It was the peak of the 90s erotic thriller craze, and honestly, The Babysitter 1995 felt like it was everywhere and nowhere at the same time. You probably remember the grainy VHS cover at the rental store or catching it on a late-night cable rotation. While it wasn't a box office smash like Scream or Clueless, the movie became a cult fixture because of its weird, voyeuristic energy. But the real reason we're still talking about it? The cast.
Looking back at the cast of the babysitter 1995, it is wild to see how many of these actors were right on the cusp of either massive stardom or becoming "that guy" you recognize in every single procedural drama for the next thirty years. It wasn't just a low-budget thriller; it was a bizarre crossroads for Hollywood talent.
Alicia Silverstone and the Pre-Clueless Transition
Timing is everything in Hollywood. Alicia Silverstone is the undisputed face of this movie. Interestingly enough, The Babysitter actually filmed before she became a household name as Cher Horowitz, but it got caught in the gears of distribution and ended up being released right around the same time as Clueless in 1995. This created a jarring contrast for audiences. One minute she was the bubbly, fashionable icon of Beverly Hills; the next, she was Jennifer, the object of obsession in a dark, psychological mess.
Silverstone was essentially the "It Girl" of the mid-90s. Before this, she’d already cemented her status as the "Aerosmith girl" from their music videos, which gave her this edgy but accessible vibe. In The Babysitter, she doesn’t actually do much—and that’s the point. The movie is about how the people around her project their own dark fantasies onto her. It required a specific kind of screen presence to be a blank slate that still felt magnetic. Silverstone had that in spades.
She’s spoken in later years about how intense that period of her life was. To go from a provocative thriller like this to the massive commercial weight of Batman & Robin shortly after was a lot for a teenager. If you watch her performance here now, you can see the raw talent that often got overshadowed by her "pop culture icon" status. She was playing a girl just trying to do a job while surrounded by creeps, and she sold that vulnerability perfectly.
Jeremy London and the 90s Heartthrob Era
Then you’ve got Jeremy London playing Jack. If you lived through the 90s, you couldn't escape the London twins. Jeremy and his brother Jason were basically the blueprint for the "sensitive but slightly troubled" male lead of the era.
👉 See also: Album Hopes and Fears: Why We Obsess Over Music That Doesn't Exist Yet
Jeremy was fresh off I'll Fly Away and was about to hit his peak with Mallrats (also 1995) and the TV drama Party of Five. In The Babysitter, he plays the boyfriend, a role that feels almost quaint compared to the darker subplots involving the older characters. His career is such a fascinatng snapshot of that decade. He had this specific look that casting directors were obsessed with—part grunge, part boy-next-door.
While Jeremy’s later life became more defined by his struggles with substance abuse and appearances on reality shows like Celebrity Rehab, his work in the mid-90s was genuinely solid. He represented a specific type of young Hollywood energy that felt very grounded. In this film, he provides the only real "normal" tether in a story that otherwise feels like a fever dream.
The Character Actors Who Carried the Weight
While the posters focused on the young leads, the cast of the babysitter 1995 was actually anchored by some heavy-hitting character actors who brought a level of "creep factor" that the movie desperately needed to work.
J.T. Walsh: The King of the Sinister Everyman
Honestly, J.T. Walsh was one of the greatest "bad guys" in cinema history, mostly because he looked like he could be your accountant or your neighbor. He plays Harry Tucker, the father who hires Jennifer. Walsh was a master at playing men who were simmering with internal rot. You’ve seen him in A Few Good Men, Sling Blade, and Breakdown.
In this movie, he has to play a man lost in a midlife crisis fueled by booze and inappropriate thoughts. It’s a thankless role in some ways, but Walsh makes it genuinely uncomfortable to watch. Sadly, he passed away only a few years after this movie came out, in 1998. The industry lost one of its most reliable villains. He didn't need a weapon to be scary; he just needed a cold stare.
