You’re walking down a quiet street in Chicago, maybe near the Green Mill or deep in the Loop, and you start thinking about the ghosts. It’s impossible not to. This city is built on layers of history, some of it polished for tourists and some of it smelling like stale beer and gunsmoke. When people talk about finding a Chicago Al Capone bar, they usually want two things: a cold drink and a genuine connection to the 1920s. But here’s the thing—Capone wasn’t just sitting at one mahogany counter every night. He owned the city. Or at least, his "outfit" did.
Finding the real spots is tricky because every basement with a wooden door claims to be a speakeasy nowadays.
Chicago in the 1920s was a war zone disguised as a party. The Volstead Act didn't stop people from drinking; it just made it more interesting. The "Scarface" legacy is plastered all over the city, but if you want the truth, you have to look past the neon signs. You have to look at the trap doors, the tunnels, and the bullet holes that the owners refuse to patch up.
The Green Mill: Where the Booth Still Waits
If you only visit one spot, make it the Green Mill Cocktail Lounge in Uptown. This isn’t a recreation. It’s the real deal. Back in the day, it was part-owned by Jack "Machine Gun" McGurn, who was one of Capone’s most trusted (and violent) associates.
There’s a specific booth. You’ll see it right away because it offers a clear view of both the front and back doors. That was Capone’s seat. He wasn't being social; he was being careful.
The Green Mill still feels heavy with that history. The jazz is loud, the lights are low, and the curved leather booths look like they haven’t been changed since 1924. Behind the bar, there’s a trap door. It leads to a series of tunnels that used to connect to nearby buildings, allowing for a quick getaway when the feds decided to ruin the fun. Honestly, standing there at 1 AM with a gin fizz in your hand, you can almost hear the sirens.
It’s one of the few places where the "Chicago Al Capone bar" legend actually holds up under scrutiny. Most historians, including those who have documented the Outfit's reach like Robert J. Schoenberg, point to the Mill as a primary hub for the gang’s North Side influence.
The Mystery of the Underground Tunnels
Why were these tunnels so common?
✨ Don't miss: What Time in South Korea: Why the Peninsula Stays Nine Hours Ahead
Chicago is a city of alleys and basements. During Prohibition, the "Outfit" ran a logistics empire that would make Amazon jealous. They needed ways to move crates of "temptation" without being seen by the "untouchables."
Take a look at the history of the Jewelers’ Building. It’s a gorgeous piece of architecture, but it had a secret: a car elevator. Legend has it that during the height of the 1920s, high-ranking gangsters would drive their cars straight into the elevator, be whisked up to a hidden speakeasy on the upper floors, and drink in total anonymity. No walking across the sidewalk. No risk.
Some people say the tunnels are just a myth. They aren't. While many have been filled with concrete over the decades for structural reasons, plenty of basement excavations in the West Loop and South Side still turn up reinforced rooms and bricked-over passageways that lead nowhere.
Harry Caray’s and the Nitti Connection
You wouldn't expect a famous steakhouse to be a hub of criminal history, but Harry Caray’s Italian Steakhouse in the River North neighborhood sits in a building once owned by Frank Nitti.
Nitti was Capone’s "Enforcer." He was the guy who kept the wheels turning while Al was the face of the operation. When the building was being renovated, workers found a hidden room behind a wall in the basement. They found a safe. They found a series of telephone wires that were used to run a "wire service" for illegal gambling.
- The basement is basically a museum now.
- You can see the old safes.
- There are ledgers that detail the business of being a "businessman" during the dark years.
- It’s a weirdly domestic look at how organized crime operated.
It wasn't all tommy guns and car chases. Most of it was math. It was keeping track of who owed what and which precinct captains had been paid off. This is the side of the Chicago Al Capone bar story that most movies skip over. It was a business. A bloody, ruthless, highly profitable business.
The Myth of the "Capone Bar" Everywhere
Let’s be real for a second. If every bar that claimed Al Capone drank there was telling the truth, the man would have died of liver failure by 1922.
