It’s been over two decades since we saw a group of Victorian literary icons team up to stop a world war. Some people love it. Most critics hated it. But when you look back at the cast of League of Extraordinary Gentlemen film, you aren't just looking at a list of actors; you’re looking at the reason Sean Connery quit Hollywood forever. That’s not hyperbole. The production was so famously chaotic that the man behind James Bond decided he was done with the industry entirely.
Honestly, the movie is a bit of a mess. It’s loud, the CGI has aged like milk, and it drifts so far from Alan Moore’s original graphic novel that it’s basically its own thing. Yet, there is something undeniably charming about the ensemble they pulled together. You had a legendary veteran, a rising American star, and a handful of character actors who actually took the source material seriously.
Sean Connery as Allan Quatermain: The Lion in Winter
Sean Connery was the gravity that held this whole project together. He played Allan Quatermain, the legendary hunter who is basically the tired grandfather of the group. By 2003, Connery was already selective. He had famously turned down the roles of Gandalf in Lord of the Rings and Morpheus in The Matrix because he "didn't understand them."
He didn't really understand this one either.
Connery’s Quatermain is rugged, cynical, and carries a massive rifle that looks like it weighs fifty pounds. On screen, he’s a professional. Off-screen? He was reportedly at war with director Stephen Norrington. The tension was so thick you could cut it with a cutlass. Norrington was a visual effects guy at heart—he’d done Blade—and his style didn't mesh with Connery’s old-school "just hit your marks" sensibility. There’s a famous story about a prop elephant gun malfunctioning on set, leading to a massive blowout. When the film finally wrapped, Connery basically said he was tired of "idiots" and headed for the golf courses of the Bahamas. He never made another live-action movie.
👉 See also: Is Heroes and Villains Legit? What You Need to Know Before Buying
Peta Wilson and the Mystery of Mina Harker
If Connery was the anchor, Peta Wilson was the pulse. Fresh off her success in La Femme Nikita, she stepped into the boots of Mina Harker. In the movie, Mina isn't just a survivor of Dracula; she’s a full-blown vampire with chemistry-defying powers.
Wilson brought a weird, gothic energy that felt more "Alan Moore" than anyone else in the cast. She had this way of looking at her teammates like they were children, which, considering she was an immortal bloodsucker, made total sense. She replaced Monica Bellucci, who had to drop out due to scheduling conflicts with the Matrix sequels. You can almost see how Bellucci would have played it—more ethereal, maybe—but Wilson gave Mina a scrappy, dangerous edge that worked for a 2003 action flick.
The American Addition: Shane West as Tom Sawyer
If you’ve read the comics, you know Tom Sawyer isn't in them. Not even a little bit. The studio felt the cast of League of Extraordinary Gentlemen film needed an American face to appeal to the domestic box office. Enter Shane West.
He was the "Secret Service agent" version of Mark Twain’s classic character. At the time, West was a heartthrob from A Walk to Remember. Putting him next to Sean Connery was a bold choice. It was the classic "mentor and protégé" trope. Looking back, West does a decent job with what he was given, but his inclusion remains one of the biggest points of contention for fans of the graphic novel. It felt like a corporate mandate inserted into a Victorian fever dream.
✨ Don't miss: Jack Blocker American Idol Journey: What Most People Get Wrong
The Supporting Heavyweights: From Captain Nemo to Dorian Gray
The rest of the roster was filled out by actors who were arguably better than the script they were reading.
- Naseeruddin Shah as Captain Nemo: This was a brilliant bit of casting. Shah is a legend in Indian cinema. He gave Nemo a regal, scientific, and slightly vengeful dignity. He wasn't just a guy driving a big submarine; he was a man who hated the British Empire but found himself saving the world for them.
- Stuart Townsend as Dorian Gray: Before this, Townsend was famously fired from the role of Aragorn in Lord of the Rings just as filming started. In LXG, he plays the immortal narcissist with a sleek, oily charm. His character was another invention for the film (he’s not in the original League lineup in the books), but his betrayal plotline adds some much-needed stakes.
