Bette Davis wasn't the first choice. Honestly, she wasn't even the fifth choice. When people talk about the cast of Of Human Bondage 1934, they usually start and end with Davis, but the story of how this group of actors came together is a mess of studio politics, rejected scripts, and a performance so visceral it basically invented the "Oscar snub" as we know it today.
Most 1930s dramas were polite. This one wasn't. Based on W. Somerset Maugham’s sprawling, semi-autobiographical novel, the film required a level of grit that RKO Pictures wasn't entirely sure their audience could handle. You’ve got Leslie Howard playing Philip Carey, a sensitive medical student with a club foot, and Bette Davis as Mildred Rogers, the waitress who essentially ruins his life. It’s a toxic relationship before we had a word for it.
The Cast of Of Human Bondage 1934 and the Gamble That Paid Off
Leslie Howard was already a massive star by 1934. He was the "civilized" actor. Precise. Refined. He brought a specific kind of intellectual vulnerability to Philip Carey that made the character's obsession with a cruel, uneducated waitress even more painful to watch. Howard’s performance is the anchor, but let’s be real—the movie belongs to the villain.
Finding someone to play Mildred was a nightmare. In the book, Mildred is wretched. She’s manipulative, she’s sick, and she’s utterly unlikable. Every major actress at the time—including Katharine Hepburn and Ann Harding—turned it down. They were terrified of looking "ugly" or being hated by the public. Then came Bette Davis. At the time, she was under contract at Warner Bros., and they were mostly giving her "ingenue" roles that bored her to tears. She practically begged Jack Warner to loan her out to RKO for this part.
She knew it was her shot.
💡 You might also like: Why Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy Actors Still Define the Modern Spy Thriller
Bette Davis as Mildred Rogers
Davis didn't just play Mildred; she inhabited the decay. While other stars of the era insisted on soft lighting and perfect makeup, Davis insisted on looking worse as the film progressed. By the final act, when Mildred is ravaged by illness and poverty, Davis looks genuinely haunting. It was a "courageous" performance in an era where vanity was the law of the land.
The chemistry between Howard and Davis is fascinating because it's so incredibly lopsided. Howard plays Philip with this quiet, desperate dignity, while Davis is a whirlwind of Cockney spite. It shouldn't work, but it does. It feels real. It feels like those relationships where you see a friend dating someone terrible and you just want to shake them.
Frances Dee as Sally Athelny
In total contrast to the chaos of Mildred, you have Frances Dee playing Sally. If Mildred is the "bondage" of the title, Sally is the release. Dee provides the only warmth in a movie that is otherwise pretty bleak. Her role is smaller, but essential. Without her, the movie would just be a descent into misery. She brings a grounded, maternal energy that balances out the high-voltage performances of the leads.
The Supporting Players
The cast of Of Human Bondage 1934 is fleshed out by character actors who were the backbone of the studio system.
📖 Related: The Entire History of You: What Most People Get Wrong About the Grain
- Reginald Owen plays Thorpe Athelny, the eccentric father of Sally. Owen was one of those guys who appeared in everything (you might remember him as Admiral Boom in Mary Poppins decades later).
- Kay Johnson appears as Norah, another woman Philip briefly turns to.
- Alan Hale (yes, the father of the Skipper from Gilligan's Island) plays Emil Miller.
These actors had to navigate a script that was heavily censored by the Hays Code. In the novel, the themes are much more explicit regarding Mildred’s "illness" and the nature of her profession. The cast had to convey a lot through subtext—lingering glances, tones of voice, and body language—to get around the censors.
The Controversy That Shook the Academy
Here is the thing. Bette Davis gave what many critics called the greatest performance ever recorded by an actress up to that point. But when the Academy Award nominations were announced, her name wasn't on the list.
The public outcry was massive. It was the first time in Hollywood history that a "write-in" campaign was officially organized. People were so angry that the Academy actually allowed write-in votes that year. She still didn't win (Claudette Colbert did for It Happened One Night), but the message was sent. The cast of Of Human Bondage 1934 had done something that couldn't be ignored. It paved the way for Davis to win for Dangerous the following year—which many people consider a "makeup" Oscar for the snub she suffered here.
Why the Casting Still Holds Up
If you watch the movie today, Leslie Howard might feel a little "stagey" to a modern ear. That was the style. But Davis? Davis feels like she walked off a film set from 2026. Her acting style was years ahead of its time. She used her whole body—the way she wiped her mouth, the way she slumped in a chair—to tell the story.
👉 See also: Shamea Morton and the Real Housewives of Atlanta: What Really Happened to Her Peach
The film's director, John Cromwell, largely stayed out of her way. He recognized that Davis had tapped into something raw. There’s a scene where Mildred lashes out at Philip, screaming at him about his club foot, and it is still genuinely uncomfortable to watch. It’s mean. It’s petty. It’s human.
Key Takeaways for Film Buffs
If you're planning to revisit this classic, keep an eye on these specific elements:
- The Makeup Evolution: Notice how Davis's appearance changes. She reportedly did her own makeup for the "sick" scenes because the studio artists kept trying to make her look "pretty-sick." She wanted to look "actually-dying-sick."
- The Dialect: Davis worked incredibly hard on her Cockney accent. While it might sound a bit thick to modern British ears, at the time, it was praised for its authenticity compared to the usual "mid-Atlantic" accent most actors used.
- The Power Dynamics: Watch the scenes where Howard and Davis are in the same frame but not looking at each other. The blocking of the cast of Of Human Bondage 1934 tells the story of Philip’s isolation better than the dialogue ever could.
Practical Steps for Watching
- Check Public Domain Sites: Because of its age, the 1934 version is often available on legal public domain streaming sites or YouTube in various qualities.
- Compare the Remakes: There were remakes in 1946 (starring Eleanor Parker) and 1964 (starring Kim Novak). Most critics agree neither reaches the heights of the 1934 original, mostly because the chemistry of the lead cast is impossible to replicate.
- Read the Source Material: If the film feels condensed, it’s because it is. Maugham’s book is huge. Knowing the backstories of the characters makes the performances of the supporting cast even more impressive.
The 1934 production remains a masterclass in how a single casting choice—Bette Davis—can elevate a standard studio drama into a piece of cinematic history. It’s the definitive version of the story because it didn’t blink. It showed the ugly side of love, and it did it with a cast that was willing to go to some very dark places.