The Black Pope: What People Get Wrong About the Superior General of the Society of Jesus

The Black Pope: What People Get Wrong About the Superior General of the Society of Jesus

You might have heard the term "Black Pope" whispered in historical dramas or read about it in some dusty corner of the internet. It sounds like something out of a Dan Brown novel, doesn't it? But the reality of the Superior General of the Society of Jesus is actually way more interesting—and a lot less conspiratorial—than the movies suggest.

The title belongs to the leader of the Jesuits. That's it. No secret world domination plans. No underground bunkers. Just a guy leading about 14,000 priests and brothers across the globe.

Currently, that man is Arturo Sosa. He’s Venezuelan. He’s also the first non-European to hold the post, which was a pretty massive deal when he was elected back in 2016. If you look at the history of the Catholic Church, things move slowly, but the election of Sosa signaled a shift toward the "Global South," much like the election of Pope Francis himself.

Wait, why "Black Pope" then?

It’s actually about the clothes. While the Pope wears white, the Superior General of the Society of Jesus wears a simple black cassock. Historically, because the Jesuits held so much intellectual and political influence, people joked (or complained) that the man in black was just as powerful as the man in white. The name stuck. It’s a nickname born out of a mix of respect and, frankly, a healthy dose of 16th-century suspicion.

How Do You Even Get the Job?

The process of choosing a Superior General of the Society of Jesus is unlike any corporate hiring process or political election you’ve ever seen. It’s intense. Honestly, it’s kind of exhausting just reading about it. When a vacancy occurs—usually through death or, more recently, resignation—delegates from all over the world head to Rome for what’s called a General Congregation.

They don't just walk in and vote.

First, there’s the murmuratio. It lasts four days. During this time, the delegates engage in one-on-one conversations. No campaigning. No speeches. No "Vote for Arturo" stickers. You just talk. You ask others who they think has the stamina, the spiritual depth, and the administrative chops to run a global organization that manages everything from prestigious universities like Georgetown to refugee camps in war zones. It is a quiet, deliberate process of vetting.

Then comes the vote. It’s done by secret ballot. Once someone gets a simple majority, they don't go out to a balcony to wave. They have to notify the Pope first. It’s a sign of the unique "fourth vow" Jesuits take—a vow of special obedience to the Pope regarding missions.

💡 You might also like: Why Every Mom and Daughter Photo You Take Actually Matters

The Power and the Pressure

What does a Superior General actually do all day? It’s basically like being the CEO of a massive, decentralized non-profit, but with a spiritual twist. They oversee "provinces." These are geographical chunks of the world.

Think about the scale here. The Jesuit network includes:

  • Over 800 schools and universities.
  • The Jesuit Refugee Service (JRS), which operates in dozens of countries.
  • Scientific research out of the Vatican Observatory.
  • Social justice ministries in some of the most dangerous places on earth.

Arturo Sosa has to balance these priorities. He has to decide where to send resources when a province in Africa is growing rapidly while one in Europe is shrinking. He has to maintain the Jesuit "brand"—which has always been about being at the frontiers of culture and science—while staying true to the spiritual exercises of St. Ignatius of Loyola.

Ignatius was the founder. He was a soldier-turned-mystic who lived in the 1500s. He didn't want the Jesuits to be monks hidden away in a choir. He wanted them "in the world." That’s why the Superior General of the Society of Jesus is often someone who is comfortable talking to heads of state one hour and visiting a homeless shelter the next.

The Adolfo Nicolás and Peter Hans Kolvenbach Era

Before Sosa, we had Adolfo Nicolás. He was often called "the Wise Man of the East" because he spent so much of his life in Japan. He brought this very Zen, meditative approach to the office. He was the one who really pushed the idea that Jesuits shouldn't just provide answers; they should ask better questions.

Before him was Peter Hans Kolvenbach. He’s the guy who had to steady the ship after some really turbulent years in the 1970s and 80s. Back then, the relationship between the Jesuits and the Vatican got... tense. Let's just say Pope John Paul II wasn't always thrilled with how political some Jesuits were becoming in Latin America with Liberation Theology.

Kolvenbach was a linguist and a diplomat. He knew how to bridge gaps. He served for 24 years. Think about that. Most CEOs burn out in five. He stayed for nearly a quarter-century, navigating the internal politics of the Church and the external pressures of a rapidly changing world.

