Believe it or not, people actually thought a smelly mammal could dictate the fate of a multi-billion-dollar baseball franchise for seven decades. It sounds ridiculous now. After 2016, we can all laugh about it. But for a long time, the Chicago Cubs goat curse wasn't just some quirky piece of trivia; it was a psychological weight that felt as heavy as the iron girders holding up Wrigley Field's upper deck.
It started with a guy named William Sianis. He was a Greek immigrant who owned the Billy Goat Tavern, a spot that's still a staple for Chicago reporters and burger lovers today. On October 6, 1945, Sianis decided to take his pet goat, Murphy, to Game 4 of the World Series. He had tickets. He had the goat. He even had a little blanket for the goat that said "Alaska."
The usher at the gate wasn't having it.
Even though Sianis had paid for the seats, P.K. Wrigley—the man whose name is on the stadium—personally ordered the goat removed. Why? Because the animal smelled. That’s the official story, anyway. As Sianis was being booted out, he supposedly threw his arms up and declared that the Cubs would never win another World Series. Or, as the legend goes: "Them Cubs, they ain't gonna win no more."
The Science of a 71-Year Drought
Let's be real: goats don't control the flight path of a baseball. But the Chicago Cubs goat curse became a convenient shorthand for decades of institutional failure and bad luck. For 71 years, the Cubs didn't just fail to win it all; they failed to even reach the World Series.
📖 Related: Matthew Berry Positional Rankings: Why They Still Run the Fantasy Industry
The curse wasn't a singular event. It was a collection of "almosts" that defied the laws of probability. You had the 1969 collapse. You had the 1984 NLCS where a routine ground ball went through Leon Durham's legs. Then, of course, there was 2003.
The 2003 season is where the curse moved from "funny story" to "dark obsession." Steve Bartman. Five outs away from the World Series. A foul ball. He reached for it, just like any other fan would. Moises Alou threw a tantrum. The floodgates opened. The Cubs conceded eight runs in that inning. People didn't blame the pitcher, Mark Prior, for losing his command. They didn't blame Alex Gonzalez for booting a double-play ball. They blamed the goat, channeled through a guy in a turtleneck and headphones.
It's fascinating how humans look for patterns in chaos. When a team loses for seven decades, you look for a supernatural explanation because the alternative—that your team is just poorly managed—is too painful to accept.
Why the Curse Actually Lasted So Long
If we move away from the mystical stuff, the "curse" was actually a series of bad front-office decisions. For years, the Cubs were behind the curve on scouting and player development. While the Cardinals and Dodgers were building modern farm systems, the Cubs were often relying on aging veterans or flashy trades that didn't pan out.
👉 See also: What Time Did the Cubs Game End Today? The Truth About the Off-Season
- Underinvestment in Pitching: For large chunks of the 70s and 80s, the Cubs struggled to develop homegrown "aces."
- The Day Game Disadvantage: Wrigley didn't have lights until 1988. Playing every home game in the afternoon heat was physically draining compared to teams playing in air-conditioned domes or under the stars.
- The "Lovable Losers" Brand: Marketing the team as a bunch of charming underdogs might have been good for beer sales, but it didn't necessarily foster a "win-at-all-costs" culture.
Breaking the Chicago Cubs Goat Curse
Everything changed when Theo Epstein arrived. He didn't care about goats. He didn't care about "The Curse of the Bambino" in Boston, and he didn't care about Sianis. He cared about On-Base Percentage and high-ceiling prospects.
The 2016 season felt different, but the "curse" still tried to make an appearance. In Game 7 of the World Series against Cleveland, the Cubs had a lead. Then Rajai Davis hit a home run that leveled the world. It felt like 1945 all over again. The rain delay that followed was like a cosmic timeout. Jason Heyward gave a speech in the weight room. The clouds parted.
When Mike Montgomery got Michael Martinez to hit a slow roller to Kris Bryant, the Chicago Cubs goat curse evaporated. Bryant was smiling before he even threw the ball to first base.
The curse died because the talent on the field finally outweighed the ghost of a tavern owner's pet. It took 108 years of waiting and 71 years of specific "goat-related" anxiety, but the hex was finally buried.
✨ Don't miss: Jake Ehlinger Sign: The Real Story Behind the College GameDay Controversy
Practical Lessons from the Legend
If you're looking for the takeaway here, it isn't about how to avoid offending livestock. It's about psychology. The curse stayed alive because the fans—and sometimes the players—believed in it.
- Don't mistake bad management for bad luck. Most "curses" in sports can be solved with a better scouting department and a higher payroll.
- Narratives are powerful. Once a story like the goat curse takes hold, every negative event is viewed through that lens, creating a self-fulfilling prophecy of dread.
- Focus on the process. The 2016 Cubs won because they built a roster that was statistically superior, not because they performed an exorcism (though some fans certainly tried).
If you want to dive deeper into the history of Wrigley Field, go visit the Billy Goat Tavern on lower Michigan Avenue. Look at the photos on the wall. Smell the "Cheezborger." It’s a reminder that sometimes a great story is just a great story, even if it takes a lifetime to reach the final chapter.
For anyone visiting Chicago to see the Cubs, start your day at the intersection of Clark and Addison. Stand under the marquee. Look at the retired numbers on the flagpoles. The goat is gone, but the history remains. Go to the Billy Goat Tavern for a burger before the game, not to appease a ghost, but because it's a damn good burger.