Victor Hugo didn’t just write about hunchbacks and escaped convicts. Honestly, he went way darker than that. If you’ve ever seen a picture of the Joker and wondered where that nightmare grin actually started, you’re looking at L’Homme qui rit. It’s a book that is, quite frankly, a mess of beautiful contradictions. Published in 1869 while Hugo was chilling in exile on the Channel Islands, it’s part political manifesto, part Gothic horror, and part soul-crushing romance.
It failed.
Well, it failed at the time. Critics hated it. They thought it was too much—too wordy, too weird, too angry. But looking at it through a 2026 lens? It feels like Hugo was predicting exactly how fame and physical appearance would be weaponized in the modern world. It’s a story about a boy whose face was carved into a permanent laugh by criminals, only for him to realize that the "civilized" world of the aristocracy was actually much more monstrous than the people who mutilated him.
The Comprachicos and the Making of a Monster
Let's talk about the nightmare fuel at the start of the book. Hugo introduces us to the "Comprachicos." These weren't just random thugs; they were a fictionalized (but based on terrifying historical rumors) group of traders who bought children to "remodel" them. Basically, they were plastic surgeons from hell. They’d stunt a kid’s growth or, in the case of our protagonist Gwynplaine, slice his face so he’d look like he was permanently laughing.
Why? For money.
Deformed children were "amusing" to the 17th-century nobility. It’s a stomach-turning thought. Imagine being abandoned on a freezing beach in Portland, England, which is exactly what happens to young Gwynplaine. He’s left behind by these child-traffickers, stumbling through a blizzard. This sequence is classic Hugo—long, descriptive, and incredibly tense. He finds a baby girl, Dea, clutching her dead mother’s breast in the snow. She’s blind; he’s "mutilated." It’s the ultimate underdog setup.
They get taken in by Ursus, a philosophical vagabond who lives in a van with a wolf named Homo. Yes, the wolf is named "Man." Hugo wasn't exactly subtle with his metaphors. Ursus is the cynical voice of the book, someone who has seen the world's cruelty and decided to hide from it in a theater on wheels.
🔗 Read more: Drunk on You Lyrics: What Luke Bryan Fans Still Get Wrong
Why L’Homme qui rit is the Secret Architect of Pop Culture
You can't talk about this book without mentioning the 1928 silent film starring Conrad Veidt. If you haven't seen stills of it, go look them up right now. Veidt’s makeup—that frozen, wide-eyed, toothy grin—is haunting.
Bill Finger, Bob Kane, and Jerry Robinson saw that face and thought, "That’s our villain."
The Joker wouldn't exist without Gwynplaine. But the irony is massive. While the Joker is a chaotic murderer who laughs because he’s nihilistic, Gwynplaine is one of the most moral, kind-hearted characters in literature. He’s a tragic hero who happens to look like a demon. This creates a weird tension for the reader. You want him to be happy, but his very existence is a joke he didn't write.
The Political Punch to the Gut
About halfway through, the book shifts gears. It stops being a survival story and becomes a political thriller. It turns out Gwynplaine isn't just some random orphan. He’s actually Lord Linnæus Clancharlie, a peer of England.
He gets "restored" to his seat in the House of Lords.
This is where Hugo really starts swinging. Gwynplaine thinks he can use his new power to speak for the poor. He stands up in front of the most powerful men in England and tries to tell them about the suffering of the masses. He gives this incredibly moving, desperate speech.
💡 You might also like: Dragon Ball All Series: Why We Are Still Obsessed Forty Years Later
But they just laugh.
Because his face is a permanent grin, they think his entire speech is a comedy routine. The more he screams about justice and hunger, the harder they laugh. It’s one of the most heartbreaking scenes in any 19th-century novel. Hugo is basically saying that the elite are literally incapable of seeing the humanity of the lower classes, even when it’s staring them in the face.
The Weird, Obsessive Style of Victor Hugo
If you pick up a copy of L’Homme qui rit today, be prepared. Hugo loves a tangent. He will spend thirty pages describing the history of the British peerage or the mechanics of a 17th-century shipwreck. Some people find it boring. I think it’s world-building at its most obsessive.
He wanted to prove he knew the system he was attacking.
His prose is thick. It’s heavy. But then he’ll hit you with a line that feels like a punch. He writes things like, "The paradise of the rich is made out of the hell of the poor." Simple. Brutal. He doesn't mince words when it comes to social inequality.
There's also the romance between Gwynplaine and Dea. It’s pure. Since she’s blind, she doesn't see his "monstrous" face. She sees his soul. It’s the only place in the book where Gwynplaine isn't a freak. In her eyes—or rather, her lack of sight—he is beautiful. It’s a bit melodramatic, sure, but in the context of the bleakness surrounding them, it’s the only thing that keeps the reader going.
📖 Related: Down On Me: Why This Janis Joplin Classic Still Hits So Hard
Misconceptions and the "Joker" Connection
A lot of people think this is a horror novel. It isn't. Not really. It uses horror elements, but it’s a "Social Novel." Hugo was trying to do for England what he did for France in Les Misérables. He wanted to expose the rot.
Another big mistake? Thinking Gwynplaine is "happy" because he's a performer. He hates it. He’s a victim of what we would now call the "attention economy." People pay to see his pain, and he has to provide it to survive.
Why did it fail in 1869?
- Too Political: The British didn't like a Frenchman telling them their history was cruel.
- Too Grotesque: The era of Romanticism was fading, and people found the physical descriptions too much.
- Complexity: It’s a hard book to categorize. Is it a romance? A history? A satire?
Today, we love "genre-bending" stuff. In 1869, they just found it confusing.
How to Actually Read L’Homme qui rit Today
If you’re going to dive into this, don't get a condensed version. You need the full Hugo experience. You need the rants about the sea and the long lists of names. That’s where the atmosphere lives.
- Look for the Penguin Classics or Oxford World's Classics editions. The translations matter because Hugo’s French is incredibly rhythmic.
- Watch the 1928 film afterward. It changes the ending (the book’s ending is way, way more depressing), but the visual language is perfect.
- Don't rush. It’s a slow-burn. Let the gloom of the 17th-century English coast sink in.
Final Actionable Insights for Literature Fans
If you're looking to understand the roots of modern "anti-hero" stories or the intersection of physical disability and social status in literature, start here.
- Analyze the "Gaze": Pay attention to how Gwynplaine describes being looked at. It’s a masterclass in the psychology of being an outsider.
- Compare to Les Misérables: If you’ve read Hugo’s more famous work, look at the character of Ursus compared to Jean Valjean. One flees society; the other tries to redeem it.
- Contextualize the Villainy: Notice how the true villains aren't the criminals who cut Gwynplaine’s face, but the lawmakers who created the world where such a thing was profitable.
The story ends in tragedy, but the message is clear: the masks we wear—whether forced on us by others or chosen by ourselves—don't define our capacity for love. Hugo’s "Man Who Laughs" is a reminder that the loudest laughter often hides the deepest scream.
To truly appreciate the depth of this work, you should compare the descriptions of the English aristocracy in the text with historical accounts of the "South Sea Bubble" era. It adds a layer of economic critique that most people miss on the first read. Once you see the connection between the physical mutilation of children and the economic mutilation of the working class, the book becomes a lot more than just a spooky story about a guy with a weird face.