Let’s be real for a second. When Telltale Games first announced they were making a narrative-driven adventure set in a world of blocks and silent protagonists, people were skeptical. How do you give a voice to a game known for its lack of one? The answer, it turns out, was to assemble a cast of Minecraft Story Mode that felt less like a marketing checklist and more like a love letter to 80s adventure movies and modern comedy.
Even now, years after the game was pulled from most digital storefronts, fans are still obsessing over the performances. You’ve got legends like Patton Oswalt and the late, great Paul Reubens. It wasn't just "good for a video game." It was legitimately great.
The Two Faces of Jesse
The most unique thing about the game was that you weren't stuck with one version of the hero. Depending on your preference, Jesse was either voiced by Patton Oswalt or Catherine Taber.
Oswalt brings that classic "lovable underdog" energy. He’s the guy who's definitely out of his depth but is going to try anyway because it's the right thing to do. If you’ve seen Ratatouille, you already know he can carry an emotional arc with just his voice. On the flip side, Catherine Taber—who many know as Padmé Amidala from The Clone Wars—gave female Jesse a slightly different edge. Her version felt a bit more like a natural leader, someone who was tired of being called a "loser" and was ready to prove the world wrong.
Interestingly, the script barely changed between the two, yet the vibe was totally different.
🔗 Read more: Why Miranda the Blighted Bloom Is the Weirdest Boss You Missed
The Core Crew: Friendship and Friction
You can't have a hero's journey without a ragtag group of misfits. The main cast of Minecraft Story Mode was built on chemistry.
- Axel (Brian Posehn): He’s the muscle, but also the comic relief. Posehn’s dry, deadpan delivery made Axel feel like that one friend we all have who is a bit too obsessed with TNT.
- Olivia (Martha Plimpton): The "brains" of the operation. Plimpton (yes, the one from The Goonies) played Olivia with a skeptical, grounded realism that balanced out the group's wilder ideas.
- Petra (Ashley Johnson): If you recognize the voice, it’s because she’s Ellie from The Last of Us. Petra is the resident badass of the group, and Johnson brings a layer of vulnerability to the character that really shines in the later episodes of Season 1.
- Lukas (Scott Porter): Originally the rival, Lukas eventually joins the team. Porter—best known as Jason Street in Friday Night Lights—gave Lukas a polished, "golden boy" voice that slowly cracked as the stakes got higher.
Why Paul Reubens as Ivor Was a Stroke of Genius
Honestly? Ivor is the best character in the game. Period.
Voiced by the legendary Paul Reubens, Ivor starts as a suspicious, potion-brewing antagonist and evolves into the team's eccentric, shouty uncle. Reubens had this incredible ability to make "vaguely villainous" sound hilarious. When he screams about "Adventure!" it’s impossible not to smile.
His performance is a huge part of why the back half of Season 1 (the "Portal Hallway" episodes) works so well. It shifted from a world-ending threat to a fun, episodic mystery series, and Ivor was the glue holding that shift together.
💡 You might also like: Why Marvel’s Guardians of the Galaxy is the Best Game You Probably Skipped
The YouTubers: A Multiverse Moment
In Episode 6, A Portal to Mystery, Telltale did something that felt massive at the time: they brought in the actual giants of the Minecraft community.
We’re talking DanTDM, Stampy Cat, CaptainSparklez, StacyPlays, and LDShadowLady. They didn't just play characters; they played "themselves" in a Clue-style murder mystery. For the kids playing this in 2016, it was like The Avengers. It grounded the game in the actual culture of Minecraft, rather than just using the brand as a skin.
The Legend of the Order
The "Old Guard" of the world was voiced by industry titans. Dave Fennoy (Lee from The Walking Dead) played Gabriel the Warrior. Corey Feldman played Magnus. Grey Griffin played Ellegaard.
This was high-tier casting. They weren't just "voice actors"; they were performers who understood the specific rhythm of a Telltale script. When the Order of the Stone falls apart, you actually feel the weight of it because the voices sound so weary and broken.
📖 Related: Why Mario Odyssey for the Nintendo Switch Still Beats Every Other Platformer
Who played who? A Quick Refresher
While I won't bore you with a spreadsheet, remember that John Hodgman played Soren the Architect, and Jim Cummings (the voice of Winnie the Pooh and Tigger!) showed up as the villainous Hadrian in the later episodes. The depth of this roster is actually kind of insane.
Actionable Next Steps for Fans
Since the game is no longer for sale on most platforms due to Telltale's original closure and licensing issues, finding it can be a bit of a quest.
- Check Physical Media: If you have a console, look for the "Complete Adventure" discs. They are often the only way to play Episodes 6-8 and Season 2 without jumping through major technical hoops.
- Archival Sites: Keep an eye on community-led archival projects. The fandom is surprisingly active on Reddit and Discord, and they often share ways to keep the game playable on modern PCs.
- Voice Actor Portfolios: If you loved a specific performance, follow the actors! Many of them, like Ashley Johnson and Scott Porter, are staples in the "Critical Role" or "Actual Play" tabletop scene now.
The cast of Minecraft Story Mode proved that even in a world made of cubes, the heart of the story comes from the voices behind the blocks. It wasn't just a spin-off; it was a performance-driven epic that still holds a special place in the history of gaming.