It was 2010. Everyone was talking about Gloucester, Massachusetts. Why? Because a group of teenage girls supposedly made a pact to get pregnant at the same time. Lifetime, never one to miss a viral news cycle, jumped on the story. They gave us The Pregnancy Pact. It was peak cable drama. Looking back, the cast of the Pregnancy Pact wasn't just a group of random actors; it was a mix of seasoned veterans and young stars who were just about to blow up.
Honestly, the movie is kind of a time capsule. It captures that specific late-2000s anxiety about social media (back when we called it "the internet") and "copycat" behavior. But beyond the tabloid headlines and the Lifetime gloss, the actors involved actually turned in some heavy-hitting performances. Some stayed in the spotlight. Others moved behind the camera. A few basically disappeared.
Thora Birch as the Moral Compass
Thora Birch played Sidney Bloom. She wasn't one of the teens in the pact; she was the blogger/journalist trying to figure out what the heck was happening in her hometown. At the time, Birch was already a massive deal. Think American Beauty. Think Hocus Pocus. She was the "indie darling" who brought a layer of legitimacy to a TV movie that could have easily felt like cheap exploitation.
She’s always been picky. Birch doesn't just take every script that lands on her desk. After the movie aired, she took a bit of a break from the massive Hollywood machine, though she did pop up later in The Walking Dead as Gamma. Most recently, she’s been leaning into directing. She actually directed a Lifetime movie herself—the 2022 The Gabby Petito Story. It’s a full-circle moment, really. She went from starring in these ripped-from-the-headlines stories to being the one calling the shots behind the lens.
Madisen Beaty and the Burden of Being the Lead
The heart of the "pact" was Sara Dougan, played by Madisen Beaty. She was the "good girl" who got caught up in the madness. Beaty was young when she filmed this, but you could tell she had range. She didn't make Sara a villain, which was a smart choice. She made her a kid who just wanted to belong.
✨ Don't miss: Who was the voice of Yoda? The real story behind the Jedi Master
If you’ve watched any prestige TV or film in the last decade, you’ve definitely seen her. She was in The Master with Joaquin Phoenix. She played a younger version of Cate Blanchett’s character in The Curious Case of Benjamin Button. But her biggest "grown-up" role? Probably Once Upon a Time in Hollywood. She played Katie, one of the Manson family members. It’s wild to go from a Lifetime teen pregnancy drama to a Quentin Tarantino flick, but that’s the kind of career trajectory you want. She’s stayed working, stayed low-key, and avoided the teen star burnout that hits so many others.
Camryn Manheim: The Adult in the Room
You can’t talk about the cast of the Pregnancy Pact without mentioning Camryn Manheim. She played the nurse, Kim, who first notices the spike in pregnancy tests. Manheim is an Emmy winner. She’s a pro. Bringing her in was a power move by the production. She grounded the more sensational elements of the plot with a sense of weary, adult reality.
Since then? She hasn't stopped. She’s a staple of the Law & Order universe now, playing Lieutenant Kate Dixon. She also spent years on Ghost Whisperer. Manheim is one of those actors who makes everything she’s in 10% better just by showing up. She provides the "gravitas" that these types of movies desperately need to avoid becoming caricatures.
The Supporting Girls: Where Did They Go?
The rest of the "pact" was rounded out by a group of actresses who represented different archetypes of the suburban teenager.
🔗 Read more: Not the Nine O'Clock News: Why the Satirical Giant Still Matters
- Kendall Cross: She played one of the mothers. She’s a Canadian actress who has appeared in basically every show filmed in Vancouver. The Flash, Riverdale, Supernatural. You name it, she’s been in it.
- Max Ehrich: He played Randy. Before he became a fixture in the soap opera world (and before that very public breakup with Demi Lovato that took over the internet for a month), he was just the guy in this movie. He’s had a steady career in daytime TV, specifically The Young and the Restless.
- Michelle DeFraites: She played Karissa. She’s had a lot of guest spots on Disney Channel and Nickelodeon shows like Austin & Ally.
It’s interesting to see who stuck with it. Being in a Lifetime movie is often a stepping stone, a way to get those SAG hours and show you can carry a scene. For some, it was the peak of their acting career before they transitioned into "normal" lives or different industries.
Why This Specific Cast Worked
Usually, these movies feel rushed. The Pregnancy Pact felt a bit different because the chemistry between the girls was actually believable. They felt like friends. They didn't feel like actors reading lines about a "pact."
The movie was directed by Rosemary Rodriguez. She’s a serious director—she’s done episodes of The Good Wife, Jessica Jones, and The Walking Dead. Having a director of that caliber working with this specific cast is why the movie still gets played in reruns and discussed in "guilty pleasure" circles today. It wasn't just fluff. It tried to say something about the pressure of social media and the desire for unconditional love, even if it did so through a very dramatic lens.
Realism vs. Lifetime Drama
We have to talk about the reality check. The real Gloucester story was a lot more complicated than the movie portrays. Time Magazine’s 2008 cover story, "The Pregnancy Pact," sparked a national firestorm, but local officials later disputed that a formal "pact" even existed. They argued it was more of a "social contagion" or just a statistical outlier in a town with limited resources for teens.
💡 You might also like: New Movies in Theatre: What Most People Get Wrong About This Month's Picks
The cast had the tough job of playing the "pact" version of the story while trying to keep the characters human. If they had played them as "bad kids," the movie would have failed. Instead, the cast of the Pregnancy Pact played them as lonely kids. That’s a big distinction.
The Lasting Impact of the Film
Does it hold up? Sorta. Some of the technology looks ancient now. The "blogging" subplots feel very 2010. But the performances—especially from Birch and Beaty—keep it watchable. It serves as a reminder of how we used to talk about teenage girls in the media: with a mix of fascination and horror.
If you’re looking to track down the actors now, your best bet is Instagram or IMDB. Most of them have moved into very different phases of their lives. Some are parents themselves now, which adds a weird layer of irony to the whole thing.
How to approach the legacy of The Pregnancy Pact
If you’re revisiting this movie or researching the cast for the first time, keep these things in mind to get the most out of the experience:
- Watch for the subtle performances: Don't just focus on the "shock" factor of the plot. Look at how Madisen Beaty handles the internal pressure of her character; it’s actually quite nuanced for a TV movie.
- Compare the fiction to the facts: Read the original 2008 Time Magazine article by Kathleen Kingsbury alongside the film. It’s a fascinating study in how media transforms a local news story into a national myth.
- Check out their later work: If you liked Thora Birch here, watch her directorial debut. It shows how her time in front of the camera influenced her style behind it.
- Contextualize the "Moral Panic": Use the film as a starting point to look at other "social contagion" stories from that era. It’s a great window into the cultural mindset of the late 2000s regarding youth culture and the internet.
The movie might be a bit dated, but the careers it launched—and the veterans who anchored it—remain a significant part of the TV landscape. Whether they're solving crimes on Law & Order or acting in Oscar-nominated films, this cast has certainly moved far beyond the halls of their fictional high school.