✨ Don't miss: The Name of This Band Is Talking Heads: Why This Live Album Still Beats the Studio Records
Lee Garlington and the Domestic Horror
Lee Garlington played Dolly, the wife. Garlington is one of those actresses who has been in everything. Seriously. From Field of Dreams to Sneakers and hundreds of TV guest spots. She brought a necessary weight to the film’s domestic side. While the movie is often categorized as a thriller, it’s also a pretty grim look at a collapsing marriage. Garlington’s performance highlights the sadness and resentment that exists just under the surface of the "perfect" suburban life Jennifer walks into.
The Supporting Players and Future Stars
If you blink, you might miss some other familiar faces. The cast of the babysitter 1995 is surprisingly deep.
- Nicky Katt: He plays Mark, the "rebel" friend. Katt is the ultimate "I know that guy" actor. He went on to have a massive career in indie films and eventually a long stint on Boston Public. He brings an unpredictable, twitchy energy to his scenes that elevates the tension.
- Lois Chiles: She appears as Bernice. If you’re a Bond fan, you know her as Dr. Holly Goodhead from Moonraker. Seeing a former Bond girl in a gritty 90s thriller is the kind of casting crossover that makes these movies so interesting to look back on.
- George Segal: He’s in there too! The Oscar-nominated legend from Who's Afraid of Virginia Woolf? and The Goldbergs. Having a veteran like Segal involved gave the project a weird sense of legitimacy it might not have otherwise had.
Why This Cast Worked (Despite the Script)
The movie itself is... complicated. It’s based on a short story by Robert Coover, and it leans heavily into the "Rashomon" style of storytelling where we see the same events through different people’s biased (and often gross) perspectives.
The reason the movie hasn't been totally forgotten is that the actors didn't play it like a cheap "slasher" flick. They played the psychological damage. When you watch J.T. Walsh or Jeremy London, they aren't playing caricatures; they’re playing people who are genuinely losing their grip. That’s why it feels more like a noir than a typical teen thriller.
Also, we have to talk about the "90s aesthetic" of the casting. This was a time when studios were desperate to find the next big thing, and The Babysitter felt like a testing ground. It was an era where you could put a future superstar like Silverstone in a movie with a Bond girl and a character actor like Walsh and see what stuck.
🔗 Read more: Wrong Address: Why This Nigerian Drama Is Still Sparking Conversations
The Legacy of the 1995 Cast
So, what happened to everyone? It’s a mixed bag, which is usually the case with cult hits.
- Alicia Silverstone became a vegan activist and continued acting in both indies and theater. She’s had a bit of a "Silverstone-aissance" lately, appearing in projects like The Lodge and American Woman.
- Jeremy London hit some rough patches but has remained active in the indie film circuit and frequently appears at fan conventions.
- The "Vets" like Walsh and Segal have passed away, leaving behind massive legacies that far outweigh this specific film.
What You Can Do Next
If you’re looking to dive deeper into this specific era of thriller or the careers of these actors, here is how you should spend your weekend.
First, go back and watch Clueless immediately after watching The Babysitter. The whiplash of seeing Alicia Silverstone go from the dark, voyeuristic lens of Jennifer to the bright, satirical world of Cher is the best way to appreciate her range. It’s a masterclass in how much a director’s vision can change an actor’s "vibe."
Next, look up J.T. Walsh’s filmography. If you liked his menacing energy in this, watch Breakdown (1997). It’s arguably his best performance and one of the most underrated thrillers of the 90s. It features him at his absolute peak of being terrifyingly normal.
Finally, check out the original short story by Robert Coover. It gives a lot of context to why the movie is structured the way it is. The "cast of the babysitter 1995" did their best to translate a very literary, abstract concept into a commercial film, and seeing the source material makes you appreciate their performances even more.
The movie might be a product of its time—complete with questionable fashion and a very specific mid-90s "edge"—but the talent on screen was undeniable. It serves as a perfect time capsule of a moment when Hollywood was transitioning from the gritty thrillers of the 80s into the teen-centric boom of the late 90s.