Finding a place to crash in Midtown Manhattan usually involves a trade-off. You either pay a fortune for a room the size of a walk-in closet, or you end up in a sterile glass tower that feels like an upscale office building. But The Benjamin Royal Sonesta New York—known to most locals and repeat visitors simply as The Benjamin—occupies a weirdly perfect middle ground. It’s a 1927 Neo-Romanesque skyscraper that actually remembers what New York used to feel like before every lobby started smelling like synthetic white tea.
The building was originally designed by Emery Roth. If that name sounds familiar, it's because he basically defined the skyline of the Upper West Side and the Beresford. He had this knack for making buildings feel massive yet intimate. Honestly, walking into The Benjamin today, you still get that vibe. It’s located at the corner of 50th and Lexington, which sounds like it would be a chaotic nightmare of honking taxis and tourists. Surprisingly, it’s not. It feels like a residential pocket tucked away in the middle of the corporate grind.
Most people book this place because they want to be near Rockefeller Center or Grand Central, but they stay because of the Sleep Program. Yeah, a hotel with a dedicated "Sleep Concierge" sounds a bit like a marketing gimmick. I thought so too. But when you realize they have a pillow menu with ten different options—ranging from buckwheat to "anti-snore" pillows—you start to get why people who travel for a living obsess over this place. It’s quiet. In a city that literally never shuts up, that’s the ultimate luxury.
What makes The Benjamin Royal Sonesta New York stand out in a crowded market?
It’s the suites.
Most New York hotel rooms are designed for people who plan on spending exactly zero minutes in their room. The Benjamin is different. Because it was originally designed as an apartment hotel (The Beverly), the layouts are actually functional. Many rooms come with kitchenettes. If you’ve ever tried to keep a bottle of wine cold or heat up leftovers in a standard hotel, you know how much of a game-changer a real sink and a microwave can be.
The terrace suites are the real flex here. Having a private outdoor space in Midtown is like finding a unicorn. You can sit out there at 11:00 PM with a view of the Chrysler Building and feel like you actually own a piece of the city. It’s a far cry from the cramped quarters of the newer "lifestyle" hotels where you can't even open your suitcase on the floor.
Then there’s the history. This isn't just another renovated box. The architecture is steeped in that 1920s ambition. It was one of the first truly tall residential buildings in the city. When you look at the terracotta detailing on the exterior, you’re looking at craftsmanship that just doesn't happen anymore. Modern developers couldn't afford to build this today.
📖 Related: TSA PreCheck Look Up Number: What Most People Get Wrong
The Sleep Program is actually legit
We need to talk about the pillows.
Most hotels give you "soft" or "firm." At The Benjamin, they treat sleep like a medical discipline. The Sleep Concierge, a concept pioneered by sleep medicine expert Dr. Rebecca Robbins, is there to help you actually get a decent night's rest after a red-eye.
- The Pillow Menu: They have 10 varieties. The "Cloud" is basically a marshmallow. The "Swedish Massage" is for people who need neck support.
- Sleep Masks and Earplugs: Standard, but high quality.
- Work-Down Service: They’ll help you transition from work mode to sleep mode with things like aromatherapy.
- Noise Machines: Because even with thick windows, NYC is loud.
It sounds extra. It probably is. But if you’re a business traveler with a 9:00 AM meeting on Wall Street, having a pillow that doesn't feel like a bag of rocks is worth the premium.
The neighborhood vibe: 50th and Lex
Living (or staying) on Lexington Avenue is a specific experience. You’re steps away from the 6 train, which gets you anywhere. You’re three blocks from St. Patrick’s Cathedral. You’re close enough to Fifth Avenue to go shopping, but far enough away that you don't feel like you're trapped in a human stampede.
I’ve found that people who choose The Benjamin are usually "pro" travelers. They aren't looking for the neon lights of Times Square. They want the convenience of Midtown without the headaches. You can walk to the United Nations. You can walk to MoMA. You can walk to the Summit at One Vanderbilt.
