You see them everywhere on TikTok and YouTube. Someone starts on Day 1 looking a bit soft around the middle, and by Day 30, they’ve suddenly got the chest of a Spartan warrior. It makes you wonder. Can knocking out 100 reps a day really change your life, or is it just a recipe for a rotator cuff injury? Most people diving into a before and after push up challenge expect magic, but the physiological reality is a lot more nuanced—and frankly, a bit more frustrating—than a thirty-second montage suggests.
It's just a push up. Simple, right? Get down, touch your chest to the floor, push back up. Repeat until you can’t breathe. But when you commit to doing this every single day for a month, you aren't just working your "pecs." You are putting a massive amount of mechanical tension on your anterior deltoids, your triceps, and your entire core stabilization network.
The First Week: The Illusion of Progress
The first few days of a before and after push up challenge are usually fueled by pure adrenaline. You’re motivated. You feel the pump. This "pump" is actually transient hypertrophy—an increase in blood flow and water retention in the muscle belly. It looks great in the mirror for about twenty minutes, but it isn't permanent muscle growth.
Then, Day 3 hits.
Delayed Onset Muscle Soreness (DOMS) arrives like a freight train. This is where most people quit. The soreness occurs because you’ve created microscopic tears in the muscle fibers. According to studies published in the Journal of Applied Physiology, these tears are necessary for growth, but only if you actually let them heal. If you’re doing a "100 push ups a day" challenge, you aren't giving those fibers the 48 hours of rest they typically need to synthesize new protein. You’re basically picking a scab every morning.
Honestly, your form probably sucks by Wednesday. When you’re sore, your body looks for the path of least resistance. You start splaying your elbows out to a 90-degree angle, which puts an incredible amount of sheer force on the subacromial space in your shoulder. You might feel a "pinch." That's not muscle growth; that's your supraspinatus tendon screaming for help.
Why Your Chest Might Not Actually Get "Huge"
Let’s talk about the hypertrophy vs. endurance paradox. To build significant muscle mass—the kind that makes a dramatic "after" photo—you need progressive overload.
✨ Don't miss: Egg Supplement Facts: Why Powdered Yolks Are Actually Taking Over
If you start a before and after push up challenge and you can only do 10 reps, then doing 50 is a massive stimulus. Your chest will grow. But if you can already do 40 reps, doing 100 is more about muscular endurance than raw size. You’re training your Type I (slow-twitch) muscle fibers. These fibers are great at resisting fatigue, but they don't have the same cross-sectional growth potential as the Type II (fast-twitch) fibers you hit during heavy bench pressing.
Dr. Mike Israetel, a renowned sport physiologist from Renaissance Periodization, often points out that for muscle growth, you need to be within a certain proximity to failure—usually 0 to 4 reps away. If you’re just mindlessly hitting a number like "100" but it's easy for you, you’re just practicing the movement, not forcing an adaptation.
- Muscle Density: You will likely see an increase in muscle "hardness" due to improved neurological drive.
- Vascularity: Lowering your body fat while increasing blood flow can make veins pop in your arms and shoulders.
- Posture: This is the dangerous part. If you only push and never pull (like rows or pull-ups), your shoulders will start to roll forward. You end up looking like a caveman.
The Nutritional Gap in Most Challenges
You can't out-push-up a bad diet. Period.
Most people sharing their before and after push up challenge results online often fail to mention they also started eating 200 grams of protein and cut out the midnight snacks. If you stay in a caloric deficit, your muscles will look more "defined" because the layer of subcutaneous fat is thinning. You aren't necessarily "bigger"; you’re just more visible.
Conversely, if you eat like a pig because "hey, I did 100 push ups," you’ll end up with stronger muscles buried under more fat. The scale might go up, but the mirror won't show that chiseled look you were promised. You need a slight caloric surplus if you want to build new tissue, but it has to be high-quality fuel. Lean meats, complex carbs, and enough healthy fats to keep your hormones from crashing.
