When The Secret Life of Pets 2 hit theaters in 2019, it had a massive hill to climb. The first movie was a juggernaut. It raked in over $875 million. People loved the idea of knowing what their dogs did while they were at work. But sequels are tricky, especially when you have to shuffle the deck with the people behind the microphones. Honestly, the cast of Secret Life of Pets 2 is one of the more interesting case studies in animation because of how it handled a high-profile lead replacement and the addition of a literal Hollywood legend.
The Max Dilemma: Patton Oswalt Steps In
You can't talk about the cast without addressing the elephant—or rather, the Terrier—in the room. Louis C.K. voiced Max in the first film. Following his 2017 admission of sexual misconduct, Illumination and Universal dropped him immediately. They didn't just push the movie back; they pivoted.
Enter Patton Oswalt.
Oswalt didn't try to do a carbon copy of the original voice. That’s why it works. He brought this nervous, neurotic energy to Max that fit the character's new arc as an overprotective "helicopter" dog for his owner’s new toddler, Liam. Max is stressed. He's itchy. He's wearing a cone of shame. Oswalt’s naturally high-strung comedic timing made that transition almost seamless. Most kids watching didn't even notice the voice changed, which is the ultimate win for a studio.
Harrison Ford’s Animated Debut as Rooster
Getting Harrison Ford to do a voice in an animated kids' movie was a massive "get." Before this, he hadn't done it. Not once. He plays Rooster, a grizzled, no-nonsense farm dog who mentors Max. It’s basically Ford playing a canine version of his public persona—curmudgeonly but secretly helpful.
Director Chris Renaud has mentioned in interviews that Ford was surprisingly game for the process. Usually, you expect a guy like that to just phone it in for a paycheck. Instead, Rooster became the emotional anchor of the film's second act. His deep, gravelly tone provides a perfect contrast to Oswalt’s frantic yapping. It’s the classic "old school vs. new school" dynamic, and it’s arguably the best part of the sequel.
The Returning Heavy Hitters
The rest of the core crew came back, and they didn't miss a beat. Eric Stonestreet is still the heart of the movie as Duke. While Duke has a bit less to do in this installment compared to the first—where the whole plot revolved around his rivalry with Max—Stonestreet still brings that big-hearted, clumsy energy.
🔗 Read more: Cast of Troubled Youth Television Show: Where They Are in 2026
Then there's Kevin Hart.
Love him or hate him, Hart’s Snowball is the engine that drives the comedy. In the first movie, he was a villainous revolutionary. In the sequel, he’s a "superhero" bunny. Hart is dialed up to an eleven here. It's loud. It's fast. It’s exactly what you expect from Kevin Hart, and for a sequel aimed at families, it’s gold.
The female leads are equally stacked:
- Jenny Slate as Gidget: She’s still the obsessed Pomeranian, and her subplot involving a "cat masquerade" to retrieve a toy is comedy peak. Slate has this unique ability to sound both adorable and terrifyingly intense at the same time.
- Lake Bell as Chloe: The cynical tabby cat. Bell’s deadpan delivery is the perfect palate cleanser for the more high-energy characters.
- Tiffany Haddish as Daisy: A new addition. She plays a Shih Tzu who enlists Snowball for a rescue mission. Haddish was at the height of her Girls Trip fame when this was recorded, and she brings a lot of "straight-man" energy to Snowball’s antics.
Why the Voice Acting Matters for This Script
The cast of Secret Life of Pets 2 had to carry three separate storylines that don't really converge until the very end. That’s a risky move for a movie under 90 minutes. You have Max on the farm, Snowball and Daisy saving a tiger, and Gidget learning to be a cat.
Without such distinct voices, the movie would have felt like three different TV episodes mashed together.
For instance, Nick Kroll joins the cast as Sergei, the villainous circus owner. Kroll is a voice-acting chameleon (look at Big Mouth or Sing), and he gives Sergei a menacing, slightly ridiculous vibe that keeps the stakes high without getting too dark for a PG rating.
💡 You might also like: Cast of Buddy 2024: What Most People Get Wrong
A Breakdown of the Key Players
Patton Oswalt (Max): The anxious protagonist. His voice is thinner and more expressive than the previous actor, which suits the "new dad" anxiety Max feels.
Kevin Hart (Snowball): The comedic relief. He spends half the movie in a blue superhero cape, and Hart’s ability to scream-talk makes the character's delusions of grandeur actually funny.
Harrison Ford (Rooster): The mentor. His presence gives the film a certain "gravitas" it lacked before.
Tiffany Haddish (Daisy): The catalyst. She triggers the main action plot involving the circus.
Jenny Slate (Gidget): The wildcard. Her vocal range goes from "high-pitched fluff" to "demon cat" in seconds.
Behind the Mic: The Process
Animation recording is usually a lonely business. Actors record their lines in a booth, often without their co-stars. However, the chemistry in the cast of Secret Life of Pets 2 feels genuine. This is largely due to the "Illumination style" of directing, where actors are encouraged to riff.
📖 Related: Carrie Bradshaw apt NYC: Why Fans Still Flock to Perry Street
Eric Stonestreet and Patton Oswalt have spoken about how they try to find the "dog-ness" in their voices. It’s not just talking; it’s the huffing, the panting, and the specific way a dog might react to a treat or a squirrel. It sounds silly, but that’s the difference between a generic cartoon and a movie that feels alive.
The Misconception About Replacements
Some fans were worried that changing the lead actor would ruin the "vibe." It’s a valid concern. Usually, when a major character gets recast, the audience spends the whole time looking for the seams.
But here’s the thing: Patton Oswalt is a better fit for "Anxious Max" than Louis C.K. would have been. The first movie was about a territorial dog protecting his home. The second is about a dog learning to let go of fear. Oswalt’s voice naturally carries a sense of vulnerability. It made the character more likable and less grumpy.
Actionable Takeaways for Movie Fans
If you're revisiting the film or watching it for the first time, keep an ear out for these specific performances:
- Watch the "Cat Lessons" Scene: Pay close attention to Lake Bell (Chloe) teaching Jenny Slate (Gidget) how to behave like a cat. The vocal timing between the two is a masterclass in comedic chemistry, even if they recorded it months apart.
- The Ford Factor: Notice how Harrison Ford barely raises his voice. In a movie where everyone else is screaming (looking at you, Kevin Hart), Ford’s quiet, rumbling bass makes him the most intimidating character on screen.
- The New Additions: Look for Dana Carvey as Pops. He’s a veteran of the first film, but his role as the "elderly dog mentor" is a great example of how a legendary comedian can disappear into a small role.
The cast of Secret Life of Pets 2 succeeded because it didn't just try to repeat the first movie. It added layers. It brought in a legend like Ford to ground the story and a frantic genius like Oswalt to lead it. It’s a rare case where the behind-the-scenes drama of recasting actually resulted in a more nuanced character.
If you want to dive deeper into how these voices were captured, check out the "Making Of" featurettes on the Blu-ray. Seeing Harrison Ford in a recording booth wearing a plain T-shirt and grumbling into a microphone is worth the price of admission alone. It shows that even the biggest stars in the world can find something fun in playing a farm dog.