You’re walking down 49th Street. The neon glow of the Eugene O’Neill Theatre is basically a permanent fixture of the Midtown landscape at this point. It’s 2026, and somehow, The Book of Mormon is still there. It’s been 15 years. That’s a lifetime in Broadway years. Most shows are lucky to survive a summer, but this foul-mouthed, tap-dancing juggernaut created by Trey Parker, Matt Stone, and Robert Lopez refuses to quit. Honestly, it’s kinda fascinating.
People always ask: is it still funny? Or is it just offensive now?
The Book of Mormon play New York experience isn't just about the jokes anymore. It’s a piece of theater history. You’ve got these two mismatched missionaries—Elder Price, who is basically a human Ken doll with a God complex, and Elder Cunningham, who can’t stop lying and has a weird obsession with Star Wars. They get sent to Uganda. Not Orlando. Uganda.
What the 2026 Production Actually Looks Like
If you saw the show back in 2011 with Josh Gad and Andrew Rannells, you’d recognize the bones, but the cast has shifted. Right now, as of January 2026, Kevin Clay and Diego Enrico are leading the charge. Enrico just stepped into the role of Elder Cunningham in late 2025, taking over for Cody Jamison Strand, who—get this—played the part for 13 years. Imagine doing the same "spooky Mormon hell dream" every night for over a decade. That’s a lot of Jeffrey Dahmer and Hitler cameos to process.
The show still runs about 2 hours and 30 minutes. You get a 15-minute intermission, which is just enough time to wait in a very long line for a $18 cocktail in a souvenir cup.
📖 Related: Big Brother 27 Morgan: What Really Happened Behind the Scenes
The Ticket Game
Don't just walk up to the box office and expect a cheap seat. Broadway is expensive. Currently, the average ticket price is hovering around $112 to $160, though if you want to sit in the premium orchestra on a Saturday night, you're looking at $300+.
- Lottery: They still do the "Lucky Seat" digital lottery. You can snag tickets for $25 if the theater gods smile on you.
- Rush: There are usually a few $40 rush tickets available when the box office opens, but you have to be that person standing in the cold at 9:00 AM.
- Schedule: They play eight shows a week. Tuesdays through Sundays. Mondays are dark—even missionaries need a day off.
Is the Satire Outdated?
Let's be real for a second. The world has changed a lot since 2011. The humor in The Book of Mormon is designed to punch in every direction. It mocks the LDS church, sure, but it also leans heavily into tropes about Africa that make some modern audiences squirm.
There’s a song called "Hasa Diga Eebowai." I won’t translate it here, but it’s the opposite of "Hakuna Matata."
Critics in 2026 are more divided than they were a decade ago. Some see it as a brilliant takedown of the "white savior" complex. Others think it relies too much on the very stereotypes it claims to be mocking. But the audience? They’re still laughing. The theater was at over 90% capacity last week. People still want to see the dancing Mormons in their crisp white shirts.
👉 See also: The Lil Wayne Tracklist for Tha Carter 3: What Most People Get Wrong
The Church's Weirdly Genius Response
One of the best "real life" facts about this play is how the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints handled it. Most religions would protest. They would picket. Instead, the LDS church bought ad space in the Playbill. They put up billboards that said, "The book is always better." It’s a masterclass in PR. They basically said, "Go ahead, laugh at the puppets, then come talk to us."
Why it Stays at the Eugene O'Neill
The Eugene O'Neill Theatre is intimate. With about 1,100 seats, there isn't really a bad view, though the mezzanine can feel a bit like a sardine can if you’re tall. It’s the longest-running show to ever inhabit this specific theater.
The production value hasn't dipped. The "Spooky Mormon Hell Dream" sequence still features high-end lighting and pyrotechnics that feel fresh. The choreography by Casey Nicholaw is still tight. It has to be—if a single tap-dancer is off-beat, the whole "Step It Up" vibe of the Mormon mission falls apart.
Essential Tips Before You Go
If you’re planning to catch the Book of Mormon play New York this season, there are a few things you should know that the tourist brochures won't tell you.
✨ Don't miss: Songs by Tyler Childers: What Most People Get Wrong
- Age Limits: They don't let kids under 5 in. Period. Even if they're "very mature." Honestly, you probably shouldn't bring anyone under 13 anyway unless you want to explain some very specific jokes about frogs and dysentery on the subway ride home.
- The Stage Door: After the show, people still crowd the stage door on 49th Street. The cast is usually pretty cool about signing programs, but don't expect a 20-minute conversation.
- Security: Give yourself 30 minutes. The line for security at the O'Neill moves okay, but it wraps around the block. If you show up at 6:55 PM for a 7:00 PM curtain, you're going to miss "Hello!"—and that’s the best song in the show.
Actionable Next Steps
If you want to see the show without getting ripped off, here is your game plan. Check the official Book of Mormon Broadway website first. Do not start with Google sponsored ads; those are often secondary brokers like StubHub or SeatGeek that mark up the price by 40%.
Enter the digital lottery 24 hours in advance via Lucky Seat. If you lose (and you probably will), head to the TKTS booth in Times Square. They often have "The Book of Mormon" on the board for 30-50% off for same-day performances, especially for mid-week matinees.
Finally, if you’re a fan of the music, listen to the original cast recording before you go. The lyrics are dense and fast. Knowing the words helps you catch the subtext while you’re busy watching 20 guys in ties do synchronized jazz hands.
Check the 2026 performance calendar and grab your seats at least three weeks out if you’re aiming for a weekend. It's a New York staple for a reason—it’s loud, it’s wrong, and it’s somehow still the most "Broadway" thing on Broadway.