You know those movies that just sort of appear on your streaming dashboard late at night? The ones with the creepy thumbnail and the title that sounds like a news headline from a neighborhood Facebook group? That's basically the vibe of The House on Laura Anne Dr. It’s this indie horror flick from 2024 that has been making the rounds on Amazon Prime and The Roku Channel. Honestly, if you’re looking for a massive ensemble cast like a Marvel movie, you’re in the wrong place. This is a "small room" kind of story. It’s claustrophobic. It’s intimate. It relies almost entirely on just a few faces to keep the tension from flatlining.
The cast of The House on Laura Anne Dr is surprisingly lean, which is probably why people keep searching for who these actors actually are. Most of the heavy lifting is done by a duo you might not recognize immediately, but they’ve been grinding in the indie scene for a while.
The Core Players: Who Is Actually in This?
The movie centers on Ava and Jay. They’re a couple moving to Florida for a "fresh start," which in horror movie language is basically code for "everything is about to go horribly wrong."
Natalie Brienen as Ava
Ava is the heart of the movie. Natalie Brienen plays her as someone already on the edge—she's dealing with depression and looking for a way out of her own head. Brienen has done a bunch of these indie horror projects, including stuff like Amber and The Amber Green Story. You can tell she’s comfortable in the "final girl" or "troubled protagonist" archetype. In this film, she’s basically on screen 90% of the time, often alone, which is a tough gig for any actor.
🔗 Read more: The Reality of Sex Movies From Africa: Censorship, Nollywood, and the Digital Underground
Stephen Lamar Lewis as Jay
Then there’s Jay, played by Stephen Lewis (sometimes credited as Stephen Lamar Lewis). He’s the husband who buys the house on Laura Anne Dr. as a surprise. Fun fact: he blindfolds her to bring her there. In real life, that’s a cute gesture; in a horror movie, it’s a red flag the size of a football field. Lewis plays Jay with this shifting energy—at first, he's the supportive partner, but as Ava starts seeing "things," he gets more frustrated and, frankly, a bit mean. It’s that classic gaslighting dynamic that makes these suburban horrors so uncomfortable to watch.
Jann Van Dyke as Ruth
Every creepy house needs a creepy neighbor. Enter Jann Van Dyke. She plays Ruth, the lady from across the street who "knows things." Van Dyke is great here because she doesn't overplay the spookiness. She just drops bits of lore about the house’s history that make Ava (and us) feel like the walls are closing in.
The People Behind the Scenes
It’s worth mentioning that the cast of The House on Laura Anne Dr is very intertwined with the crew. This is a true indie production.
💡 You might also like: Alfonso Cuarón: Why the Harry Potter 3 Director Changed the Wizarding World Forever
- Joseph A. Mazzaferro: He’s the director and the writer. But if you look closely, he also pops up in the movie as an "Officer." He’s basically the architect of the whole thing.
- Jason Henne: He plays a character named Tony, but he also handled the cinematography.
This "all hands on deck" approach is pretty common in Florida’s indie horror circle. If you look at the credits of other movies in this niche, like You Shouldn’t Have Let Me In, you’ll see the same names popping up over and over. It's a tight-knit community.
Why the Small Cast Actually Works (and Where it Doesn't)
Look, I’ll be real with you. This isn't a high-budget jump-scare fest. Because the cast is so limited, the movie lives or dies on Natalie Brienen’s performance.
Some viewers find the slow burn frustrating. There aren't many people for the protagonist to talk to, so a lot of the plot is revealed through post-it notes and internal monologues. It’s a bold choice. It highlights the isolation of mental illness, which is a big theme here. But if you’re someone who needs a body count or a dozen different subplots, you might find the Laura Anne Dr. crew a bit too sparse.
📖 Related: Why the Cast of Hold Your Breath 2024 Makes This Dust Bowl Horror Actually Work
What You Should Know Before Watching
If you're diving into this because you saw a clip on TikTok or a recommendation on a horror forum, keep your expectations grounded.
- It’s a 75-minute movie. It’s short. It doesn't waste time introducing a massive cast because it doesn't have one.
- The "True Story" claim. The marketing sometimes leans into the "based on true events" trope. While the house or the specific street might have some local lore in Florida, the paranormal stuff is, you know, movie magic.
- The Acting Style. It’s very naturalistic. It feels like a home movie at times, which adds to the "this could happen to you" vibe of suburban horror.
Actionable Insights for Horror Fans
If you enjoyed the performances of the cast of The House on Laura Anne Dr, you should definitely check out the director's other work. Joseph Mazzaferro has a very specific style that stays in this lane of "troubled people in quiet houses."
Also, follow Natalie Brienen on social media or IMDb. She is a workhorse in the indie horror world and usually picks projects that allow her to do more than just scream.
For those trying to find the movie right now, it’s usually free with ads on The Roku Channel or Tubi. Don't pay $16.99 for it on Apple TV unless you’re a die-hard collector of Florida indie cinema. It pops up for free or on cheap rental ($0.99) on Amazon Prime Video pretty frequently.
The next time you see a movie with a small cast and a specific address for a title, you'll know exactly what kind of ride you're in for. It's about the atmosphere, the isolation, and the few actors brave enough to carry a whole film on their shoulders.