You’ve seen the photos. That milky, neon-blue water set against jagged black lava rock. It’s basically the visual shorthand for Iceland. But honestly, if you’re planning a trip, there’s a massive point of confusion that trips up almost everyone: there isn't just one "Blue Lagoon hotel." There are two very distinct, very different experiences owned by the same company—The Retreat and Silica Hotel—and picking the wrong one can kind of ruin the vibe you’re going for.
Most people just search for the Blue Lagoon hotel and click the first booking link they see. That’s a mistake. One is a wellness sanctuary designed for quiet reflection, while the other is a high-end luxury fortress. If you show up at Silica expecting the floor-to-ceiling lagoon views of The Retreat, or if you book The Retreat thinking it’s a casual basecamp for hiking, you're going to have a weird time.
Iceland's tourism has exploded, and the Reykjanes Peninsula, where the lagoon sits, is currently a geological hotspot in every sense of the word. With recent volcanic activity near Grindavík, the way we visit this area has changed. You can't just wing it anymore.
The Massive Difference Between Silica and The Retreat
Let’s get into the weeds.
Silica Hotel was the original. It was built for people seeking the healing properties of the water, specifically those dealing with skin conditions like psoriasis. It’s smaller. It’s quiet. It feels a bit like a high-end clinic that got a chic Nordic makeover. The big draw here is the private lagoon. It’s only for guests. You don’t have to deal with the 4,000 day-trippers splashing around in the main public area. It's just you and the moss.
Then you have The Retreat at Blue Lagoon Iceland. This opened in 2018 and shifted the whole landscape. This is where the celebrities stay. It’s built into the 800-year-old lava flow. If Silica is "nice," The Retreat is "architectural masterpiece." Every room is a suite. Some suites even have their own private lagoons—literally, you open your sliding glass door and step into the blue.
But here’s the kicker: The Retreat costs about three times as much as Silica.
💡 You might also like: Why the Nutty Putty Cave Seal is Permanent: What Most People Get Wrong About the John Jones Site
Is it worth it? That depends on how much you value the "Ritual." The Blue Lagoon Ritual is a spatial journey through three chambers: silica, algae, and minerals. At the main lagoon, you’re doing this with a bunch of strangers in a crowded cave. At The Retreat, it’s a choreographed, private experience. It’s the difference between a public pool and a private spa. Honestly, if you’re doing a honeymoon, you go for The Retreat. If you’re a photographer or a solo traveler looking for peace, Silica is actually better.
What Nobody Tells You About the Water
Everyone thinks the Blue Lagoon is a natural wonder. It isn't. Not really.
The water is actually a byproduct of the nearby Svartsengi geothermal power plant. It’s clean, it’s renewed every 48 hours, and it’s rich in sulfur and silica, but it’s essentially industrial runoff that turned out to be amazing for your skin. The plant pumps up superheated water from 2,000 meters below ground to run turbines for electricity. Then, the water is channeled into the lagoon.
That "milky" blue color? That’s physics. The silica in the water reflects sunlight. On a cloudy day, the water looks more like a greyish-white. On a sunny day, it’s that electric blue you see on Instagram.
The "Silica Hair" Disaster
This is the most important piece of advice you will read today. Do not get your hair in the water.
The silica isn't "toxic," but it will wreck your hair’s texture for weeks. It makes it feel like straw. It becomes stiff, unmanageable, and impossible to brush. Even the high-end Blue Lagoon hotel amenities can’t totally save you if you soak your head.
📖 Related: Atlantic Puffin Fratercula Arctica: Why These Clown-Faced Birds Are Way Tougher Than They Look
The pro move:
- Slather your hair in the provided conditioner before you get in.
- Don't rinse it out.
- Put your hair in a high bun.
- Accept that you will look a bit goofy with white cream plastered on your head.
- It's better than the alternative.
The Volcanic Reality of 2024-2026
We have to talk about the eruptions. The Reykjanes Peninsula has woken up after 800 years of slumber. Since late 2023, the area around Grindavík has seen multiple fissure eruptions. This has led to temporary closures of the Blue Lagoon hotel facilities several times.
When you book now, you have to look at the cancellation policy. The Blue Lagoon is very good about refunds during government-mandated evacuations, but the uncertainty is real. The hotels have built massive earthen barriers (berms) to protect the buildings from lava flows. It’s a surreal sight—ancient luxury meeting modern disaster prevention.
Check the Icelandic Meteorological Office (IMO) website daily. Don't rely on TikTok for your safety info. The road access can change in an hour. If the wind is blowing the wrong way, gas pollution from the eruptions can shut down the pools even if the lava is miles away.
Dining at the Lagoon: Beyond the Buffet
Most people eat a sandwich at the cafe and call it a day. That's a waste.
Moss Restaurant, located at The Retreat, earned a Michelin star for a reason. They do a vegan tasting menu that actually tastes like food, not just "vegetables." They have a wine cellar built into a cavern of multi-colored lava rock. It’s one of the few places in Iceland where the "destination dining" label isn't just marketing fluff.
👉 See also: Madison WI to Denver: How to Actually Pull Off the Trip Without Losing Your Mind
Lava Restaurant is the more accessible option. It’s built into a cliffside. The floor-to-ceiling windows look out over the main lagoon. If you stay at the Blue Lagoon hotel, you usually get a reservation here automatically, but you still have to confirm. Order the langoustine soup. It’s the best thing on the menu, period.
Is it a Tourist Trap?
I get asked this constantly. "Is the Blue Lagoon just a giant tourist trap?"
Yes. And no.
It is 100% a commercialized experience. It’s expensive. It’s crowded. There are better, more "authentic" hot springs in Iceland—like the Myvatn Nature Baths or the Hvammsvik Hot Springs.
But.
There is something about the scale of the Blue Lagoon that those other places don't have. The contrast of the black rock and the blue water is genuinely startling. If you stay at the Blue Lagoon hotel, specifically Silica or The Retreat, you bypass the "trap" part of the experience. You get the beauty without the elbows of a thousand tourists in your face.
Actionable Steps for Your Visit
If you're going to pull the trigger on a stay, follow this specific sequence to make sure you don't waste money or time.
- Book 4-6 months out. These hotels are small (Silica has 35 rooms; The Retreat has 62). They fill up with tour groups and weddings fast.
- Fly in, then soak. The lagoon is only 20 minutes from Keflavik Airport (KEF) but 45-50 minutes from Reykjavik. It makes the most sense to go directly from the airport or stay there on your final night before flying out.
- Download the "SafeTravel.is" app. This is the only way to get real-time alerts on volcanic activity and road closures.
- Skip the "Premium" day pass if you're staying at the hotel. Your hotel stay already includes better versions of everything in the premium package (robes, masks, etc.). Don't pay for them twice.
- Look for the "Northern Lights" wake-up call. If you stay in the winter, the front desk will literally call your room if the Aurora appears. Keep your warm clothes by the bed. There is nothing like seeing the green lights while standing on a balcony overlooking a steaming blue lagoon.
The Blue Lagoon is a weird, beautiful, industrial-accident-turned-luxury-oasis. It isn't for everyone. It’s pricey. It’s in a volcanic rift zone. But if you pick the right hotel and keep your hair out of the water, it’s one of those few places that actually looks like the postcards.