Cinco de Mayo isn't Mexican Independence Day. It just isn't. Most people in the States treat it like a tequila-soaked version of St. Patrick’s Day, but the actual history behind the Battle of Puebla is way more intense and honestly kind of a miracle. We’re talking about a ragtag group of under-equipped Mexican liberals taking on the most feared professional army on the planet in 1862.
Napoleon III—the nephew of the Napoleon—wanted an empire in the Americas. He saw the U.S. was busy tearing itself apart in the Civil War and figured it was the perfect time to swoop in, collect some debts, and install a puppet monarch. He sent the French Foreign Legion and elite Zouave troops to march on Mexico City. They were basically the 19th-century version of the Avengers. They hadn't lost a major battle in decades. Then they got to Puebla.
Why the French were even there
Mexico was broke. After years of internal conflict, the Reform War had left the treasury empty. President Benito Juárez decided to hit "pause" on paying back foreign debts to European powers for two years. England and Spain were annoyed, but they eventually talked it out and left. France? Not so much. Napoleon III had grander plans. He wanted "Latin America" to be a thing—a French-influenced Catholic bulwark against the expanding Protestant United States.
The French landed at Veracruz and started marching inland. They were arrogant. Charles de Lorencez, the French commander, famously wrote back to his minister of war saying that with 6,000 soldiers, he was already the master of Mexico. He genuinely believed the locals would welcome the French with open arms and flower petals. He was dead wrong.
The chaos at the forts
Puebla is a high-altitude city protected by two main hills: Loreto and Guadalupe. General Ignacio Zaragoza, the 33-year-old leader of the Mexican forces, knew he couldn't win a standard open-field battle. He had about 4,000 men. Some were regular army, but many were Zapotec Indians and local peasants armed with machetes and outdated muskets from the Napoleonic Wars.
✨ Don't miss: Hotel Gigi San Diego: Why This New Gaslamp Spot Is Actually Different
On May 5, 1862, Lorencez did something incredibly stupid. He launched a direct, uphill frontal assault on the Mexican positions. He didn't use his artillery to soften them up first. He just sent his guys into the mud. It had started to rain, making the slopes of the hills slippery and miserable.
The turning point
The French tried three times to take those hills. Each time, they were pushed back. During the final retreat, Zaragoza ordered a counter-attack. This is where the legend of the Mexican cavalry comes in. Colonel Porfirio Díaz—who would later become the long-term dictator of Mexico—led a charge that absolutely shattered the French flanks.
It wasn't just about the guns. It was about the terrain. The French were wearing heavy uniforms and carrying full packs, trying to climb a muddy hill while being shot at by people who were defending their actual homes. By the end of the day, the French had lost nearly 500 men. The Mexicans lost fewer than 100.
The big misconception: Did it end the war?
No. Not even close. This is the part people forget when they’re drinking margaritas. The Battle of Puebla was a morale booster, but it didn't stop the French invasion. Napoleon III was embarrassed. He sent 30,000 more troops the following year. Puebla eventually fell after a brutal two-month siege, and the French did take Mexico City. They installed Maximilian of Habsburg as the "Emperor of Mexico."
🔗 Read more: Wingate by Wyndham Columbia: What Most People Get Wrong
But the victory on the 5th of May mattered because it proved the French weren't invincible. It gave Juárez’s government-in-exile the legitimacy it needed to keep fighting a guerrilla war. It also prevented the French from helping the Confederacy in the American Civil War. If the French had smashed through Puebla in 1862, they might have reached the U.S. border and started supplying the South with weapons and resources. Historians like Justo Sierra have argued that the defense of Puebla was essentially a defense of the entire continent’s sovereignty.
Why Puebla looks the way it does now
If you go to Puebla today, you can actually walk the grounds of Fort Loreto and Fort Guadalupe. It’s a massive park area (Los Fuertes) with incredible views of the city and the Popocatépetl volcano. It’s not a "party" city on May 5th in the way people think. In Puebla, the day is solemn. There’s a massive military parade, a reenactment of the battle involving thousands of people, and a real sense of local pride.
The city itself is a UNESCO World Heritage site. You can see the bullet holes and the scars of the 1863 siege on some of the older buildings. It’s a place where history feels heavy and real, not like a marketing gimmick.
The U.S. Connection
So why do Americans celebrate it? During the 1960s and 70s, Chicano activists in the U.S. started using the Battle of Puebla as a symbol of resistance against oppression. It was a "David vs. Goliath" story that resonated with the civil rights movement. Over time, beer companies saw a golden opportunity to commercialize the date. By the 1980s, it had shifted from a political symbol of resistance to a general celebration of Mexican-American culture.
💡 You might also like: Finding Your Way: The Sky Harbor Airport Map Terminal 3 Breakdown
There’s a bit of irony there. A battle fought against European imperialism became a massive driver of American consumerism. But hey, that's history for you.
How to actually honor the history
If you're interested in the real story, don't just settle for a taco special.
- Visit the Museo de la No Intervención: Located inside Fort Loreto, this museum houses the actual weapons, uniforms, and flags from the battle. It’s haunting to see how outclassed the Mexican equipment was compared to the French gear.
- Read Zaragoza’s telegrams: His message to the National Palace was short and legendary: "Las armas nacionales se han cubierto de gloria" (The national arms have covered themselves in glory).
- Look into the 1863 Siege: To understand the full scope, you have to look at what happened a year later. The resistance didn't end on May 5th; it just began there.
- Explore the tunnels: Puebla has a secret network of underground tunnels, some of which were used during the various battles for the city. They were only recently rediscovered and opened to the public.
The Battle of Puebla wasn't the end of a war, and it wasn't the birth of a nation. It was a moment where a group of people looked at the "best" army in the world and said, "Not today." It’s a story about terrain, bad weather, massive egos, and the sheer will of people who refuse to be colonized. That’s worth a lot more than a discount drink.
To get a true sense of the scale, your next step should be researching the "Zacapoaxtlas." These were the indigenous fighters from the Sierra Norte of Puebla who played a decisive role in the hand-to-hand combat at the forts. Understanding their contribution shifts the narrative from a standard military history to a story of grassroots national defense.