Let’s be real for a second. Most people’s first experience with back-door play is... well, it’s usually a bit of a disaster. It’s either a spur-of-the-moment decision fueled by too many drinks or a rushed attempt to mimic something seen on a screen. Neither of those is actually the best way to have anal sex. Honestly, if you go into it expecting it to just "work" like vaginal sex, you’re probably going to have a bad time.
The anatomy is different. The physics are different. Even the psychology is a whole different ballgame.
The rectum isn’t a self-lubricating organ. That’s the first thing you have to wrap your head around. It’s a muscle—a very strong, dual-sphincter system designed specifically to keep things in, not let things in. To make it enjoyable, you’re basically asking those muscles to do the exact opposite of their primary job. That takes more than just a "go for it" attitude. It takes physiological understanding.
Why prep is actually 90% of the work
You can't just skip to the main event. If you do, you’re risking micro-tears, or at the very least, a lot of discomfort that’ll make you never want to try it again.
Start with the external stuff. The area around the anus is packed with nerve endings—roughly the same density as the fingertips. You’ve got the external sphincter, which is under your conscious control, and the internal sphincter, which is autonomic. You can't just "will" the internal one to open. It has to be coaxed.
The "Sensation Overlap" trick
One thing many people miss is that the nerves in the pelvic floor are interconnected. Using a vibrator on the clitoris or the perineum while focusing on the anus helps the brain process the new sensations as "pleasurable" rather than "intrusive." It’s basically a distraction technique for your nervous system.
It helps to think of the anus like a shy door. You don't kick it down. You knock, you wait, you offer a gift (usually lube), and you wait for it to open on its own. If you feel resistance, that is your body saying "not yet." Listen to it. Pain is not a prerequisite for anal. In fact, if it hurts, you’re doing it wrong. Period.
✨ Don't miss: Why Meditation for Emotional Numbness is Harder (and Better) Than You Think
Selecting the right "equipment" (and I mean lube)
If you take nothing else away from this, remember: use way more lube than you think you need. Then add more.
Since the rectum absorbs moisture quickly, water-based lubes tend to dry out fast. That leads to friction. Friction leads to tears. Most experts, including those at the International Society for Sexual Medicine, suggest silicone-based lubricants for anal play because they stay slippery much longer. However, there's a catch. If you’re using silicone toys, silicone lube will degrade them.
- Silicone Lube: Great for skin-to-skin or with glass/metal toys. Lasts forever.
- Water-Based Lube: Necessary for silicone toys. You just have to reapply it every five minutes.
- Hybrid Lubes: A decent middle ground, though sometimes they have additives like glycerin that can irritate sensitive tissues.
Avoid anything with "numbing" agents. Seriously. Lidocaine or benzocaine might seem like a shortcut to the best way to have anal sex, but they’re actually dangerous. Pain is your body’s only way of telling you that tissue is being damaged. If you numb the area, you might cause a tear or a fissure without even realizing it until the chemicals wear off. That's a recipe for a very long, very uncomfortable recovery.
The mechanical reality of the internal sphincter
When you’re finally ready to try penetration, the "pushing" method is the secret weapon.
It sounds counterintuitive, but when something is entering, you should gently push out, as if you’re having a bowel movement. This action naturally relaxes the external sphincter. It’s a physiological reflex. If you pull away or tense up, the muscle constricts.
Position matters more than you think
Forget the "standard" positions for a minute. The best way to have anal sex for beginners is often "doggy style" or lying on your stomach with a pillow under your hips. Why? Because these positions allow for the straightest "shot" into the rectum.
🔗 Read more: Images of Grief and Loss: Why We Look When It Hurts
The rectum isn't a straight tube; it has a slight curve called the sacral flexure. If you’re lying flat on your back, the angle can be awkward and cause the penis or toy to poke against the rectal wall rather than sliding past it.
- Side-lying (Spooning): Great for intimacy and allows for easy reaching to stimulate other areas.
- On Top: This gives the receiving partner total control over depth and speed. This is arguably the safest way to start because you can stop the millisecond it feels "off."
The hygiene elephant in the room
Let’s talk about the "mess." It’s the biggest barrier for most people.
Look, it’s the anuses's primary job to handle waste. There is always a non-zero chance that things won't stay pristine. Accepting this is part of the process. However, you can minimize the risk. Using an enema (a simple bulb with lukewarm water) can clear out the lower rectum. Just don’t overdo it. The rectum has a delicate microbiome, and flushing it out too often or using harsh soaps can lead to irritation or even infection.
A high-fiber diet also helps. Keeping things "bulkier" means less residue left behind on the rectal walls. Simple biology, really.
Understanding the "A-Spot" and the Prostate
For those with a prostate, anal sex isn't just about the sensation of fullness; it’s about direct internal stimulation. The prostate is located about two to three inches inside, toward the front (the "belly button side").
Hitting this spot can lead to what some call "full-body" orgasms. It’s a different kind of peak than what you get from the penis alone. For people without a prostate, the "A-spot" (anterior fornix erogenous zone) can be stimulated through the vaginal wall, but anal penetration offers a different kind of pressure against the back of the uterus and the pelvic floor that many find intensely pleasurable once the initial relaxation is achieved.
💡 You might also like: Why the Ginger and Lemon Shot Actually Works (And Why It Might Not)
Communication is the actual "Best Way"
You can have all the lube in the world, but if you aren't talking, it’s going to suck. Use a "stoplight" system.
- Green: Everything is great, keep going or speed up.
- Yellow: It’s okay, but let’s stay at this speed or depth for a bit.
- Red: Stop immediately.
This takes the pressure off. Knowing you can stop at any second makes it much easier for the brain—and therefore the muscles—to relax.
Actionable steps for your next attempt
If you're ready to move past the theory, here is how you actually execute this safely.
- Don't start with the main event. Use a finger first. Use two. Get used to the feeling of something being there without the pressure of "performance."
- Lube the toy/penis AND the opening. Coating both surfaces creates a "hydroplaning" effect that reduces friction to almost zero.
- The 10-second rule. When the tip first enters, just stop. Wait 10 seconds. Let the sphincters adjust to the new object. Don't start thrusting immediately.
- Breathe into your pelvis. Deep diaphragmatic breaths physically force the pelvic floor to drop and relax. Short, shallow breaths (the kind we take when nervous) cause the muscles to tighten.
- Clean up right. Use a mild, unscented soap for the outside afterward. If you used a condom (which you should, especially for STI protection and easier cleanup), dispose of it properly and check for any irritation.
The goal isn't just to "get it in." The goal is for both people to actually enjoy the experience. If it takes three sessions of just "practicing" with fingers before full penetration happens, that's fine. In fact, that's usually how the most successful long-term experiences start.
Focus on the relaxation of the internal sphincter through slow, steady pressure and consistent communication. Ensure you have a high-quality silicone-based lubricant on hand, and never skip the external "warm-up" phase. By prioritizing the physiological needs of the rectum over the psychological rush to finish, you transform the experience from something stressful into something deeply pleasurable.