The Hidden Danger: Overuse and Adaptation
The human body is an adaptation machine. It wants to be efficient. By day 20 of your before and after push up challenge, your nervous system has become incredibly efficient at the movement. Your brain learns exactly which motor units to fire to move your body weight with the least amount of energy possible.
🔗 Read more: Is Tap Water Okay to Drink? The Messy Truth About Your Kitchen Faucet
This is great for survival. It's bad for bodybuilding.
Once the movement becomes "easy," the stimulus for growth drops significantly. To keep seeing changes in your "after" photos, you have to change the variables.
- Move your hands closer (Diamond push ups) to target triceps.
- Elevate your feet to hit the clavicular head of the pectoralis major (the upper chest).
- Slow down the eccentric (lowering) phase to four seconds.
If you just do the same standard push up for 30 days, your progress will plateau by week two. Most people just add more reps, but 200 shitty reps aren't better than 20 perfect, slow, agonizing ones.
Real World Results: What the Science Says
A study published in the Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research compared low-load training (like push ups) to high-load training (bench press). They found that as long as you go to failure, the muscle growth can be surprisingly similar. But there's a catch. The "low load" group had to do a massive volume of reps to get that result.
If you’re a beginner, a before and after push up challenge is arguably the best thing you can do for your upper body. It builds a foundation of "strength sense" and toughens up your connective tissue. For an advanced lifter? It’s basically active recovery. It won't replace a heavy chest day.
Mental Gains vs. Physical Gains
We focus so much on the triceps and the chest that we forget the brain. The real "after" of these challenges is often psychological. There's a profound power in doing something you don't want to do, every single day, regardless of the weather or your mood.
💡 You might also like: The Stanford Prison Experiment Unlocking the Truth: What Most People Get Wrong
That discipline spills over. You start choosing water over soda. You start taking the stairs. The push up challenge is a "gateway drug" to a fitness lifestyle. That’s the real value. The physical changes—the slightly wider shoulders, the firmer chest—are just the bait to get you to build the habit.
How to Actually Succeed Without Wrecking Your Shoulders
If you’re going to start your own before and after push up challenge, don't just follow a random infographic from 2012. You need a strategy that respects your anatomy.
The "Pull" Tax
For every push up you do, you should ideally do a pulling movement. If you can't do pull-ups, grab a resistance band and do "face pulls" or "band pull-aparts." This keeps your scapula healthy and prevents that "hunched over" look that plagues people who only train what they can see in the mirror.
Quality Over Quantity
Fifty "chest-to-floor" reps with a tucked pelvis and locked core are worth more than 500 "half-reps" where your lower back is sagging like a wet noodle. If your hips touch the ground before your chest, you aren't doing a push up; you’re doing a weird floor-humping exercise. Stop it.
Listen to Your Elbows
Joint pain is not "working hard." It’s inflammation. If your elbows start clicking or your shoulders feel "hot," take a day off. The world won't end if your 30-day challenge takes 32 days. Consistency is the goal, but longevity is the prize.
Actionable Next Steps for Your Challenge
- Document Everything: Take photos in the exact same lighting and time of day (preferably morning) for your before and after push up challenge records.
- Vary the Grip: Switch between wide, narrow, and standard grips every few days to distribute the stress across different muscle groups.
- Track Your Tempo: Spend 3 seconds lowering yourself, hold for 1 second at the bottom, and explode up. This increases "Time Under Tension," the primary driver for hypertrophy.
- Prioritize Protein: Aim for roughly 0.8 to 1 gram of protein per pound of body weight to ensure those micro-tears actually turn into new muscle.
- Add a "Pull": Perform 20 band pull-aparts for every 50 push ups to maintain shoulder health and posture.
- Focus on the Core: Keep your glutes squeezed and your abs tight; a push up is essentially a moving plank. If your core isn't tired at the end, you weren't doing them right.