If you’ve ever driven through the rolling hills of Morris County, you’ve definitely seen it. That massive, looming structure sitting right at the corner of Main and Hilltop. It looks like it belongs in a history textbook, and honestly, it basically is one.
The Black Horse Tavern in Mendham is one of those places people talk about with a weird mix of reverence and local gossip. It’s been there since 1742. That’s before the United States was even a thing. But here’s the kicker: most people think it’s just one big restaurant. It’s actually two distinct vibes—the Tavern and the Pub—and they aren't interchangeable.
The 1742 Myth and the Real History
You’ll hear locals swear that George Washington slept there. While the "George Washington slept here" trope is the oldest cliché in New Jersey history, the Black Horse actually has the receipts to prove its colonial importance. It started as a stagecoach stop. Imagine being a traveler in the mid-1700s, bruised and dusty after a day on a bumpy carriage from Newark. This was your sanctuary.
The building itself was originally the farmhouse of Ebenezer Byram, one of the town’s founding fathers. Legend has it—and this is a fun bit of trivia to drop at dinner—that the town name "Mendham" came from Byram’s catchphrase. When people brought him broken stagecoaches to fix, he’d say, "I’ll mend 'em." Whether that’s 100% historically verified or just a great local yarn, the name stuck.
The Tavern vs. The Pub: Know Your Lane
This is where the confusion usually starts. People call the whole complex "The Black Horse," but you’ve gotta know where you’re going.
- The Pub: This used to be the horse stables. No, seriously. You’re literally eating where the stagecoach horses used to sleep. It’s rustic, loud, and family-friendly. It’s where you go after a soccer game or for a casual beer.
- The Tavern: This is the more formal side. It’s currently used more for private events and "higher-end" dining. If you show up in gym shorts to the Tavern side, you’re gonna feel a bit out of place.
Why Everyone Is Talking About the Renovation
In early 2024, the place went dark. It was a huge deal in Mendham. The 40North Restaurant Group, which owns a bunch of spots like Piattino and Office Tavern Grill, decided the old girl needed a facelift.
They didn't just paint the walls. We’re talking a multimillion-dollar overhaul. They doubled the size of the kitchen—which, if you’ve ever worked in a 280-year-old building, you know was probably cramped and terrifying. They updated the dining room to feel "fresh" but kept the fireplaces and the dark wood. It reopened in early 2025 (after a small fire during construction almost gave everyone a heart attack), and the "new" Black Horse is a weirdly perfect blend of 18th-century charm and 21st-century comfort.
The Secret Burger You Need to Order
Okay, let’s talk food. The menu is "Modern American," which is a fancy way of saying "upscale comfort food."
👉 See also: Acura ZDX Type S: What Most People Get Wrong
There is this thing called the 1742 Burger. It’s not your average Five Guys patty. It’s a proprietary blend of meat—prime short rib, sirloin, flat iron, and chuck. It’s topped with Brie, sautéed onions, applewood bacon, and a lemon aioli. It’s $29. Yeah, you read that right. Nearly thirty bucks for a burger. Is it worth it? Honestly, if you’re a burger nerd, yes. If you just want a snack, stick to the regular Pub Burger.
The menu also leans heavily on local farms. We’re talking about a kitchen that uses about ten different farms within a five-mile radius. That’s real farm-to-table, not the fake kind you see in big cities.
- French Onion Soup: It’s a classic for a reason. Gooey, salty, and perfect for a New Jersey winter.
- Prime Rib Panini: This is a sleeper hit. Most people go for the fish and chips, but the prime rib is where it's at.
- The Raw Bar: Surprisingly good for a place so far from the ocean.
The Controversies: It’s Not All Colonial Sunshine
You can't have a 300-year-old landmark without some drama. Since 40North took over, some old-school locals have been... vocal.
You’ll find Reddit threads where people complain that it’s become "too much of a chain" or that the prices have hiked while the portions stayed the same. Some people miss the "grittier" version of the old stable-turned-pub. There’s also the "Birthday Schtick." If you go there on your birthday, the servers do a whole loud performance that is designed to embarrass you. Some people love the energy; others want to crawl under the table.
But that’s the reality of a town institution. Everyone feels like they own a little piece of it, so any change feels personal.
Is It Actually Haunted?
You can't talk about the Black Horse Tavern in Mendham without the ghost stories.
Staff members over the decades have reported "cold spots" and the sound of footsteps in the Tavern when nobody is there. Considering the building survived the Revolutionary War and has seen thousands of travelers pass through, it’d be weirder if it weren't haunted. Whether you believe in ghosts or just think it’s the old pipes settling, it adds to the vibe when you’re sitting by the fireplace with a glass of scotch.
✨ Don't miss: How Much is a Pink Drink from Starbucks? The Real Price You’ll Pay Right Now
Practical Logistics for Your Visit
If you’re planning a trip, don’t just wing it on a Saturday night.
- Reservations: Use Resy. Don't just show up at 7:00 PM on a weekend and expect a table. This place gets packed with locals.
- Parking: It’s a bit of a nightmare. There is a small lot, but you often end up parking on the street or in the back.
- Atmosphere: It’s cozy. Like, "wear your favorite sweater and talk about your day" cozy.
- Live Music: Usually happening on Friday and Saturday nights. It makes the Pub side pretty loud, so if you want a quiet heart-to-heart, request a table further back.
Actionable Steps for the Best Experience
To truly get the most out of a visit to the Black Horse, you shouldn't just treat it like another restaurant.
- Go for the History first: Walk through the Tavern side even if you're eating at the Pub. Look at the architecture. The beams are original.
- Check the Seasonal Specials: Because they work with local Mendham farms, the menu shifts. If there is a seasonal vegetable side, get it.
- Try the "Secret" Menu: Ask about any off-menu specials. Since the renovation, the kitchen has been experimenting with rotisserie items that don't always make the printed list.
- Skip the Peak Hour: If you want to actually appreciate the 1742 vibes, go for a late lunch or an early Sunday dinner. You get the fireplace without the three-deep crowd at the bar.
The Black Horse Tavern in Mendham isn't perfect—no place that’s been around for 280 years is—but it’s a living piece of New Jersey history that you can actually touch, taste, and experience. It’s less of a museum and more of a community living room with really good bourbon.