If you’ve been keeping up with the Lake Eden saga, you know things have felt a little different lately. The flour-dusted world of Hannah Swensen has undergone some serious construction. When Pie to Die For: A Hannah Swensen Mystery premiered on Hallmark in June 2025, it wasn't just another case of a dead body found near a dessert. It was a litmus test for the "new era" of the franchise.
Honestly, people were skeptical. Losing a lead is risky. But as the cast of Pie to Die For: A Hannah Swensen Mystery proves, sometimes a fresh coat of paint—or a new prosecuting attorney—is exactly what a long-running series needs to keep from getting stale.
The Central Trio: Alison Sweeney, Victor Webster, and the Delores Factor
At the heart of it all is Alison Sweeney. She’s been playing Hannah for a decade now, and she’s basically the glue holding the whole Hallmark Mystery brand together. In Pie to Die For, Hannah is doing what she does best: balancing a bakery, a blossoming romance, and a murder investigation that hits way too close to home.
The big talk, of course, is still about Victor Webster as Chad Norton.
Let's be real—replacing Cameron Mathison (who played Mike Kingston for years) wasn't going to be easy. Fans had a lot of "Mike and Hannah" feelings. But Victor Webster brings a different energy. He’s Chad, the prosecuting attorney, not a cop. This changes the whole dynamic. Instead of Hannah constantly butting heads with the police department, she now has a partner in the legal system who actually encourages her "intellectual curiosity." It’s less "stay behind the yellow tape" and more "let's look at this evidence together over coffee."
🔗 Read more: Cast of Troubled Youth Television Show: Where They Are in 2026
Then there's Barbara Niven as Delores Swensen. If Barbara Niven ever left this show, we’d have a riot on our hands. In Pie to Die For, Delores is actually at the center of the drama. Her theater rival ends up dead, and Delores’s reputation is on the line. Seeing Delores vulnerable—well, as vulnerable as a woman with that much hairspray can be—adds a layer of stakes that makes this installment feel more personal than the "victim of the week" formula.
The Full Cast of Pie to Die For: A Hannah Swensen Mystery
Beyond the big three, the supporting cast fills out the town of Lake Eden with familiar faces and a few newcomers. Here is who you’ll see on screen:
- Alison Sweeney as Hannah Swensen: The baker/sleuth who can't stop finding bodies.
- Victor Webster as Chad Norton: The suave attorney and Hannah's new romantic interest.
- Barbara Niven as Delores Swensen: Hannah's high-society mother.
- Lisa Durupt as Andrea Swensen Todd: Hannah’s sister, who brings that much-needed sibling groundedness.
- Gabriel Hogan as Norman Rhodes: The dentist. Honestly, Norman is the MVP of this series. He's the "forever friend" who fans still occasionally root for to win Hannah’s heart.
- Mike Dopud as various roles: Often appearing in these mysteries to provide that sturdy, dependable presence.
- Tess Atkins as Michelle Swensen: Rounding out the Swensen sisters.
Why the Change in Casting Mattered
A lot of fans wondered why the cast changed so much around 2024 and 2025. It basically boils down to network shifts. Cameron Mathison moved over to Great American Family (GAF), which left a hole in Lake Eden.
Hallmark didn't just recast Mike Kingston—they wrote him out. That was a smart move. Recasting a character like Mike would have felt "off," like those sitcoms where a different actor shows up in Season 5 and everyone pretends not to notice. By bringing in Victor Webster as a new character, Chad Norton, the writers gave Hannah (and us) permission to move on.
💡 You might also like: Cast of Buddy 2024: What Most People Get Wrong
The Plot: More Than Just Pie
The mystery in Pie to Die For is actually based on Joanne Fluke's book, Banana Cream Pie Murder. If you’ve read the books, you know the plots usually involve about 40% baking, 40% sleuthing, and 20% Hannah trying to decide between two men.
In this film, the stakes are heightened because it's not just a random customer who dies; it’s someone tied to Delores. This forces Hannah to work overtime. She has to clear her mother’s name while navigating her "blossoming" romance with Chad.
The chemistry between Sweeney and Webster is surprisingly natural. They worked together previously on The Wedding Veil movies, so they already had a shorthand. It shows. Chad isn't trying to be Mike. He’s more analytical, maybe a little more polished, and he treats Hannah like a peer in a way that feels very "2026."
What Most People Get Wrong About the New Cast
The biggest misconception is that the "new" Hannah Swensen movies are a total reboot. They aren't. While the leading man changed, the core DNA—the Cookie Jar, the sisterly banter, the meddling mother—is all still there.
📖 Related: Carrie Bradshaw apt NYC: Why Fans Still Flock to Perry Street
Some fans miss the "cozy" vibe of the original Murder, She Baked films. Earlier movies had a different color palette and a slightly slower pace. The newer ones, including Pie to Die For, feel a bit more like modern procedurals. Is that better? Depends on who you ask. If you like your mysteries with a side of high-definition crispness and faster dialogue, you’ll probably prefer the current era.
How to Watch and What to Do Next
If you missed the premiere, you can usually find Pie to Die For on Hallmark+ (the rebranded streaming service) or during the "Mystery" blocks on the Hallmark Mystery channel.
If you're looking to dive deeper into the world of Lake Eden after watching the movie, here’s how to get the full experience:
- Read the Source Material: This movie is based on Banana Cream Pie Murder. Comparing the book to the movie is a hobby in itself for this fandom, especially since the movie takes some... liberties with the ending.
- Watch the Transition Movies: If you're confused about how we got from Mike to Chad, go back and watch One Bad Apple and A Sprinkle of Deceit. Those are the bridge films that set up the current cast dynamic.
- Check the Recipes: One of the best parts of the Hannah Swensen world is that the treats are real. Hallmark usually posts the recipes for the titular desserts on their website. The banana cream pie from this movie is actually pretty legendary.
Lake Eden has changed, sure. But as long as Alison Sweeney is at the helm and Barbara Niven is wearing statement jewelry, the series remains the ultimate comfort food for mystery fans. Keep an eye out for the next installment, Cooked to Death, which is rumored to continue the Chad and Hannah storyline later this year.