It was the kind of wedding that launched a thousand Pinterest boards. Back in 2012, when Blake Lively and Ryan Reynolds tied the knot at Boone Hall Plantation in South Carolina, the world saw a pastel-hued dream. There were Martha Stewart-designed dessert tables, a custom Marchesa gown, and the Spanish moss of Mount Pleasant draped over everything like a filtered Instagram post come to life.
But years later, that same imagery became the center of a massive cultural reckoning. Honestly, it’s one of those celebrity stories that didn't just fade away; it changed how an entire industry operates.
People didn't just wake up one day and decide to be mad. The backlash built slowly, peaking around 2018 and 2020, as the public started looking closer at the "picturesque" backdrop. It wasn't just a pretty garden. It was a site where, historically, hundreds of enslaved people lived, worked, and died. Specifically, the blake lively wedding plantation—Boone Hall—is home to "Slave Street," a row of nine preserved brick cabins that housed the enslaved people who fueled the plantation’s brick-making and cotton industries.
Why the choice of Boone Hall sparked a firestorm
When the news first broke in 2012, the focus was on the glamour. Most people recognized the venue as the setting for Allie’s summer house in The Notebook. It felt romantic. It felt "Old South" in that hazy, cinematic way that Hollywood loves to sell.
Then the lens shifted.
Critics pointed out the jarring juxtaposition of a joyful, million-dollar celebration happening just yards away from where human beings were once kept in bondage. It’s a heavy realization. For many, the idea of "plantation weddings" became synonymous with glamorizing a period of horrific systemic violence.
The couple stayed mostly quiet about it for years. That changed in 2020. Amidst the global conversation surrounding the Black Lives Matter movement, Ryan Reynolds finally addressed the elephant in the room. He called the decision a "giant f***ing mistake."
"It’s something we’ll always be deeply and unreservedly sorry for," Reynolds told Fast Company. "What we saw at the time was a wedding venue on Pinterest. What we saw after was a place built upon devastating tragedy."
It was a blunt admission. He didn't try to sugarcoat it or say they "didn't know" it was a plantation—he basically admitted they were blinded by the aesthetic.
The ripple effect on the wedding industry
This wasn't just about two movie stars. The fallout from the blake lively wedding plantation controversy forced the biggest players in the wedding world to pick a side.
- Pinterest and The Knot (and its sister site WeddingWire) changed their policies.
- They stopped promoting plantation content that "romanticized" the history.
- Search results for "plantation wedding" began featuring warnings or were de-indexed entirely.
- Vendors were told they couldn't use words like "charming" or "elegant" to describe former slave sites.
It’s kinda wild to think about. A single celebrity wedding helped dismantle an entire marketing category. Now, in 2026, you’ll notice that many of these historic sites have rebranded. They call themselves "manors," "farms," or "gardens." But the internet doesn't forget.
What happened after the apology?
A lot of people wondered if the apology was just "PR damage control." To be fair, the couple didn't just post a black square on Instagram and move on. They reportedly held a second, private wedding ceremony at their home in New York to "redo" the vows without the historical weight of the previous venue.
They also put their money where their mouths were. They’ve donated millions to the NAACP Legal Defense Fund and the Young Center for Immigrant Children's Rights. Reynolds also launched the "Group Effort Initiative," which aims to bring people from underrepresented communities into the filmmaking process.
Still, the internet is a polarized place. On one side, you have people who think the couple was genuinely ignorant and has done the work to fix it. On the other, there are critics who find it impossible to believe that two grown adults in America didn't understand the implications of a South Carolina plantation in 2012.
👉 See also: How Old Is Joyner Lucas: The Truth About His Age and Career
The reality of Boone Hall today
If you go to Boone Hall now, it’s a complicated place. It’s still one of the most popular tourist attractions in the Charleston area. They have a "Black History in America" exhibit. They have Gullah culture presentations. They are trying to tell the full story.
But they still host weddings.
That’s the core of the tension. Can a place of historical trauma ever truly be a "neutral" venue for a party? For Blake and Ryan, the answer was a hard no. They’ve spent the last decade trying to distance themselves from those 2012 photos, many of which have been scrubbed from the major wedding platforms.
Key takeaways from the controversy
If you’re looking at this story and wondering what the "big picture" is, it’s basically about the end of the "aesthetic-only" era. You can’t just pick a place because it looks good in a 35mm film shot.
- Context is everything. A beautiful oak tree isn't just a tree if it’s on land with a dark history.
- Accountability matters. The couple's apology worked—as much as any celebrity apology can—because it was specific and admitted to "social conditioning" rather than making excuses.
- The industry changed. The ban by Pinterest and The Knot was a massive blow to the business model of Southern plantations, forcing them to pivot toward education or rebrand entirely.
So, when you see those "Notebook-style" wedding photos now, they come with a footnote. It’s a reminder that even the most polished celebrity moments are subject to the messy, complicated truth of history.
Actionable Insight: If you are planning a high-profile event or even just a personal celebration, do the "history check." Research the land, the venue's past, and what those "charming" buildings were actually used for. It saves you from a "giant mistake" that might haunt your photo albums for decades.