Honestly, nobody expected a 1995 parody of a sugary 1970s sitcom to actually work. But here we are, decades later, and the cast of the Brady Bunch movie is still basically the gold standard for how to do a reboot right. They didn't just play the characters; they inhabited the weird, polyester-clad souls of a family trapped in a time warp while the 1990s raged around them with grunge music and carjackings.
It’s kind of wild when you look back at how perfect the casting was. You had Gary Cole, who wasn't exactly a household name yet, stepping into Mike Brady’s perky architect shoes. Then there was Shelley Long, fresh off Cheers, playing Carol with a shimmering, slightly terrifying maternal glow.
The movie succeeded because it wasn't just making fun of the Bradys. It was a "send-up with sweetness," as Gary Cole put it in a recent interview. Let’s get into who these people actually were and what happened after they survived the 90s.
The Parents: Gary Cole and Shelley Long
Gary Cole was a revelation. Before this, he was mostly known for the intense TV drama Midnight Caller. To see him pivot to Mike Brady—complete with the lecture voice and the unintentional double entendres—was a masterclass. Cole has since become a character actor legend. You’ve seen him as the soul-crushing boss Bill Lumbergh in Office Space, the fast-talking Kent Davison in Veep, and now he’s the lead on NCIS. He actually worried the bad wig and polyester would kill his career. Luckily, it did the opposite.
Shelley Long was already a star, of course. But her Carol Brady was something else. She nailed the "smiling through the chaos" energy perfectly. After the Brady films, she kept busy with a recurring role as DeDe Pritchett on Modern Family. She’s mostly stayed out of the spotlight lately, officially retiring around 2022, but her performance as the Brady matriarch remains a high-water mark for 90s comedy.
💡 You might also like: Not the Nine O'Clock News: Why the Satirical Giant Still Matters
The Kids: Catching Lightning in a Bottle
Casting six kids who look like the originals but can also pull off deadpan comedy is basically impossible. Yet, they did it.
Christine Taylor (Marcia Brady)
If there’s a breakout star from the younger cast, it’s Christine Taylor. She was so good as Marcia that it’s hard to imagine anyone else in the role. The hair flip? The ego? Perfection. She went on to star in Zoolander and Dodgeball with her husband, Ben Stiller. Even though she’s slowed down her acting work to focus on family, she’s still a comedy icon.
Jennifer Elise Cox (Jan Brady)
"Sure, Jan." That meme wouldn't exist without Jennifer Elise Cox. This was actually her first big on-screen credit. She captured Jan’s middle-child neurosis so well it was almost uncomfortable to watch. She’s had a really steady career since, appearing in shows like Web Therapy and 10 Items or Less.
Christopher Daniel Barnes (Greg Brady)
Barnes was already a voice acting pro before Greg Brady. He was the voice of Prince Eric in The Little Mermaid! After the Brady movies, he became the definitive voice of Spider-Man in the 90s animated series. He doesn't do much on-camera acting these days, but if you’ve played Kingdom Hearts II, you’ve definitely heard his voice.
📖 Related: New Movies in Theatre: What Most People Get Wrong About This Month's Picks
The Rest of the Siblings
- Paul Sutera (Peter Brady): Paul eventually moved behind the camera. He’s now a successful reality TV producer, working on shows like Shark Tank and Ice Road Truckers.
- Olivia Hack (Cindy Brady): Olivia kept that lisp for the movie and then went on to a massive voice acting career. She was Rhonda in Hey Arnold! and Ty Lee in Avatar: The Last Airbender.
- Jesse Lee Soffer (Bobby Brady): You might know him better as Jay Halstead from Chicago P.D. He’s probably had the most consistent "serious" acting career out of all the Brady kids.
The Neighbors and the Cameos
We can't talk about the cast of the Brady Bunch movie without mentioning Michael McKean and Jean Smart. They played the Dittmeyers, the miserable neighbors who just wanted the Bradys to sell their house. McKean is a legend (Better Call Saul, Spinal Tap), and Jean Smart has basically won every Emmy in existence recently for Hacks.
Then there were the cameos. The movie was packed with "blink and you'll miss it" moments from the original 70s cast:
- Florence Henderson (The Original Carol): Played Grandma Brady.
- Ann B. Davis (The Original Alice): Appeared as a trucker named Schultzy.
- Barry Williams (The Original Greg): Played a music producer.
- Christopher Knight (The Original Peter): Played a coach.
Even RuPaul made an appearance as Mrs. Cummings, the guidance counselor! It was a weird, beautiful mix of the old guard and the new.
👉 See also: A Simple Favor Blake Lively: Why Emily Nelson Is Still the Ultimate Screen Mystery
Why the Casting Still Holds Up
Most reboots fail because they try too hard to be "cool" or "gritty." This movie did the opposite. It kept the Bradys exactly as they were in 1972 and dropped them into a world that had moved on.
The actors had to play it straight. If Gary Cole had winked at the camera once, the whole thing would have fallen apart. Instead, he played Mike Brady as a man who genuinely believed his advice about "fitting in" was helpful, even while wearing a ruffly tuxedo shirt at a 90s high school dance.
Actionable Insights for Fans
If you want to revisit the world of the Bradys, start by watching The Brady Bunch Movie (1995) followed by A Very Brady Sequel (1996). The sequel is actually just as funny, especially the subplot involving Greg and Marcia. For a real trip, check out A Very Brady Renovation on HGTV, where the surviving original cast members helped renovate the actual house used for exterior shots in the 70s. It’s a great way to see the "real" Bradys alongside the legacy the 90s cast helped preserve.