistry between the leads is what saves it from being forgettable. They actually seem to care about the characters, which is more than you can say for some of the "assembly line" holiday movies we see now.
Final Takeaways for Your Watchlist
If you are planning a marathon and want to include this film, keep a few things in mind. First, verify you are watching the 2014 version directed by Paul Lynch. Second, pay attention to the smaller roles; you’ll see several Canadian character actors who pop up in almost every production filmed in Ontario.
Next Steps for Holiday Movie Fans:
To get the most out of this specific sub-genre, compare the performances in The Christmas Switch with other soul-swap classics. Watch Brian Krause’s performance and see how he handles the "old man in a young body" tropes compared to Zac Efron in 17 Again. Then, check out Cooper Koch’s more recent work to see just how much he has evolved as a performer since his days as Sam.
Verify the streaming platform before you settle in, as titles this similar often get shuffled between services like Peacock, Tubi, and Freevee depending on the month.