- Jason Flemyng as Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde: Flemyng had to endure hours of prosthetic work to play the "Hulk-ified" version of Hyde. It’s a physical, grunting performance that contrasts perfectly with his twitchy, terrified Jekyll.
- Tony Curran as Rodney Skinner (The Invisible Man): Due to rights issues with the H.G. Wells estate, they couldn't use the name Griffin. So, they created Skinner, a thief who stole the invisibility formula. Curran is mostly just a floating pair of glasses or a voice in the wind, but he provides the comic relief that keeps the movie from becoming too self-serious.
The Villain in the Shadows: Richard Roxburgh
You probably recognize Richard Roxburgh as the Duke from Moulin Rouge! or Dracula from Van Helsing. Here, he plays "M," the man who assembles the League. Without spoiling a twenty-year-old movie, let’s just say he has a double life. Roxburgh is great at playing sneering, high-society villains. He has this precise, clipped way of speaking that makes you want to punch him and applaud him at the same time.
Why the Chemistry Failed (and Why It Sorta Worked)
Making this movie was a nightmare. A massive flood in Prague destroyed over $7 million worth of sets. Connery and Norrington weren't speaking. The script was being tinkered with constantly. You’d think the final product would be unwatchable.
But when you watch the cast of League of Extraordinary Gentlemen film interact, there’s a strange, accidental spark. Maybe it’s the shared trauma of a difficult production. There is a genuine sense of "we’re all in this mess together." The scene where they all sit around the table in the Nautilus feels like a real group of outcasts trying to figure out if they actually like each other.
🔗 Read more: Why American Beauty by the Grateful Dead is Still the Gold Standard of Americana
The film tried to do what the MCU eventually perfected: the team-up. It just did it about ten years too early and with a lot more steam-powered gadgets.
The Legacy of the Extraordinary Cast
Whatever you think of the film’s quality, its impact on the industry was massive. It served as a cautionary tale about ballooning budgets and director-actor friction. It also effectively ended the "Victorian Superhero" genre before it could really start.
For the actors, the paths diverged wildly.
- Sean Connery retired, leaving a void in Hollywood that hasn't quite been filled.
- Naseeruddin Shah returned to India and continued his streak as one of the greatest actors in history.
- Peta Wilson did a few more projects but eventually stepped away from the massive blockbuster machine to focus on her own business ventures.
- Tony Curran became a staple of high-end TV, appearing in everything from Doctor Who to Mayans M.C.
Practical Insights for Fans and Collectors
If you’re revisiting this film today, don't look at it as a faithful adaptation. It isn't. Look at it as a time capsule of early 2000s filmmaking. If you want to dive deeper into this specific era of the cast of League of Extraordinary Gentlemen film, there are a few things you should actually check out:
- The "Making Of" Documentaries: The DVD extras are surprisingly honest about how difficult the shoot was. They don't gloss over the tension as much as modern "EPK" (Electronic Press Kit) fluff does.
- The Original Graphic Novel: If you’ve only seen the movie, go read Alan Moore and Kevin O’Neill’s work. It is darker, weirder, and Mina Harker is the actual leader, not just the "vampire girl."
- The Prop Auction History: A lot of the physical props from the Nautilus were sold off years ago. You can still find high-res photos of the intricate detail work that went into the "Sword of Nemo" and Quatermain's rifle, which shows the craftsmen were working way harder than the scriptwriters.
The movie might be a footnote in cinema history, but the cast was a powerhouse collection of talent that deserved a better sandbox to play in. It remains a fascinating "what if" in the world of comic book movies.
To truly understand the impact of this production, track down the 2003 interviews with Sean Connery during the press junkets. You can see the exact moment he decides he's done with the business. It’s a masterclass in professional exhaustion. After that, compare the film's version of the characters to their literary origins in Bram Stoker or Jules Verne novels to see just how much "Hollywood-izing" happened during the rewrite process. It's a fascinating study in adaptation choices.