Look, let’s be real. If you grew up in a certain kind of household or spent any time in a church basement, you know the Herdmans. They’re the kids who smoked cigars, hit each other, and essentially high-jacked the annual nativity play to the horror of everyone in town. For years, people have been trying to figure out the best christmas pageant ever how to watch because the 1983 TV movie was weirdly hard to find for a while. But things changed in 2024 when Dallas Jenkins—the guy behind The Chosen—finally brought a big-budget version to the big screen.
The good news? You don’t have to hunt down a dusty VHS anymore. Whether you’re looking for the brand-new Lionsgate hit starring Judy Greer or you’re feeling nostalgic for the old-school 80s classic, there are a few very specific ways to get your fix.
Where Can You Actually Stream the 2024 Movie?
If you missed the theatrical run where it pulled in over $40 million (which is honestly impressive for a mid-budget holiday flick), you've got options. As of early 2026, the 2024 version of The Best Christmas Pageant Ever has settled into its home on digital platforms.
You can’t just flip on Netflix and expect it to be there. At least, not in the U.S. right now. Licensing for these things is always a bit of a mess. Currently, the most reliable way to watch the new movie is through Digital VOD. This means you’re looking at:
- Amazon Prime Video: You can rent it for a few bucks or buy it to keep in your digital locker.
- Apple TV (iTunes): Usually priced around $3.99 for a rental.
- Fandango at Home (formerly Vudu): Great if you like keeping all your digital movies in one place.
- Google Play / YouTube Movies: Accessible on basically any device.
Interestingly, despite some early rumors that it would land exclusively on Peacock or Netflix, the movie has primarily stayed in the "buy or rent" category for a long stretch. However, for those with a STARZ subscription, you’re in luck. The movie has been known to rotate through their lineup, making it one of the few places you can watch it "for free" if you're already paying for the service.
💡 You might also like: Disney Tim Burton's The Nightmare Before Christmas Light Trail: Is the New York Botanical Garden Event Worth Your Money?
The Old School 1983 Classic: A Different Story
Some of us just want to see Loretta Swit as Grace Bradley. I get it. The 1983 television movie is a different beast entirely. It’s shorter—only about 48 minutes—and has that specific, grainy 80s warmth that the new one can't quite replicate.
Tracking this one down is trickier. It’s not on the major streamers like Disney+ or Max. Honestly, your best bet for the 1983 version is often YouTube. Every Christmas, a few "unofficial" uploads tend to pop up, though they get taken down pretty regularly. If you want a legal, stable version, you might actually have to go physical. Lionsgate and other distributors released it on DVD years ago, and it’s still floating around on Amazon and eBay.
Don't overlook your local library either. Many library systems carry the DVD, and if they use the Hoopla or Kanopy apps, you might even be able to stream the 1983 version for free using your library card. It's a total pro tip that most people forget about while they're busy scrolling through Netflix.
Why People Are Still Obsessed With the Herdmans
The story hasn't really changed since Barbara Robinson wrote the book in 1972. It’s still about the "worst kids in the world" taking over the church pageant and accidentally teaching a bunch of judgmental townspeople what Christmas is actually about.
📖 Related: Diego Klattenhoff Movies and TV Shows: Why He’s the Best Actor You Keep Forgetting You Know
What’s cool about the 2024 film is that it actually stays pretty faithful. It doesn't try to "modernize" it to the point of ruining it. You still have Gladys screaming "Hey! Unto you a child is born!" like she’s starting a fight. It works because it's messy. Most holiday movies are too polished, too perfect. This one is about kids who smell like woodsmoke and don't know who Herod is.
Physical Media Isn't Dead Yet
If you’re a "buy once, own forever" type of person, you should know that the 2024 version hit Blu-ray and DVD in late 2025. This is actually the version I’d recommend if you're a fan of the book.
The Blu-ray comes with a bunch of extras that the streaming versions don't always include. We’re talking:
- Director’s Diary: Dallas Jenkins talking about the decades-long journey to get this made.
- Deleted Scenes: Some extra Herdman chaos that didn't make the theatrical cut.
- The "Least of These" Featurette: A look at the heart of the story.
Quick Tips for the Best Viewing Experience
If you’re planning a family movie night, check the ratings. Both the new version and the 1983 special are rated PG. They’re safe for kids, but the Herdmans do behave badly (that's the point). There’s some mild talk of smoking and some "light" bullying, but it’s all handled with a lot of heart.
👉 See also: Did Mac Miller Like Donald Trump? What Really Happened Between the Rapper and the President
One final thing: If you are trying to find best christmas pageant ever how to watch during the actual month of December, keep an eye on the UPtv or Hallmark schedules. They often license these family-friendly titles for holiday marathons. If you still have a cable box or a live TV streamer like Philo or Fubo, you might be able to DVR it and skip the rental fee entirely.
The best way to see the film right now is to head over to Amazon or Apple TV and grab the digital version. It’s fast, the quality is 4K (for the 2024 version), and you don’t have to worry about it disappearing from a subscription service next month when the licensing deal expires.
If you want to dive deeper into the world of the Herdmans, your next move should be checking your local library's digital catalog on Hoopla to see if they have the original 1983 special or even the audiobook—it's a great way to compare the different versions of the story while you wait for the movie to download.