Food-wise, you’re in a bit of a sweet spot. While the hotel’s own dining scene has shifted over the years—moving from the high-profile Geoffrey Zakarian era to more flexible options—the surrounding blocks are packed. You have everything from the old-school charm of P.J. Clarke’s to the high-end sushi spots hidden in the basements of nearby skyscrapers.
👉 See also: Historic Sears Building LA: What Really Happened to This Boyle Heights Icon
Practicalities: What you need to know before booking
Let's be real for a second. This is an older building. While Sonesta has done a solid job keeping things fresh, you have to expect the quirks of pre-war architecture. The elevators can be a bit slow during peak checkout times. The hallways are narrower than what you'd find at a Marriott Marquis.
But those quirks are exactly why people like it.
The rooms are generally larger than the NYC average. A "Deluxe Studio" here is often 350 to 400 square feet. In a city where 220 square feet is considered "spacious," that extra breathing room matters. If you’re traveling with kids, the one-bedroom suites are a lifesaver. They have pull-out sofas that are actually comfortable, and the separate living area means you aren't forced to go to bed at 8:30 PM just because the kids are asleep.
The Sonesta transition and what’s changed
When Sonesta took over the management of The Benjamin, some regulars were worried. It’s always a risk when a historic boutique property gets folded into a larger corporate portfolio. However, the transition to The Benjamin Royal Sonesta New York has mostly been about upgrading the backend—better booking systems, loyalty points (Sonesta Travel Pass), and more consistent service standards.
The "Royal" designation in Sonesta’s world is reserved for their upper-upscale properties. They know they have a jewel here. They haven't tried to turn it into a cookie-cutter hotel. The lobby still feels grand. The staff still remembers your name if you stay there twice.
One thing that hasn't changed is the focus on the "residential" feel. They want you to feel like you live in New York, not like you're just passing through. That's why the kitchenettes remained. That's why the desk spaces in the rooms are actually big enough to work at. It’s a hotel for adults.
✨ Don't miss: Why the Nutty Putty Cave Seal is Permanent: What Most People Get Wrong About the John Jones Site
Is it worth the price tag?
NYC hotel prices are currently insane. There’s no sugar-coating it. You’re going to pay a premium to stay anywhere in Manhattan.
The Benjamin usually sits in that $350–$600 a night range, depending on the season and whether there’s a massive convention in town. Is it worth it? If you value sleep and space, yes. If you’re looking for a rooftop pool and a DJ in the lobby, look elsewhere. This isn’t a "scene" hotel. It’s a "recovery" hotel. It’s where you go to escape the city after spending all day in it.
The verdict on The Benjamin Royal Sonesta New York
Honestly, The Benjamin is a survivor. It has outlasted dozens of trendy boutique hotels that opened with a lot of hype and closed five years later. It stays relevant because it does the basics exceptionally well: great beds, large rooms, and a location that makes sense.
It’s not trying to be the coolest hotel in the world. It’s trying to be the most comfortable one in New York.
If you're planning a trip, keep an eye on their seasonal offers. They often have packages that include parking—which is a nightmare in Midtown—or credits for local dining.
Your next steps for a better stay
- Request a high floor: The street noise at 50th and Lex isn't terrible, but NYC is NYC. The higher you are, the more that Sleep Program actually works.
- Check the suite layouts: Not all one-bedrooms are created equal. Some have better views of the city skyline, while others are tucked into the back for maximum quiet.
- Use the Sleep Concierge: Don't be shy about asking for a different pillow. You’re paying for the service; use it.
- Explore the "Secret" Parks: There are several small "pocket parks" within two blocks of the hotel, like Greenacre Park on 51st Street, which has a massive waterfall that drowns out all city noise. It’s the perfect spot for a morning coffee.
- Book Direct: Sometimes the Sonesta website has "member only" rates that beat the big travel sites, and you're more likely to get a room upgrade if you're in their loyalty program.
Stay here if you want to feel like a New Yorker with a very expensive apartment and a very good night's sleep. Skip it if you're looking for a party. The Benjamin is for the grown-ups.