Nobody expected much from Chester A. Arthur. Honestly, most people in 1881 were actually terrified of him.
When President James A. Garfield was shot by a crazed office-seeker who shouted, "I am a Stalwart and Arthur will be President!" the nation shuddered. To the public, Arthur was basically the poster child for political corruption. He was a "machine" guy—a dapper, silk-hat-wearing New York lawyer who had spent years handing out government jobs to his buddies like candy at a parade.
Then, he did something nobody saw coming. He became a good president.
The Man Behind the Mutton Chops
Before we get into the politics, you’ve gotta understand the vibe of the man. Chester A. Arthur was nicknamed "Elegant Arthur" for a reason. He reportedly owned 80 pairs of pants. He didn't even move into the White House right away because he thought it looked like a "badly kept barracks." Instead, he hired Louis Comfort Tiffany—yes, that Tiffany—to redesign the place.
But behind the fancy clothes and late-night dinners, Arthur was a man of surprising depth. Long before he was in the White House, he was a young lawyer in New York. In 1854, he represented Elizabeth Jennings Graham, a Black woman who had been forcibly removed from a whites-only streetcar.
Arthur won the case.
That victory actually led to the desegregation of the New York City public transit system. It’s a detail that often gets buried under his later reputation as a "spoilsman," but it shows that the man had a moral compass, even if he kept it in his pocket most of the time.
📖 Related: Why Fox Has a Problem: The Identity Crisis at the Top of Cable News
Why Everyone Thought He’d Be a Disaster
For years, Arthur was the right-hand man to Roscoe Conkling, the boss of the New York Republican machine. This group, the "Stalwarts," lived and breathed the spoils system. Basically, if you helped the party win, you got a government job, regardless of whether you could actually read or write.
Arthur was the Collector of the Port of New York, a position that made him incredibly wealthy through a legal-but-shady system of fines and kickbacks. When President Rutherford B. Hayes fired him for being a symbol of corruption, it should have been the end of his career.
Instead, through a weird series of political compromises at the 1880 convention, he ended up as Vice President. Then, the unthinkable happened. Garfield died, and the "Prince of Patronage" was suddenly the leader of the free world.
The Great Pivot: The Pendleton Act
This is where the story gets really interesting. Everyone—especially his old boss Conkling—expected Arthur to open the floodgates of corruption. They thought it was "payday."
Arthur said no.
In 1883, he signed the Pendleton Civil Service Reform Act. This was basically a slap in the face to every political friend he ever had. It established that federal jobs should be awarded based on merit—competitive exams—rather than political loyalty.
👉 See also: The CIA Stars on the Wall: What the Memorial Really Represents
Imagine a modern politician suddenly dismantling the very system that gave them power. That’s what Arthur did. He knew the spoils system had led to Garfield’s death, and he chose the country over his cronies.
A Secret That Was Slowly Killing Him
There’s a reason Arthur seemed a bit sluggish or detached during his final years in office. He was dying.
In October 1882, Arthur was diagnosed with Bright’s Disease, a fatal kidney condition (today we’d call it glomerulonephritis). He kept it a complete secret from the public. He was exhausted, in pain, and his body was essentially poisoning itself.
He didn't have the energy to fight for a second term, and honestly, he probably knew he wouldn't live to see the end of it anyway. He burned almost all of his personal papers just before he died in 1886, which is why historians have such a hard time getting "inside his head." He wanted his private life to stay private.
What Really Happened With the Chinese Exclusion Act?
We have to talk about the messy parts, too. Arthur’s record on immigration is complicated. In 1882, Congress passed a bill that would have banned Chinese immigration for 20 years.
Arthur actually vetoed it.
✨ Don't miss: Passive Resistance Explained: Why It Is Way More Than Just Standing Still
He argued that 20 years was a breach of existing treaties. He wasn't necessarily a modern civil rights hero—he still signed a revised version that limited the ban to 10 years—but he was one of the few voices at the time trying to pull back on the extreme xenophobia of the era.
Why He Still Matters (Kinda)
Arthur isn't usually on anyone’s "Top 10" list, but he’s the reason the "Steel Navy" exists. Before him, the U.S. Navy was a joke—mostly rotting wooden ships left over from the Civil War. Arthur pushed for the construction of modern, steel-protected cruisers, laying the groundwork for the U.S. to become a global power.
He was a man who rose to the occasion. He wasn't a saint, and he definitely liked his fancy dinners and expensive cigars too much, but he proved that the office can change the man.
Actionable Insights: Lessons from the 21st President
- Look for the "Pivot" Potential: Just because someone has a "checkered" past doesn't mean they can't govern with integrity. Arthur is the ultimate example of a "reformed" leader.
- The Power of Merit: The Pendleton Act is the reason your mail gets delivered and your taxes get processed by people who (mostly) know what they’re doing, rather than just the friends of a local politician.
- Research the "In-Betweeners": If you're a history buff, look into the Gilded Age presidents. They dealt with issues—like corporate power and civil service reform—that look a lot like the headlines we see today.
To really get a feel for the era, you should check out the North Fairfield, Vermont historic site where he was born, or take a look at the Tiffany-designed elements still present in historical records of the White House. Understanding Arthur is about understanding how a "machine" politician found his soul.
Next Step: You might want to dig into the "Star Route" postal scandals to see exactly what kind of corruption Arthur was fighting against when he took office.