🔗 Read more: Where to Stay in Seoul: What Most People Get Wrong
Marketing is a powerful drug. You’ll find bars in the suburbs, bars in Wisconsin, and bars in Florida all claiming to be "Capone’s favorite." In Chicago, the label is often used to describe any place with a pre-war aesthetic.
But there’s a difference between a place where Al Capone had a drink once and a place that was part of his ecosystem. The real spots—like the now-defunct Lexington Hotel where he lived—weren't always glamorous. They were functional.
If you’re looking for the vibe, you go to the speakeasies that survived. You go to places like Exchequer Restaurant & Pub, which used to be a speakeasy called the 226 Club. It’s rumored that Capone was a frequent guest because it was close to his headquarters. The walls are covered in memorabilia, and while some of it is for show, the bones of the building don’t lie.
How to Spot a Fake
How do you know if you're standing in a genuine historical site or just a tourist trap with overpriced cocktails?
First, look at the architecture. True speakeasies weren't usually at street level with huge windows. They were in basements, behind pharmacies, or tucked inside "social clubs." Second, check the records. The Chicago Historical Society has extensive files on the raids conducted during the 1920s. If a place was never raided, it either wasn't a speakeasy or the owner was paying a lot of money to the police.
Most "Al Capone bars" you see on TikTok are just 1920s-themed lounges. There’s nothing wrong with that! The drinks are usually better at the new places anyway. But if you want the shiver down your spine, you have to go where the wood is scarred and the air feels a little thinner.
The Legacy of the Outfit
Why are we still obsessed with this guy a century later?
💡 You might also like: Red Bank Battlefield Park: Why This Small Jersey Bluff Actually Changed the Revolution
Capone was a monster, flat out. He was responsible for the St. Valentine’s Day Massacre. He ordered hits like people order pizzas. Yet, there’s this weird romanticism about the era. Maybe it’s the rebellion against a law that everyone thought was stupid. Maybe it’s the fashion.
Whatever it is, the Chicago Al Capone bar is a staple of the city’s identity. It represents a time when Chicago was the wildest place on Earth. It was a city of "Big Shoulders" and even bigger egos.
When you sit at the bar at a place like Twin Anchors in Old Town, which has its own history with the Mob (and later, Frank Sinatra), you aren't just buying a beer. You’re buying into the legend. You’re sitting where guys with nicknames like "Greasy Thumb" and "Hymie" used to argue over turf.
What to Do Next
If you’re planning a night out to chase the ghost of Scarface, don't just wing it. The city is big, and the real spots are spread out.
- Start at the Green Mill. Go early, around 8 PM, to snag a booth before the jazz crowd packs the place. Respect the "no talking during the set" rule.
- Take a "Gangsters and Ghosts" tour. Yeah, it’s touristy. Do it anyway. The guides usually have access to stories and specific alleyways you’d never find on your own.
- Visit the Chicago History Museum. See the actual tools of the trade. It puts the bars in perspective.
- Head to River North for dinner. Eat at Harry Caray’s and ask to see the Nitti vaults.
Keep your eyes open. Chicago doesn't always advertise its secrets. Sometimes the most authentic Chicago Al Capone bar is just an unmarked door in a brick wall that you’ve walked past a dozen times.
The history is there, buried under a hundred years of Lake Michigan wind and new construction. You just have to know where to dig. Just don't ask too many questions if you see someone sitting in the corner booth with their back to the wall. Some traditions never die.
Actionable Insights for Your Visit:
- Logistics: Most historic bars in Chicago are cash-only or have a stiff cover charge during live music—bring bills.
- Timing: To see the "Capone Booth" at the Green Mill without the crowd, try a weekday afternoon right when they open.
- Verification: Use the Chicago Tribune digital archives to look up the address of any "speakeasy" you visit; the raid reports from 1921–1933 are surprisingly detailed.
- Etiquette: These are working bars, not museums. Buy a drink, tip your bartender well, and don't treat the regulars like props in a movie.