Why the "Life Term" Is Changing

Historically, being the Superior General of the Society of Jesus was a "life sentence." You did it until you died. But that changed with Father Pedro Arrupe in the 80s, who suffered a stroke.

📖 Related: Sport watch water resist explained: why 50 meters doesn't mean you can dive

Since then, there’s been a move toward "resignation for health or age." It makes sense. The world is too fast now. You can't lead a global organization at 90 years old with the same energy required to handle the complexities of modern social media, global migration, and secularization.

Modern Challenges for the Office

The Superior General today isn't just fighting old theological battles. They are dealing with:

  1. The Clerical Abuse Crisis: A legacy of pain that requires transparency and massive structural changes within the order.
  2. Declining Numbers in the West: How do you keep a university "Jesuit" when there are fewer Jesuits to staff it?
  3. Climate Change: Following the lead of Pope Francis's Laudato Si’, the Jesuits have made "care for our common home" a central pillar of their mission.

It’s a lot for one person. Sosa often speaks about "collaboration with laity." Basically, he knows the Jesuits can't do it alone anymore. They need laypeople—regular folks who aren't priests—to take the lead in their institutions.

The Relationship with the "White Pope"

Here is a weird twist of history: for the first time ever, the Pope is a Jesuit.

When Jorge Mario Bergoglio became Pope Francis, it created a unique dynamic. The Superior General of the Society of Jesus is technically a subject of the Pope, but now his "boss" is one of his own guys. You’d think this would make things easier, right?

In some ways, yes. They speak the same language. They both value "discernment." But it also puts the Jesuits under a microscope. Every move Sosa makes is parsed for clues about what Francis is thinking. Every time the Jesuits take a stand on an issue like migration or the environment, critics of the Pope use it as ammunition. It’s a delicate dance.

Practical Realities of the Role

If you visited the Jesuit headquarters (the Borgo Santo Spirito) in Rome, you wouldn't find a palace. It’s pretty functional. The Superior General lives in a community with other Jesuits. They eat together. They pray together.

There is a sense of "poverty" that is supposed to be maintained, even if the person in the office is managing a multi-billion dollar network of assets. That tension is always there. How do you remain a "poor servant" while running Georgetown?

👉 See also: Pink White Nail Studio Secrets and Why Your Manicure Isn't Lasting

It’s the Superior General’s job to make sure the soul of the organization doesn't get lost in the spreadsheets.

Real-World Impact: More Than Just Titles

When the Superior General issues a "Universal Apostolic Preference," the world feels it. A few years ago, the Society of Jesus set four goals for the next decade:

  • Showing the way to God through discernment.
  • Walking with the excluded (the poor, the vulnerable).
  • Journeying with youth.
  • Caring for the environment.

These aren't just nice-sounding bullet points. They dictate where funding goes. They determine which missions stay open and which ones close. If you’re a student at a Jesuit high school in Chicago or a farmer in a Jesuit-led cooperative in India, the decisions made by the Superior General in Rome eventually trickle down to your daily life.

Actionable Insights for Understanding the Role

If you want to truly grasp the influence of the Superior General of the Society of Jesus, don't look at the conspiracy theories. Look at the ground-level work.

Watch the "State of the Society" addresses. Arturo Sosa is quite active on social media and through the Jesuit communications office. He often releases videos explaining the Order's stance on global issues. It's a great way to see the "Black Pope" in action without the filter of Dan Brown-esque mystery.

Look into the "Spiritual Exercises." To understand why the leader of the Jesuits makes certain decisions, you have to understand the logic they use. It’s called "Ignatian Discernment." It’s a specific way of weighing pros and cons based on spiritual "movements" rather than just a bottom line.

Follow the Jesuit Refugee Service. This is often the "canary in the coal mine" for Jesuit priorities. Where the JRS is active, you’ll find the Superior General’s heart. It’s the most direct expression of their current mission to be at the "margins."

The Superior General of the Society of Jesus isn't a shadow ruler of the world. He's a man trying to steer an ancient ship through very choppy modern waters. He's a CEO with a vow of poverty and a spiritual leader with a global administrative nightmare. It's a role defined by paradox, and that’s exactly what makes it fascinating.

To dig deeper into how this leadership affects global education and social policy, checking the official Jesuit Global website or reading the "Decrees of the 36th General Congregation" provides the actual framework these leaders use to govern. It’s far more revealing than any "secret history" you'll find elsewhere.