You’ve seen the videos. Someone is sweating on a yoga mat, shaking like a leaf, while a repetitive, soulful loop drones in the background. Bring sally up, bring sally down. It sounds simple. It sounds like a nursery rhyme. But if you’ve actually tried to time your squats or pushups to Moby’s "Flower," you know it’s a three-and-a-half-minute descent into physical purgatory.
Most people think it’s just a "pushup song." It isn't. It’s actually a masterclass in isometric tension and psychological warfare.
The Strange History of Green Sally
The song "Flower" by Moby, released in 2000 on the Play: The B Sides album, didn't start in a recording studio. It started in the dirt. The lyrics—which most people mishear as "Bring Sally Up"—are actually "Green Sally Up." Moby sampled a field recording from 1959. Alan Lomax, a legendary ethnomusicologist, captured a group of young girls in Como, Mississippi, singing a clapping game. Mattie Gardner, Mary Gardner, and Jessie Lee Pratcher were the voices behind the track. It was a children’s game song, likely rooted in older African-American folk traditions. When you hear that "Old Miss Lucy’s dead and gone," you aren't just hearing a catchy bridge; you’re hearing a piece of Southern oral history that Moby layered over a heavy synth bass.
Kinda wild that a 60-year-old children's game is now the reason CrossFitters are crying on TikTok.
Why the Bring Sally Up Challenge is Actually Science
So, why does it hurt so bad? On paper, you’re only doing about 30 reps. Most fit people can do 30 pushups or 30 squats in their sleep.
The "Bring Sally Up" challenge isn't about reps. It’s about Time Under Tension (TUT).
💡 You might also like: The Reality of Before and After Face Transplants: What Actually Happens Post-Surgery
When you do a standard pushup, you’re in motion. Motion is easy. Your muscles act like springs, using momentum to bounce back up. But the Sally challenge forces you to hold the "down" position—the most mechanically disadvantaged part of the movement—for several seconds at a time.
- Isometric Stress: Holding a squat at the bottom (parallel or just below) or a pushup an inch off the floor stops blood flow to the muscle temporarily. This is called "hypoxic stress."
- Metabolic Waste: Because you aren't moving, lactic acid builds up and stays put. The "burn" isn't just a feeling; it’s a chemical reality.
- Eccentric Control: You can't just drop. You have to lower slowly to match the beat, which causes micro-tears in the muscle fibers that lead to serious hypertrophy.
Honestly, it’s a trap. The first 30 seconds feel fine. You think, "I've got this." Then the first bridge hits. You’re holding that hover, and suddenly your triceps feel like they’re being poked with hot needles.
Breaking Down the Movement Variations
While pushups are the "classic" way to suffer, people have gotten creative. You’ve got options, depending on how much you hate yourself today.
The Squat Version
This is the most common entry point. "Bring sally up" means standing; "bring sally down" means sitting deep into a squat. The trick here is the depth. If you "cheat" by sitting too high, you lose the tension. If you go too low and "bottom out" (resting your butt on your heels), you’re also cheating. You have to hover.
The Pushup Version (The Original)
This is the gold standard of the challenge. Start in a high plank. On "down," lower until your chest is an inch from the floor. Hold it. On "up," lock out. Most people fail around the 2-minute mark because their core gives out before their chest does.
👉 See also: How to Cum Without Masturbating: The Science of Non-Manual Orgasms
The Leg Raise Version
If you want to absolutely incinerate your lower abs, try it with leg raises. Up is 90 degrees; down is hovering your heels six inches off the floor. Don’t do this if you have lower back issues. Seriously.
The Math of the Song
The track is exactly 3 minutes and 28 seconds long.
- Total "Up/Down" cycles: 30
- Longest hold: Roughly 8 seconds during the bridges.
- Total time spent hovering: Way more than you think.
Common Mistakes That Ruin the Gains
If you’re going to do the bring sally up bring sally down workout, do it right. I see people at the gym doing this all the time, and half of them are wasting their energy.
First, holding your breath. It’s the instinctual thing to do when you’re under tension. Don't. If you stop breathing, your blood pressure spikes and you’ll fatigue twice as fast. Sharp exhales on the "up" are your best friend.
Second, sacrificing form for the beat. If your lower back starts sagging during the pushups, stop. You’re not "completing the challenge" at that point; you’re just begging for a disc injury.
Third, the "rest" at the bottom. In the pushup version, your chest should never touch the floor. If you’re laying on the ground waiting for the "up" command, you’ve basically turned a high-intensity isometric workout into a series of singles with long naps in between.
How to Actually Beat It
Most people fail because they go 100% on day one. Unless you’re already hitting 50+ unbroken strict pushups, you probably won't finish the song the first time.
Try this: The Regression Method. Start on your knees for the pushups. It feels "easy" for the first minute, but by the end, you’ll be struggling just as hard as the person on their toes. Once you can finish the song on your knees, move to your toes for the first 60 seconds, then drop to knees.
Progress is just staying on your toes for five seconds longer every time you play the track.
📖 Related: When Does Your Penis Stop Growing? The Timeline Most Guys Get Wrong
Actionable Next Steps
Ready to try it? Here is how to set yourself up for success without burning out in 40 seconds:
- Warm up the joints: Do 2 minutes of arm circles and cat-cow stretches. Isometric holds are hard on the tendons.
- Pick your poison: Start with squats if you’re a beginner. They’re easier to "save" if your form breaks.
- Find the rhythm: Listen to the song once before you start. Notice the long pauses in the bridge where "Old Miss Lucy" is mentioned. Those are the moments you need to mentally prepare for.
- Record yourself: Prop your phone up. You’ll think you’re hovering an inch off the ground, but the video will show your butt three feet in the air. The camera doesn't lie.
The beauty of the Moby challenge is that it’s a definitive benchmark. You either finished the song or you didn't. There’s no "sorta" finishing it. It’s you versus three minutes of 1950s Mississippi folk samples and 2000s electronic bass. Good luck.