So, you’re looking for the book of mormon nyc tickets. Honestly, it’s about time. This show has been running at the Eugene O’Neill Theatre since 2011, and yet, people still act like it’s this impossible-to-get, once-in-a-lifetime miracle. It’s not. But it is expensive if you’re a tourist who just walks up to a random website and clicks the first "Buy" button you see.
Don't do that.
New York is a city that rewards the savvy and punishes the impatient. If you want to see Elder Price and Elder Cunningham have their mid-life crises in Uganda without draining your savings account, you need a plan. 2026 is actually a massive year for the show—it’s hitting its 15th anniversary. That means some weirdly specific deals are popping up, but it also means the crowds are as thick as ever.
Why Everyone Overpays for The Book of Mormon NYC Tickets
Most people think "Broadway" and "cheap" don't belong in the same sentence. They aren't totally wrong. If you’re looking at Saturday night tickets for a holiday weekend, you're going to see prices north of $300. That's just the reality of the Eugene O'Neill’s tiny 1,066-seat capacity. It’s an intimate house, which is great for the comedy, but it sucks for supply and demand.
The biggest mistake? Buying from "re-sellers" who pose as the official site. Always check the URL. If you aren't on Lucky Seat or the official Jujamcyn/ATG portal, you're likely paying a middleman markup that would make a missionary blush.
🔗 Read more: How Old Is Paul Heyman? The Real Story of Wrestling’s Greatest Mind
The 15th Anniversary $15 Lottery
This is the big news for 2026. To celebrate 15 years of "Hasa Diga Eebowai," the production launched a special $15 lottery. Yeah, fifteen bucks. Compare that to the standard $250 premium seat and you’ll realize why everyone is jumping on it.
Here’s how it actually works, because it's slightly different from the daily lottery:
- Entries for the following month usually close around the 14th of the current month.
- Winners are picked on the 15th.
- If you win, you get a unique link to buy up to two tickets.
It’s a long shot. Like, winning-the-actual-lottery long shot. But for $15? You’d be crazy not to throw your name in the hat while you're planning your trip.
The "Regular" Digital Lottery and Rush
If you miss the $15 window, don't panic. The standard digital lottery through Lucky Seat is still alive and kicking. These tickets usually go for about **$49** ($40 plus those pesky fees). You enter a day or two in advance.
💡 You might also like: Howie Mandel Cupcake Picture: What Really Happened With That Viral Post
The "Rush" situation is a bit more old-school. For Tuesday through Thursday performances, there are often a limited number of $40 In-Person Rush tickets sold right when the box office opens (usually 10 AM). You have to actually stand there. On 49th Street. In the rain or the humid NYC heat.
Is it worth it?
If you're a student or on a tight budget, absolutely. But if you’ve only got three days in the city, do you really want to spend three hours of your morning standing on a sidewalk? Probably not.
Seating Secrets at the Eugene O'Neill Theatre
Let’s talk about where you’re actually sitting. The O'Neill is small. That’s a blessing because even the "nosebleeds" aren't that far away. However, the Mezzanine (the upper level) is famously tight. If you are over six feet tall, your knees will be touching your chin in some of those rear rows.
📖 Related: Austin & Ally Maddie Ziegler Episode: What Really Happened in Homework & Hidden Talents
- Best View for the Money: Mid-Center Mezzanine. You see the whole choreography of "Turn It Off" without the "I can see the actors' sweat" price tag of the front orchestra.
- The "Avoid" List: Far side Orchestra. The O’Neill has some "partial view" seats where you will literally miss 20% of the stage because a speaker stack or a wall is in the way. They're cheaper, but you'll spend the whole show leaning to the left.
- The Sweet Spot: Center Orchestra, Rows H through N. You're far enough back to see the stage floor but close enough to see the panic in Elder Cunningham’s eyes.
Midweek vs. Weekend: The Price Gap
If you can go on a Tuesday or Wednesday, do it. Seriously. I’ve seen tickets for a Wednesday night go for $86, while the exact same seat on a Saturday night is $152. Broadway pricing is "dynamic," which is just a fancy way of saying they charge more when they know you’re in town for the weekend.
Also, the 7:00 PM start time for weeknights is the new standard. Don't show up at 8:00 PM thinking you're early; you'll miss the entire opening number, and the ushers won't let you in until the first "break" in the action.
Tips for Scoring the Best Deal
- Avoid the Fees: If you are already in Manhattan, walk to the box office at 230 West 49th St. You save about $15-$20 per ticket in "convenience" fees just by talking to a human being.
- Check TodayTix: Sometimes they have "Digital Rush" or last-minute drops that aren't on the main site.
- The "Single Seat" Trick: If you're traveling solo or don't mind sitting apart from your group, look for those weird single seats left over in the front rows. They often get price-dropped a few hours before curtain.
- Matinees are for Families: If you want a slightly more "energetic" (read: loud) crowd, the Saturday/Sunday matinees are it. If you want a more focused, "theatre-pro" vibe, go for the Tuesday night show.
What to Expect at the Theatre
The show runs about 2 hours and 30 minutes. There is one 15-minute intermission. The line for the women’s restroom will be long. The drinks will be overpriced ($20 for a themed cocktail in a plastic souvenir cup? Welcome to New York).
But honestly? None of that matters once the "Hello!" bell starts ringing. It’s one of the few shows that actually lives up to the hype, even 15 years later. It’s raunchy, it’s offensive to some, but it has a massive heart. Just make sure you’ve secured your spot without getting ripped off.
Next Steps for Your Trip:
Check the official Lucky Seat website exactly 48 hours before the performance you want to see to enter the digital lottery. If you're looking for standard seats, browse the Tuesday night availability first to see the baseline low price for the week.